Ask A Priest Live
- Épisodes
- 727
- Parution
- quotidienne
- Dernier épisode
- 13 Nov 2026
À propos du podcast
"Ask A Priest Live," because Father knows best! We'll bring you a different priest each weekday at 12pm Eastern time, where you'll be able to participate in a live Q&A on the topics that matter! We'll be joined by priests and canons from the Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest, the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter, the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate, and even some Diocesan priests that you may know personally! To ask your question, call 1-877-511-5483 or email us at [email protected]
Épisodes 727
11/12/26 - Fr. Joseph Dalimata, FSSP - Why is Celibacy Necessary for Priestly Ordination?
Fr. Joseph Dalimata, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at Our Lady of Mount Carmel in Littleton (Denver), Colorado. He was ordained in May of 2021. Click here for more information on Bosco Ministries. In Today's …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Joseph Dalimata, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at Our Lady of Mount Carmel in Littleton (Denver), Colorado. He was ordained in May of 2021.
Click here for more information on Bosco Ministries.
In Today's Show:
- Why is celibacy necessary for priestly ordination?
- Why are some archangels saints?
- What are your thoughts on the Catholic Charismatic Renewal?
- What is the concept of emotional chastity?
- And more.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/11/26 - Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I. - What Are Some Devotions to Christ's Passion?
Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I., served as Rector of the Shrine Church at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Lacrosse, Wisconsin, from 2016 to 2021. He was ordained in May of 2000. In Today's Show: EMAIL …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I., served as Rector of the Shrine Church at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Lacrosse, Wisconsin, from 2016 to 2021. He was ordained in May of 2000.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Anonymous
I work in hospice, and as a nurse I know of a facility that does not use IV's or nasogastric tubes (sometimes listed as "artificial nutrition and hydration" in literature).
It is Catholic, and all the patients have terminal cancer.
When they get so sick they can't eat/drink, the policy is to simply wait for them to die, other than providing basic care (changing them, oxygen, etc.).
Is this in conformity with Church teaching? And as a nurse, would I be responsible for making the determination of what is right and wrong in these situations, or should I leave if I think this is not good?
EMAIL: Debra from Henderson, Nevada
If Purgatory is “necessary” for most Catholics to enter Heaven, then where does this leave the work of our Lord Jesus on the cross? Isn't that where Jesus said, "it is finished"?
EMAIL: Tim from New Jersey
I was raised Protestant, but I’ve become very disillusioned with that form of Christianity; it seems disingenuous in its current state.
I’ve felt drawn to Catholicism for over a year at this point, and I’m just not sure where to start. Can I just go to Mass, or do I need to do anything prior? The only thing I know is that I can’t take part in the Eucharist yet.
EMAIL: Anonymous from New Hampshire
If we commit a mortal sin, do we automatically lose all the merit and grace we have earned, or is it gradual? Is it all restored by the sacrament of reconciliation?
EMAIL: Gerald from Boston, Massachusetts
With many churches being sold and turned into mosques, do you think that Catholicism and Christianity as a whole will have a difficult time surviving if this expansion continues?
Message from Caller: Anonymous from Arizona
When someone is enlisting in the military, is it morally permissible for them to take all of the vaccines even though some are derived from aborted fetal cells?
@Felix
In Matt 3:25 and Luke 11:17, it says "a house divided cannot stand". Then in Matt 10:34 and Luke 12:51 it says "I come to set man against father and daughter against mother". How do we understand these two differences?
@christopherbrunetti5074
What are some of the devotions to the Passion? Does the Seven Sorrows Rosary of Mary count?
Caller: Cynthia from Rochester, NY
Is the statement OMG considered blasphemy when it is said in a moment of frustration?
EMAIL: Anonymous
What are the requirements for the fast before communion? What specific things break it?
EMAIL: Judy from Illinois
If someone says that they find spiritual retreats boring, would that be considered a sin? Would that be considered talking badly of God?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/10/26 - Fr. William Rock, FSSP - How Do We Recognize and Reject the "Mark of the Beast"?
Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America Missive Blog. Fr. Rock is also currently contributing to TAN Books “Year of the Latin Mass.” Fr. Rock’s video contributions can be found on TAN Books YouTube page.
