
Inequality, power and the fight for a fairer world with Jayati Ghosh
Notas del episodio
Why have a decade of global commitments failed to deliver a fairer world, and what would it actually take to build one?
In this episode of The Club of Rome Podcast, Till Kellerhoff speaks with Jayati Ghosh, economist, member of The Club of Rome and professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, about why the promise of 2015 — the SDGs, the Paris Agreement, a moment of collective ambition — has given way to a world of deepening inequality, democratic erosion and concentrated power.
The episode explores how the neoliberal framework underlying the SDGs was always likely to undermine them, why progressive forces have struggled to channel public anger into transformative change, and how a tiny group of ultra-wealthy individuals has come to shape laws, institutions and the course of global events in ways unprecedented in history.
They discuss the urgent need to shift from GDP growth as a proxy for progress towards economies that deliver dignity, decent work and basic security for all — and why communicating that vision in simpler, more direct terms has never been more important.
This episode maps out where the possibilities for genuine systemic change still lie, and why, even now, there are reasons not to abandon hope.
Till: In 2015, the world agreed on the sustainable development goals and the Paris Agreement, and for a moment, it felt like collective action was possible. A decade later, however, only 18% of the SDGs are on track. The international economic architecture, trade rules, debt fossil fuel dependency is still stacked against the countries that need transformation most.
Inequality is one of the central challenges of our time and the crisis of the old economic paradigm isn’t producing a progressive wellbeing alternative, as many of us had imagined, but rather the opposite it looks like. So what went wrong and is there a different path still possible? That’s what we’re talking about today in the Club of Rome podcast, where we explore bold ideas for shaping sustainable futures.
I’m Till Kellerhoff director of Content and Programs at the Club of Rome. And in this episode, I’m delighted to be joined by Economist Jayati Gosh, member of the Club of Rome, professor of Economics at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. She’s the author of over 20 books, including Co-authoring Earth for All, A Survival Guide for Humanity, A Report to The Club of Rome in 2022.
So welcome to the Club of Rome podcast.
Jayati: Thank you. It’s a pleasure to be with you.
Till: So you won’t remember that. But actually the first time we met was over 10 years ago in the context of A YSI Young Scholar Initiative event, uh, in 2015. And looking back 2015 seems kind of like a promising time, right? We, many countries came together agreeing on the SDGs. We had the. Climate agreement.
Looking back now, it seems like you were already not in the camp of the naive optimists, however, you, you wrote a paper in 2015, uh, which said that many problems of the global South require changing economic strategies rather than tinkering with minor outcomes. So the question is, now that we see we are only on track with 18% of SDG, some are backtracking, some are stagnating.
Did you see that coming? Did you know that we won’t be successful in the medium run? And why is that?
Jayati: Yes, I think I was fairly sure that we wouldn’t be successful in the medium run to meet the SDGs because of the broader neoliberal strategies that we were following, especially in the global south, but basically in the whole global economy. But let me be also clear. I did not anticipate the major disasters we have experienced and the bigger mess that we are in today.
Till: that makes sense. But, you, you mentioned the neoliberal paradigm and kind of an economic paradigm in which the SDGs were embedded. which were those elements you feel like that made it hard to achieve the goals we set out as global community? in what system did the SDGs fall that maybe prevented its success in the first place?
Jayati: Well, you know, when you look at the individual goals, they’re all excellent. Yes. I mean, you know, eliminating hunger, eliminating poverty, reducing inequality, employment, better quality, employment for everyone, development and industrialization. I mean, there were so many excellent goals individually dealing with the environment, with the oceans, all of that.
However, they were all embedded within a broader framework that I think, especially the Club of Rome, has been very, uh, sort of accurate and prescient in pointing out is the wrong framework, which is the idea that GDP growth, that is just the growth of monetized economic activities is the ideal indicator of material progress even, and that that is the thing you should, that should frame everything else.
If you do enough of that, then you will get positive byproducts. Or maybe you’ll have to do a little bit of adjustment for some of the bad stuff. But you can do that if you have the GDP growth. And I think that was the fundamental failing because it was not just that we were obsessed with monetized exchange as our indicator of progress, but that it depended on a very growing system of privatizing everything.
Of privatizing certainly wealth. There’s been a massive increase in private wealth at the expense of public wealth, but of privatizing services of privatizing what should be seen as public goods of privatizing knowledge. And commercializing it of privatizing finance to a way and financializing everything so that things that people would see as minimal social protections or as basic economic rights are now mediated through financial institutions, which make everybody more vulnerable and people’s lives more fragile.
So I think it was that framework which was not never explicitly mentioned, but kind of underlay all of the goals. I think that was the problem.
Till: Right. and I do think we still see this kind of using growth as a proxy for wellbeing in many discussions, right. In many economic, discussions. And it’s still then the kind of international architecture that prevents us of achieving kind of economies as serving people. Rather, we still have these discussions of people serving the economy.
