
Australian Tribunals (10 November 2026)
Notas del episodio
Seven decisions from tribunals in the ACT, Victoria and Queensland in the Tribunals edition of Tuesday 10 November 2026, one with a headnote and three more worked examples from synopses. A medical practitioner who committed perjury and tried to pervert the course of justice, and what it takes to resist cancellation; a building claim under the consumer guarantee of fitness for a disclosed purpose; costs after a mixed result in a domestic building dispute; and sanction on agreed facts in health practitioner discipline.
Tribunals Desk: recusal, cancellation and staged costs (lead; headnoted).
- Medical Board of Australia v KADER (No 2) (Occupational Discipline) [2026] ACAT 66 - adverse credit findings at the liability stage did not ground a reasonable apprehension of bias at penalty (the Ebner test as formulated in Sunshine Loans; no logical connection where the presiding member's view prevailed under s 52(3)); perjury and attempting to pervert the course of justice within all three limbs of s 5; clear, corroborated proof of change is required and is not assumed from the passage of time; s 195 costs follow the event by stage. Reprimanded; registration cancelled; no disqualification period; 90 per cent of Stage 1 costs to the practitioner, own costs of Stage 2. JADE
Tribunals Desk: worked examples from synopses (frameworks; no outcomes stated).
- Andrew v Ajc Portables Pty Limited Acn 602 941 604 (Civil Dispute) [2026] ACAT 65 - s 55 Australian Consumer Law: contract compliance alone does not satisfy the fitness guarantee; three issues and the onus; disclosed purpose by implication; objective NCC Class 1a and EER benchmarks; expert thermal modelling evidence; s 236 compensation. JADE
- Millander Nominees Pty Ltd v Lynford Pty Ltd (Costs) [2026] VCAT 925 - the s 109 VCAT Act fairness gateway and its factors in a mixed-result building dispute; forensic conduct as costs facts; apportionment after partial success; fee reimbursement under ss 115B and 115C. JADE
- Medical Board of Australia v Epa [2026] VCAT 944 - framework only: agreed statements of findings and determinations; the Lee nine-point sanction checklist; the fit and proper limb of professional misconduct; the weight of mitigation and character references. JADE
Registry (list only; by subject; no outcome): MG Estates Pty Ltd v Coliban Water Corporation [2026] VCAT 938 (discovery); Chief Executive, Office of Fair Trading, Department of Justice v Yahia [2026] QCAT 521 (statutory reimbursement); Gear v Department of Youth Justice and Victim Support [2026] QCATA 158 (appeal grounds).
Case notes
Medical Board of Australia v KADER (No 2) (Occupational Discipline) [2026] ACAT 66 - Acting Presidential Member G Curtin SC (presiding) and Senior Member E Morrison, 28 October 2026. Signal: Practice & Procedure; headnote JL 10. Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (ACT) ss 3(2)(a), 3A(1), 4, 5, 193, 195, 196; ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) s 52(3). The apprehended bias test applied is from Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63, as formulated in Sunshine Loans Pty Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2026] HCA 8 (an authority applied, not a decision reported in this edition). The Stage 1 decision is Medical Board of Australia v Kader [2026] ACAT 19. The costs quantum is still to be agreed or determined. Why aired: a full penalty, cancellation and recusal compendium for discipline practitioners.
Andrew (Senior Member J Francis, 26 October 2026), Millander (Member R Bennett, 5 November 2026) and Epa (J Billings, Senior Member and Presiding Member, with Dr R McRae and Dr L Warfe Oam, as printed, Medical Practitioner Members, 10 November 2026) are aired from the edition's Signal synopses (Illustrative); no outcome is aired.
The discipline decision involving sexual harassment is reported for its legal framework only, and no practitioner is named. In Kader the amount of costs is still to be worked out; nothing here predicts it. Headnoted outcomes are as the headnote states them. A word from JADE is the house spot. Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.
Capítulos
Cargando capítulos…
Todos los episodios de The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw