Saltar al contenido

Episode 131: Math + Aphasia: A Conversation with Tami Brancamp and Dave Brancamp

19 de agosto de 2025 · 57 min

Notas del episodio

In this episode you will discover:

  • Math IS Language - It's in Our Wheelhouse Math has syntax (order of operations), semantics (number meanings), and involves memory and executive function - all areas SLPs already assess and treat. If you can help with language, you have transferable skills for math therapy.
  • Start Simple with What You Have You don't need special materials or extensive math training. Use a deck of cards, dice, and real-life examples like restaurant receipts. Make numbers "friendly" (round $18.72 to $20) and let clients show you multiple ways to solve problems.
  • Address Your Own Math Anxiety First Most SLPs feel uncomfortable with math, but clients need this support for life participation (paying bills, calculating tips, telling time). Acknowledge your discomfort, start with basics you DO know, and remember - if you avoid it, you can't help your clients who want to work on it.

If you've ever felt your palms get sweaty when a client asks for help with numbers, this conversation is for you. Welcome to the Aphasia Access Aphasia Conversations Podcast. I'm Katie Strong, a faculty member at Central Michigan University where I lead the Strong Story Lab.

I'm today's host for an episode that might just change how you think about math anxiety - both your own and your clients'. We're featuring Tami Brancamp and Dave Brancamp, who are doing pioneering work at the intersection of aphasia and mathematics. Before you hit pause because you're having flashbacks to algebra class, stay with me! This research shows us that the language of math is exactly that - language - which puts it squarely in our wheelhouse as SLPs.

We'll explore how to support our clients with aphasia who are struggling with everyday math tasks like counting change, telling time, or balancing a checkbook. And yes, we'll tackle the elephant in the room: addressing our own math insecurities so we can show up confidently for our clients.

Let me tell you about our guests. Tami Brancamp is an associate professor at the University of Nevada, Reno School of Medicine and founder of the Aphasia Center of Nevada. Her research focuses on identity in aphasia and rehabilitating everyday math skills. Dave Brancamp spent over 15 years as a junior high math teacher and later became Director of Standards at the Nevada Department of Education. Together, they co-founded Aphasia + Math, where they're exploring how language and mathematics intersect for people with aphasia.

Okay now let's get this Aphasia + Math conversation started!

Katie Strong: Tami and Dave, welcome to the podcast. I'm so excited for you to be here today.

Dave Brancamp: Thank you.

Tami Brancamp: We are both super excited to have a chance to talk about things that are different, right?

Katie Strong: Right. I do have to say, I don't know if it was a rash, but I did get a little bit nervous coming into the conversation, because I think I may be one of those SLPs that feel a little bit uncomfortable with math.

Tami Brancamp: Well, this SLP also is uncomfortable with math, so we can be uncomfortable together. And we'll let the math dude guide us through some of the things.

Dave Brancamp: And it will be fun. By the time you're done, I want to see that smile that you have on your face.

Katie Strong: Well, let's jump in and have you share a little bit about how you came to researching aphasia and math.

Tami Brancamp: Well, I have loved working with people who have aphasia since the beginning of my graduate studies. And then probably, like most of us, there's a few clients who've really hit your heart. One of them, I don't recall her name, and that's okay, but she had a stroke, had aphasia. She had had great recover physically, and her language was quite good, some anomia. But she's a banker, and she could not process numbers, and she was angry. I'm a newbie, I didn't understand the emotional piece of stroke survivor, aphasia. can't do my job well. But she was angry, and I felt so helpless. I didn't know what to do to help her. You know, I could pull a workbook off the shelf or something, but it didn't feel right. You know, she could do calculations, but couldn't do her job. And I always felt so very, very helpless over the years.

And the other part that came to start looking at this was teaching in a speech pathology program, undergrad and grad. And in class, maybe we're doing an averaging or something to get a score. I'm not sure if we start talking math, and I would see these students, and their eyes would just like, pop up, like, "Oh my gosh, she's asking me to do math." And like, deer in the headlights. So I'm like, "What is this?" Every semester, I would do kind of an informal survey when we would do a little bit of math, and I say, "Okay, so how many of you don't do math? Raise your hand or are afraid of math?" And it would be at least two thirds to three quarters of the class every single semester, and I'm like, "Okay, there's something here." Like, if I'm afraid of math, how am I going to help my clients remediate that in an efficient way? Right? I'm going to avoid it. If I can, I'll go do other things that are important.