In Today's Show:
Message from Caller: Brother Knight Scott
In the Book of Revelation it says we are going to have a one world currency and a one world government. How as Catholics do we prepare for this "New World Order" and how do we recognize and reject the Mark of the Beast?
EMAIL: Anonymous (FSSP)
I have been feeling like leaving my TLM parish because I don’t connect with the priests and feel unwelcome.
I know the pastor at another nearby FSSP parish, whose spiritual style may suit me better, but I worry about causing tension or being told I must stay at my current parish.
Any advice would be helpful.
EMAIL: Michael
My local priests frequently refuse to answer my questions. Could you give me some advice on how best to approach asking a priest a question in person?
Also, why do you think some priests are so unwilling to discuss anything?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Riverside, California
If two people with SSA were living together but were not in a sexual relationship and were trying to seek help for their tendencies, would they be able to receive communion?
EMAIL: Justin
I'm severely allergic to wheat and cannot receive the Eucharist. I have also been concerned with cross-contamination from the chalice. How would you, as a priest, prefer a parishioner handle that?
Do you think it would be appropriate to ask for a separate chalice occasionally during low-attendance Masses?
@Felix
While a full-on crusade is off the table, what about self-defense or defense of others? Lots of Christians are being attacked in parts of Africa and other places. Should we let the attacks continue?
@surfdude1217 (TLM)
Father, what is your reaction to Cardinal Roche's recent statement that "you shouldn't attend TLM exclusively"?
@CriticalThought369
Does reading the bible in the living Tradition of the Church include reading the bible with Patristics? Does it include anything else? What is Tradition exactly, is it patristics, councils, papal acts
Caller: Molly from Ontario, Canada
Are unmarried couples allowed to hold hands or hug?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Garland, Texas
Can a Catholic be in favor of unrestricted free speech when much of that free speech is used to tear down the Catholic Church and blaspheme?
EMAIL: Maria from New Hampshire
Would you be able to explain the Heroic Act of Charity Prayer? As one of the souls you help, I would like to thank you for this program from the bottom of my heart.
Caller: Alexander from Bloomington, Illinois - YouTube
His grandmother is in the hospital, probably does not have much time left. He would like to tell her the meaning of the will of God -in short. Can Fr give him this meaning?
@LizB-Cath
How do I talk to someone who uses AI to restore Catholic art? Is it wrong or not? (uses to revise existing paintings)
@Doug_Remeikis
Question for father: Would Father Rock respond to the request of the Pope to remove Cardinal Fernandez because of heresy. Thank you.
@BrianBenson-rc9mu
Why are some of the Vatican 2 documents written in a way that makes it seem like they enforce doctrines condemned by the Catholic Church?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Buffalo, NY
When you bring a sin or sins to confession but you know out of habit or current circumstance that you will likely not immediately stop committing that sin, however your intentions are to rid these sins from your life, is it a valid confession?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/06/26 - Fr. Paul Born - What Makes Catholicism the True Religion Among So Many Others?
Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts. In Today's Show: EMAIL: Michael from Ontario, Canada What makes Catholicism the true religion …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Michael from Ontario, Canada
What makes Catholicism the true religion among so many others?
How can we be sure that God isn’t actually just a "coping mechanism," as various atheist “arguments” suggest?
@TeqTony
I would like to know Father Born's opinion on the midterm elections, and what Catholics can do about it moving forward.
Message from Caller: Alex from Illinois - YouTube
What is the 3rd secret of Fatima? (He keeps hearing about it, and knows most of the story of Fatima, but he doesn’t know about the 3rd secret)
EMAIL: Anonymous from Chicago
How can we determine in today’s day the difference between someone afflicted by a demon and someone who suffers from mental illness?
Caller: Molly from Ontario - YouTube
Her boyfriend was raised Catholic, but was never baptized. He is leaning towards Orthodoxy. She is trying to discern the future for them with the difference in beliefs and would like Father's input.
@bdeda5
Dad was actively dying, and the priest came in and anointed him. He was out of it on morphine in 2023. By anointing him, were all his sins forgiven?
EMAIL: David from Lincoln, Nebraska
If someone prays for someone else to come back to the Church, can it cause God to allow bad things to happen to them?
For example, would God allow someone to reach a new low point in an addiction if it meant that afterwards they would come back to the Faith?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/05/26 - Fr. Christopher Mahar - What is the Validity of the Alleged Apparitions in Medjugorje?
Father Christopher Mahar earned a Bachelor of Science in Philosophy from Providence College in 2000 and subsequently completed his Bachelor's degree in Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University …
Notes de l’épisode
Father Christopher Mahar earned a Bachelor of Science in Philosophy from Providence College in 2000 and subsequently completed his Bachelor's degree in Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome in 2003. He was ordained a deacon in St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome in 2003 and a priest in the Diocese of Providence in 2004. He currently serves as Pastor at St. Augustine Church in Providence, Rhode Island.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Anonymous from Nashua, New Hampshire
When does charity and love of neighbor become dangerous? When do we say no to charity, especially if it makes us victims to bad people?
EMAIL: Cliff from Rhode Island
What is your opinion on the validity of the private revelations from Medjugorje?
I read some very encouraging things there, such as most who die today go to purgatory.
However, I am hesitant to believe anything the Church may not have approved yet.
@Felix
1 Corinthians 9. Paul writes that he and Barnabas should be able to take a wife like the other apostles and Peter.
Was Peter married?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Austria
I sometimes find myself looking at women I come across on social media or in real life and obviously finding them attractive. However, I have a hard time knowing when I am looking at a woman with lust or when I'm committing a mortal sin. I am just absolutely clueless whether I admired their beauty, looked at them neutrally, or committed a serious sin. Can you help me on this matter?
@DisaHelgason
I was at work yesterday, and I said to my Store Director I wish a client would come in.
I was referring to a client at the last store I worked at who bought quite a bit.
The Store Director then told me to "just manifest it". I said I didn't believe it was possible, but I couldn't explain it any further. Can you explain why the idea of "manifesting" things is against the Catholic faith?
Message from Caller: Brother Knight Scott
Would it be appropriate if he organized a bible study comparing the life of Saint Paul with the life of Bella Dodd?
Also, would that be an appropriate question to ask his priest during confession?
EMAIL: Melissa from Cincinnati, Ohio
I recently visited with a priest who told me not to take children into thrift stores, and to be VERY careful about bringing things home, as these items could be cursed. He told me many stories about second-hand items causing demonic activity in people's homes, and even illnesses. This is the first I ever heard about this. Should I take this warning seriously?
EMAIL: Brittany from Buffalo, NY
What is the purpose/symbolism behind the sign of the cross on the forehead, chin, and chest before the gospel?
EMAIL: Borivone
If one spouse pursues a civil divorce but the other spouse does not want the marriage to end, what are the faithful Catholic's obligations while the marriage bond remains in place?
Also, how should a Catholic approach the possibility of an annulment when one spouse wants to pursue it, and the other has concerns or questions about the process?
@blessedlittlem
Is "bad energy" a thing?
@muaythaigirl63
@AskAPriestLive - May I do my night prayers before I go out to dinner? Vespers and daily examinations.
EMAIL: Kelly from Hilton, NY
I offer up my weekend & daily Masses to Our Lady’s intentions, for the conversion, sanctification & salvation of the whole world, especially those that will die that day & for the souls in Purgatory.
My question is, if I add in the intention for the return of my family to our Lord & His Church, are they not going to receive the same amount of graces as if I offered it up for them? I ask because I end up feeling somewhat “guilty” to my family for not offering up continuous Masses just for them when souls who will die that day absolutely need that grace to be saved.
EMAIL: Douglas from Georgia
What is the Catholic Church's stance on gambling, sports betting, and prediction markets? Is it always a sin or is there some nuance?
EMAIL: Bill from Austin, Texas
Tonight I was watching the news on the ongoing reports of the private jet crash in Palm Beach. I could hear the captain praying the Lord’s prayer in the infamous radio convo with the air controller. It was so heart-wrenching. I’m still processing this, and I’m hoping to find some answers, but why do you think God would let this happen, and to someone who was a devout Christian, praying in his most desperate time of need?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Massachusetts
As Catholics, how do we respond to the claims that the wedding of Cana was the wedding of Jesus to Mary Magdalene?
EMAIL: Alex from Fairport, NY
Are priests allowed to use tobacco? I've seen clergy holding cups of coffee or pints of beer, but never in my life have I seen a priest holding a cigarette or cigar. Is that frowned upon?
EMAIL: Kathy
Are we given our guardian angel at birth or baptism?
EMAIL: John from New Hampshire
My wife asked me this question, and I didn't know the answer. After we die, are we able to look down and see our own funeral and our loved ones here on earth?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/04/26 - Father François Bandet, EP - What is the Church's View on the Crusades?
Father François Bandet, EP, was ordained a priest on July 22, 2009, for the Clerical Society "Virgo Flos Carmelii." He obtained a licentiate (2009) and a doctorate (2015) in Fundamental Theology at the …
Notes de l’épisode
Father François Bandet, EP, was ordained a priest on July 22, 2009, for the Clerical Society "Virgo Flos Carmelii." He obtained a licentiate (2009) and a doctorate (2015) in Fundamental Theology at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome (Italy) and a licentiate (2021) in Philosophy at the Centro Universitário Ítalo Brasileiro in São Paulo (Brazil). He collaborates with the Thomist magazine "Lumen Veritatis" and is currently a missionary in Brazil.
In Today's Show:
@AnonHandle-q5w (For Fr. Francois)
Are there currently any Heralds/TFP Missions in Southeast Asia? I did some research, but the International Network orgs in my country seem to be defunct now.
@saulcd2
How can I answer someone who thinks there is no reason to be Catholic? “What’s the point?” That's what this person asked me. Thank you
@Aeterna-Pax
I saw a video of a priest in Africa placing a white, wet cloth over the babies' heads during a group baptism.
Would this method be sufficient for a valid Baptism and the reception of sacramental grace?
@Neisnice
Can I own a priest's Roman vestment even though I’m not a priest? (not wearing)
@crazyfaith77
Is there such a thing as Catholic fatigue?
@TeqTony
Father, how should Catholics react to the sweeping wins by democrats in the midterm elections?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Pennsylvania
What is the appropriate response for the laity if the priest skips the consecration during Liturgy?
I have read in some places that the priest's intention is sufficient. Elsewhere, I have read that to receive the unconsecrated host in such an instance is “technically idol worship”. (if you knew that the consecration was skipped I guess, and you did it out of habit?)
Some advocate for immediately and discreetly informing the priest of the error, while others say you should not interrupt the Liturgy under these circumstances. What are the faithful to do?
EMAIL: Anonymous from New Orleans
Is breaking the communion fast and receiving communion a sin of grave matter?
EMAIL: Phillip from Minnesota
At one of the parishes I frequently visit, I saw they offer a solemn Mass once per week for internationals. What is the difference between a regular Mass and a solemn Mass?
@Felix
What is the Church’s view on the Crusades? And would the Church ever call for another crusade?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/03/26 - Fr. Michael Copenhagen - How Can I Learn More About Eastern Rite Catholics?
Fr. Michael Copenhagen is a Melkite (Eastern Catholic) priest, husband, and father at St. Nicholas the Wonderworker Melkite Catholic Church in Gates, New York. He holds a Bachelor's of Sacred Theology from the …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Michael Copenhagen is a Melkite (Eastern Catholic) priest, husband, and father at St. Nicholas the Wonderworker Melkite Catholic Church in Gates, New York. He holds a Bachelor's of Sacred Theology from the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas in Rome.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Anonymous from Nashua, New Hampshire (Fr. Copenhagen)
Fr. Copenhagen, as a Roman Catholic wanting to learn more about the perspective and teaching of our Eastern Catholic brothers, can you recommend any books to help?
EMAIL: Patrick from Plymouth, Massachusetts
Aside from the whole “breaking off and starting his own church” part, was any of Martin Luther's criticism of the Catholic Church valid?
Also, is it true that we wouldn't have a translated version (“accessible”) of the Bible without him?
Caller: Dolores from Boston, MA
Should priests have their phones on them during confession? Also, does penance need to be done before communion?