Right. but if we look, look back then in the last years, do you feel like there was any. Progress at all on the international architecture. You back then 10 years ago, spoke about the trade regimes the international institutions. we know the harm institutions like IMF did to many countries of the global south.
you mentioned the financial system. How, how do you see the development over the past couple of years with regard to those fundamental systemic pillars? We base our policies on.
Jayati: You know, I, I wish I could say that it’s a glass half full. I, I don’t really know how to, define it, but what I do see is that more and more people realize that, that this paradigm is not okay. I think that is true. I think there’s a, among people across the world, there is a recognition that this is not the way to go.
Unfortunately, I think a lot of that public, reaction and resentment has been channeled by the right wing rather than by progressive forces. But I think there’s a general popular realization that that particular paradigm, which relied on economic growth at all costs, nevermind who it benefits that relied on incentivizing and giving priority to large private capitalists.
And giving them all the advantages that were denied to all other stakeholders, including nature. People realize that that’s not the way to go As a result, however, what’s happened is that increasingly in many countries, certainly in the United States and Europe, but we see that in Asia, we see that in Latin America.
We see that everywhere. That right-wing people, I won’t even call them populists because they’re not really about. You know, being for the people in any way. So I don’t think people should really figure in that, but right-wing, demagogues have been able to take over the narrative and claim that there is an elite that is benefiting, but we are going to free you from that.
In fact, they’re doing the opposite. In fact, they’re hand in glove with an elite that is further controlling, concentrating power in its own hands, and making life more difficult for everyone else and making our planet more unlivable.
Till: and it’s a good point, and we ask that question regularly in that podcast. Like, why, does the right wing benefit from the pain of the people that’s currently there? Right? Like, many people suffer from the economic system they live in. Many people suffer from climate change consequences already, but, the.
Gains are in the field of the people who would not only stop doing anything about climate change, but also basically stop doing anything for the workers, right? Like the right wing parties are very often also the most neoliberal ones in a way. So why does the, does progressive economic policymaking not seem to benefit from the pain that people are certainly feeling?
Jayati: Well, if I have to be sort of brutally realist, I would say there are two causes. One is that broadly progressive, let’s say social democratic forces. Ended up being basically caught in the clutches of neoliberalism themselves. And this is true not just in Europe, which we’ve seen very clearly, but also in the United States, also in India.
My own country, also in Latin America, which is that, you know, we, the left wing we give in too much, or rather, we talk left and walk right. And people eventually see that, or rather they experience that so they don’t trust a lot of those. They say, well, yeah, you’re saying all these big things about how you want us, and, and it’s not that they do nothing, they try and do that.
But what they’re really trying to do is put bandages on the wounds rather than address the basic sickness. And that I think is what a has alienated so many people from social democracy. They just don’t trust social demo, left social democracy to deliver in terms of radical change. What the right promises is, radical change.
It delivers radical change, but it actually delivers very terrible radical change which people have yet to see through. I think, I mean that that cycle has to unfortunately work itself out. I only hope. That people see through it before it ends up destroying all of us on the planet. But I think that’s one, you know, important cause.
And the other is that, you know, the world is complex as we know. It’s very interrelated. We know, and I think Clum of Rome has been essential in championing this, that it’s a, you have to take a systems approach. You have to look at everything in terms of how each thing relates to the other, which means all arguments are necessarily complex.
You can’t say we can just do this. Whereas, you know, the right wing has very simple messages. Most of the time they’re completely untrue, unworkable, undesirable, et cetera. But they’re very simple and so they say migrants are the problem. Or in India, they will say, Muslims are the problem. Or they will say, you know, the Epstein alleges the problem, which it is, but they will say it in a very simple way.
And that is an easy message to follow. So I think part of our problem is that we are unable to get across the fact that it is a system in which everything is interrelated and you have to work on all bits of that system together. We’re unable to get that across in a way that people understand.
Till: many good points. And I maybe picking up on the, on the last one you made there, do organizations like Club of Rome need to become more. Populist in the better sense of the word or what is your recommendation there? Because, you know, we continue talking about beyond GDP work, for example, as well.
You know, like for us it makes total sense. And then we discuss like 243 different indicators that include different elements. Very hard to understand for, people who don’t deal with that daily. Are we also using the one wrong strategies to counter the current right.
Jayati: I am beginning to think. Yes. I think our communication, I mean, I believe in the fact that it’s complex and that we do need to work on many things simultaneously, but our communications has to be. Simplified for sure. And that means bearing things down to their essence. and it may not be the same in every specific political, social, economic context, but we need to have relatively simple messages.
So, you know, when we say beyond GDP, and I’ve been part of groups that have looked for indicators, we’ve all together been looking at indicators. The SDGs had. 17 goals, 169 targets and I don’t know how many indicators for each of those targets. Yeah, so we’ve all done this, but you know, that doesn’t capture people’s imagination.