So those were, like, the two big things, and then happened to be married to a math dude. And I wondered why are we not combining our skill sets? Because I would come home and I would share with Dave. I'm like "Dave, the majority of my students are afraid to do math or uncomfortable doing math." And it's not complicated math. We're not talking quadratic equations or things I don't even know what they mean anymore. And we would talk about it a little bit, and we talk about math attitudes and perceptions and how we develop our math skills. And I'm like, "There's something here."But I was never taught, how do you remediate number processing? Calculations? right? But yet, I would have multiple clients say, "Hey, Tammy, I can't do numbers." "Yeah, how do I do this?" And there really wasn't anything the literature that told me how to do it. So, I would talk to Dave, and then, just over the years, I'm like, "Okay, we need to do something with this. We really do." And I don't know what that means, because I'm not most comfortable with math, it is not my passion. We're very opposite. I think I shared like, Dave has math and fun in the same language, and then in the same sentence, I'm like, "they don't go together in my brain." So we're very, very opposite. But you know, you can speak for yourself how you grew up and you had to learn how to embrace math, and having good teachers helped when we were younger, and having poor teachers or teachers with different attitudes also left a lasting impression. But when you think about it, whether it's, you know, cooking, driving, banking, living, going to grocery store, restaurants, everything we do all the time, it all involves numbers to some impact, you know, to some effect. And our folks with aphasia, again, not everybody, but the majority of them, will still have an impact with acalculia, difficulty processing numbers and calculating and transcoding, you know, saying, saying the numbers. So, we started to look at it.

I did have a had a gift of time with Audrey Holland. So that was my beautiful, like, for many of us, a mentor, you know, she had her three-pronged stool, like the different parts of aphasia. And Dave and I started dividing it up, like, what were the parts we thought involve, you know, aphasia and numbers. And we did think about the math and language math skills, making it fun, but also those influencing elements, like attitudes and perceptions. So, we started just like, "How do we look at this?" Because it's really overwhelming just from the beginning, you know, and just pulling that workbook off the shelf didn't do it for me. You're allowed to speak on that. (Laughter)

Dave Brancamp That's one of my passions, obviously, the whole math side. But pulling a workbook is an unfortunate because if someone starts to practice something wrong, they'll repeat that practice, and now it's very difficult to get them to correct a habit, basically that you've formed. And sometimes it's like that nails on a chalkboard? That's what it feels like to me when I hear it. I'm like, "Oh, don't do that." Because if they're doing it wrong, like, 20 times, 10 times, even then it performs a habit that's real hard for them to go, "Well, but I thought I got them all right."

Katie Strong: Yeah.

Dave Brancamp: Because I think we can all go back to math and you come up unless it was something really, really difficult in at least in our early years of math. We all came up with an answer. And that's how it feels on a worksheet that might have like just adding single digit numbers, if you make an error, you won't know until someone either corrects it or asks you, "How did you get there?" And to me, that's where it became more important. And then I had to learn how to do what do you call it? aphasia friendly language, you know? So, math folks usually speak in short sentences, so that helps. But we'll run a whole bunch of sentences together. If I give you the best example. I know we're going to talk a little bit about that math perception quiz, the difference between us on that question, I think it says "I would prefer to do an assignment in math rather than write an essay." I'm the person to give me that math assignment. 100%. Tammy is like, give me the essay!

Katie Strong: And I have to say I'm right there with Tammy.

Tami Brancamp I think so, as speech pathologists, we learned about the pedagogy of language and language development. We can analyze it. We can treat it. We can assess it. And then I talked to Dave, and he goes, "Well, there's this whole math I know there's a math pedagogy, and there's this whole developmental progression of how we learn math." But "Really, okay, well, I've never learned that, right?" "No, you learn this before you learn that." We lived it, we just weren't overtly taught it. Or how you know, if there's an error in a calculation, that means that there's some challenges in this part of your developmental math abilities. Like, "Huh, okay, well, that kind of sounds like language to me, a little bit." They do go together.