Supposing instead, we just picked one or two and we said in each and in in different countries it can be different.
in India it could really be how do you make sure that everyone in your family is going to have three proper nutritious meals for the rest of their lives? Because two thirds of our population can’t afford it. the big one, I think the really big one, which is universal, is work. How do we ensure good quality employment for everyone?
That gives them dignity, that allows them to use their capabilities. That gives them some freedom to develop more capabilities. So I personally think we should look at that, the world of work, the amount of unpaid work women do, the amount, the terrible conditions of employment that most people face. Let’s just focus on that and say we want to create an economy in which the work you do will be valued.
It’ll give you enough time to live a meaningful life. Otherwise, it’ll allow you dignity and it’ll allow you to provide minimum, decent, basic needs for your family.
Till: You’re listening to the Club of Rome podcast, the place to discover bold ideas from change makers tackling the world’s biggest challenges. We are now in our third season and our archive includes episodes on universal basic dividend wellbeing, economics, planetary peace, climate resilience, and societal collapse and renewal.
You. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Now, back to the discussion.
there is this overused chy quote currently saying, the, old world is dying. The new one struggles to be born. It is a time of monsters, but in a way, there is some truth to it that the old world, and if we connect it to economics, even the neoliberal world to a certain extent.
It’s dying, right? But there is no consistent way it’s being replaced by, it’s currently not being replaced by something, what we would consider wellbeing economics or something like that, but rather something which is like a state kind of autocratic mercantilist. State geopolitical competition, kind of conglomerate of different not really consistent economic policies as I would see it, right?
So what paradigm are we living in actually currently?
Jayati: you know, I don’t think we should look at, if you like the superstructure of what leaders are saying or even the superstructure of the wars that are being fought right now, because seen that way, they make no sense at all. But if we look at it in terms of the fundamental framework that has guided.
Global economic policy making over the last 30 years? I would say a lot of it stems from power, particularly large corporate power, and particularly plutocratic power. And if you start thinking of it in those terms, a lot of things make a bit more sense. Maybe I should go back a little bit to also say that, you know, I was involved recently in a committee looking at global inequality and some of the findings are astounding.
We found we have probably today the greatest concentration of wealth and power, therefore, in history, in terms of the global concentration, you know, a tiny handful of men, and they’re all men control not just vast unthinkable fortunes, which have global implications, but as a result of that, they control laws, institutions, regulations, policies, media, how people think.
And they’re able to influence the course of events in ways that we would not have imagined in the past. So all of the things that we think of as shocks end up enriching the same set of people. It’s quite amazing when you think about it. We have a pandemic, which seems like, you know, a major health shock.
It plays that on a particular way in which. Some, , tech oligarchs and, pharma oligarchs, et cetera, become tripling their wealth. You know, doubling, tripling, quadrupling their wealth in just two years when most of the world is actually further impoverished and made more fragile, we have a Ukraine war, which is then associated with dramatic rises in the price of food and fuel.
Which turned out, by the way, not to have anything to do with actual supply and demand they have. They result from profiteering what my colleague Isabella Weber calls sellers inflation and, financial activities. And that once again further enriches the same very small group of people. Today we have another war, a completely senseless, unnecessary.
Inexplicable war, which is killing people, which is destroying massive infrastructure, which is denying people minimum facilities for their existence, which is creating a huge climate of uncertainty and is again, having an impact on supplies of essential goods of fuel and food, fertilizer, which will affect food supplies.
And once again, we see these prices rocketing, even though right now there is no impact on supply. So you see, we see the same pattern over and over and over again with the superstructure of all these other changes happening. So really I think my biggest fear today is in fact inequality. In our report for the G 20, we called it, , an inequality crisis, equivalent to the climate crisis.
Now it’s a very strong thing to say. It is equivalent to the climate crisis. Because you know the climate crisis is, is as existential, but in a way, if you look at it, not only is inequality interlinked with the climate crisis, but it is also existential. It is threatening our societies. It’s threatening our democracies, not just because people are getting alienated and angry and, and going for us, you know, right-wing Democrats and so on.
But because of this massive power of a relatively few tiny group to influence and further change policies and laws and institutions and activities in their own favor, and that is a crisis for humanity. It’s a crisis for nature. It’s a crisis for the planet.
Till: Do you feel like any of this, , resonates on the political level as well? The pressure by the people you mentioned at the beginning is certainly there, but do you feel like it’s being implemented as well?
Jayati: Well, I won’t say it’s being implemented, but I would say it is one of the few areas of global interaction that gives me a little bit of hope. So, because, you know, when we submitted our report to G 20, that was last year in, in November, we did not expect the positive reaction we got. You know, it’s a very critical report if you’ve seen it.
We are really criticizing the way all economies have functioned over the last, and the international architecture has functioned over the last three decades. But in fact, there was active support and, and you know, one of our main proposals, was setting up of an international panel on inequality, which would be like the IPCC. It would provide coherent, systematic, , consensus information, scientific objective information that wou