Katie Strong: Yeah, yeah. So, I love to maybe ask a little bit about this. As we've pretty clearly stated, many SLPs feel uncomfortable with math and their own math skills.

Tami Brancamp: Yeah.

Katie Strong: And we, probably many of us, have avoided it in our own education.

Tami Brancamp: Yeah.

Katie Strong: So I love this idea that there's the language of math, and I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about that and why it should fit right within our scope of practice as SLPs.

Tami Brancamp: A long time ago, I remember how many years ago I came across an article by Seron 2001 in Aphasiology. And he or she, I actually don't know, stated that math should be part of the SLPs practice. I started looking at 20 years later, and it still wasn't (a part of our practice). So, something's really amiss. What are we missing? When we talk about the language, there is a syntax in math. Dave calls it order of operations. And I don't even know what the PEMDAS.

Dave Brancamp: PEMDAS.

Tami Brancamp: PEMDAS, right?

Dave Brancamp: You what scares most people about that? Parentheses, exponents, multiplication, division, addition, subtraction. The left to right. I mean, that's the part people left off.

Tami Brancamp: But, ah, yeah, that kind of sounds familiar, doesn't it?

Katie Strong It does. It's ringing a very faint bell.

Dave Brancamp: It's like, oh no, we're not going to do that.

Tami Brancamp So there is a syntax. There's an order of operations, how we put mathematical equations together. Just like how we put sentences together. There's semantics, right? There's word meaning. We have a little sign for you. It won't translate audio, but we'll talk about it. So, in math, and you use the word or the number, the orthographic representation 2, right? Yes. And then we spell it TWO. We also spell it TO and TOO. And then, if you say, "Okay, we also have a two in the number 12, right?" They have to be able to transcode that and a two in the number 20, the two zero. The two in all those locations has different meaning, right? So, it does have semantics.

The other parts, I think, were important, was memory and executive function. Executive function permeates mathematics in so many ways. So, when we think about our stroke survivors, those are areas that are and can be impacted. Information processing. How much can they hold in memory of being presented with language, and in this case, language and numbers.

So, I think for me, it just, it really is integrated. I also thought, too, when we were looking, I was looking at the neuroscience of it, and there's some shared neuro space that works for math and language. They're not fully disassociated, so I found that really fascinating as well.

Katie Strong Yeah, it really is, as I've been thinking about our conversation and just looking into things a little bit, it really makes sense. And even just thinking about just thinking about a word problem in math, certainly, there's that language component that may be a little less intimidating for SLP clinicians that aren't typically working in practice. But I so appreciate you both bringing this conversation out into the light and doing this work, because I can think of a significant number of clients that I've worked with that have also expressed challenges in all sorts of different ways of math. And sometimes I've been able to maybe support it a little bit, and other times I haven't. And I, you know, whether it's me just avoiding it and saying, "Oh, we could work on all of these other things or we can work on this math thing" or, you know, it's just frustrating, I think, to not have really the tools to be able to know how to support it.

Our podcast, really focuses on the Life Participation Approach to Aphasia, which really emphasizes a person-centered approach. Like I'm the client I want to choose what I want in my life and what I want to work on. And so, I'm just wondering if you might be able to talk through a little bit about how math skills fit into LPAA framework.

Tami Brancamp: Yeah, we were talking about that, and there's one particular client who has multiple PhDs before his stroke. He has family, adult children. And he's like, "Tammy." And we were Dave and I were piloting some work together. And he's like, "Guys, I want to take my family to dinner. I want to pay the bill and the tip." I'm like, "Okay, dude, I got an app for that." And he's like, "No, I want to do it myself." So that, to me, is life participation. If a person is fine with an app, let's make it so and work on something else.

Katie Strong: Yeah.

Tami Brancamp: But his case, it was so important to him. I'm like, "Okay, here we go." How do we how do we work on figuring out the tip? Now, does it have to be an exact percent? No, Dave likes to teach it more like there's some more strategies to get to the tip.

Another client I wanted to share, and sometimes too, when we think about assumptions. So, the data on how many people with aphasia also have math difficulties, numeracy difficulties is wide ranging. It's so big. So you can't even really say what percent. But I also had an assumption. I have a gentleman who I've worked with off and on for a very long time. He's nonfluent aphasia and also has apraxia of speech, and so we're working a lot on his language and his speech. And I said, "So how's your math?" "It's fine. You know, I own my own business and I have somebody help, but it's fine." I'm like, in my head, hmm, I don't think so. I wonder, because the severity of his aphasia and his ability to transcode so like, see a number and then say the name or say the numbers he wants to say, was really impacted. So, we were doing a pilot study during the pandemic online, and so Dave and I were working with this one gentleman. And I think you why don't you do the story because I don't remember you gave him homework or something. A home program.

Dave Brancamp: There's a math game called Krypto.

Tami Brancamp: Oh, Krypto.

Dave Brancamp: So you put five cards down. And each one has its value, you know. And so your listeners just so they know, like when the Jack would fall, that would be 11, and so the Ace automatically took a one, the Queen would be, you know, 12, and the King 13. So five cards different values, or they could be the same value didn't matter, and then one more card became like a target. You had to figure out an equation. So, some big, nice math term there to that you'd add, subtract, multiply, divide to equal this last card.

Now they could do with just two cards, three cards, four cards or five would be ideal. So, they had some room for success. And this gentleman, we had some hard numbers that were there. And, you know, he had done a couple, and was rolling right through. And I kept looking over at Tami and I am like, "He's got his math. His math is really good."

Tami Brancamp: His ability to calculate.

Dave Brancamp: And then we hit one that was really hard, and we're both looking (each other). And the next thing, you know, this gentleman, not to scare anybody, but makes a complex fraction, making a fraction over another fraction to solve. And you can see right now, right Tammy. Tammy is like, "What are you doing?" I'm like, "Yeah, yeah, no, let's go for it. Let's go for it." And next thing you know, we were able to solve it by doing two complex fraction with another number. And he solved the problem. And I looked at Tammy said, "This man has no math problems."

Tami Brancamp: And I said, "Boys, I'm out. I'm out. You all just continue playing with your numbers. Have a good time." That's not a comfort zone for me. It's also not the focus we're doing with aphasia in math. But it was something he was capable to do, and I also could see within him, he was super excited that he could do this.

Katie Strong: Yeah

Dave Brancamp: And he wanted to show his wife. He wanted to show other people, he was like, "Look at this. Look at this." You know, I was like, "Yeah, there's a lot happening."

Tami Brancamp: But he could not read the equation. Okay, so there's the aphasia language issue.

Katie Strong: Right.

Tami Brancamp: Transcoding. He could do the calculations without difficulty.

Katie Strong: Amazing.

Tami Brancamp: But those are the those are really fascinating. And while we were piloting, we had a group of, I don't know, five or six people with aphasia, and each one had their own. They're all on the non-fluent side, but everybody had their own combination of language difficulty and number processing difficulty. We did notice what one client we worked with who had more cognitive impairment along with language and hers, her processing was much more different than pure aphasia and the acalculia issues. So, it's really interesting to see. It's definitely not cookie cutter, right? Just like aphasia therapy.

Katie Strong: Right.

Tami Brancamp: Every person's got their unique strengths and challenges.

Todos los episodios de Aphasia Access Conversations

Ajustes

Visualización

Idioma

Determina qué emisoras ves primero en la página de inicio.

Historial

Las emisoras y episodios escuchados recientemente y tus últimas búsquedas solo se guardan en este navegador.

Avisos

Un breve aviso cuando un pódcast que sigues tiene un episodio nuevo. Puedes desactivar pódcast concretos con la campana de su página.

Cuenta

Guarda tus favoritos: en la app y en la web.

Atajos de teclado

/
Abrir búsqueda
Espacio
Reproducir o pausar
← →
En el reproductor: 15 s atrás, 30 s adelante (episodios) · en una fila: siguiente tarjeta
↑ ↓
En una fila: destino dentro de la tarjeta
Inicio / Fin
En una fila: primera o última tarjeta
Esc
Cerrar ventana o menú
?
Este resumen
Reproduciendo ahora

Ir a la emisora

A continuación

    Añade episodios con «A continuación»: sonarán después del episodio actual.