Caller: Alex from Illinois - YouTube
He uses a website to meditate on the mysteries of the rosary. There is an icon of "an angel who chopped the hands off of a man". What should we think about this image as Catholics?
Caller: Phil from Vancouver
Can you elaborate on our definition of what a "Christian" is as a Catholic? He believes it's difficult to determine.
EMAIL: Jeremy
Scripture describes the fall of a portion of the angels, and Saints discuss the possibility that redeemed humanity may fill the places left vacant in the heavenly hierarchy.
If angels made their irrevocable choice with a clarity of understanding far beyond ours, could our earthly lives be the period in which we demonstrate our willingness to serve God without seeing Him?
The Church teaches that the Theotokos is more honorable than the Cherubim and more glorious than the Seraphim, suggesting that humanity can be elevated even above the angelic orders through God's grace.
Could one purpose of our earthly existence be to prepare us for particular roles in God's eternal kingdom, potentially even filling the places abandoned by the fallen angels?
I understand this is not defined dogma, but I'm curious whether you believe this interpretation is consistent with Catholic theology, particularly the Eastern understanding of theosis.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
11/02/26 - Fr. Casey Jones - Can Time in Purgatory Last for Years?
Father Casey Jones is a priest of the Diocese of Venice, Florida. He currently serves as the pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton Parish and school in Naples, Florida. In Today's Show: Caller: Frank from Syracuse, NY …
Notes de l’épisode
Father Casey Jones is a priest of the Diocese of Venice, Florida. He currently serves as the pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton Parish and school in Naples, Florida.
In Today's Show:
Caller: Frank from Syracuse, NY - 88.7FM
He had heard on a Catholic channel yesterday that time in purgatory can last for years. Is this true? Is there a way to know the length of time a soul can spend there?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Virginia
When I attended Mass, I was disturbed that only one person out of approximately 300 raised their hand when asked if they loved their neighbor.
Does this mean the congregation lacks Christian love, or am I wrong to judge them?
Am I being hypocritical by noticing their shortcomings while overlooking my own, as Jesus warned in the parable about removing the log from our own eye?
@SpoiloftheImmaculate
I have a question for father! Is dark sarcastic humor a sin and should it be confessed? Ex: seeing a fellow catholic friend praying in front of a statue and calling him a “idol worshipper”. Thank you
EMAIL: Anonymous from Taiwan
Is restitution necessary for a confession to be valid, even if the priest didn't suggest it?
For example, is a penitent required to turn himself in to civil authorities if he broke a law, or is a student required to tell his teacher that he cheated on a test?
EMAIL: Annie from Oakland, California
With today being All Souls' Day, should we pray for someone even if we believe they are in hell?
For example, should we pray for a family member who died with unrepentant sin or someone who rejected the Catholic Church?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Ohio
I recently watched a YouTube video where a Muslim man claimed that he saw Jesus 3 times in his dreams. He describes Jesus appearing with a "radiant face, giving him bread and wine, washing his feet, and later appearing beside a cross".
He said that he feels pushed now to leave Islam and convert to Catholicism. Do you think stories like this are true? Are Muslims really seeing Jesus in their dreams? Or do you think they are reading Scripture and their minds are just creating these scenarios in their sleep?
Caller: John from Rochester, NY - 1460AM
He has metal replacements in his body (Hip, leg). After the resurrection, will he have a perfect body like Jesus? What happens to his body after the resurrection if he does not make it to Heaven? Will it be the way it was before the metal replacements were put in?
EMAIL: Juan from New York
I hear the words 'minister', 'mission', and 'evangelization' used by protestants and even some Catholics.
I don't understand.
What are the true meanings of these words, and how can they be used vaguely or incorrectly?
@dennisbolanos (Superchat)
Were the gods of ancient Egypt really demons?
@prcvids2024
Have you ever witnessed an exorcism or possessed people in person?
EMAIL: Madison from Colorado
I recently visited the Vatican for the first time, and I was so amazed by it - it was such a beautiful place, with such wonderful treasures and art.
I found it very spiritually moving. The problem was it was just so crowded, and I often felt overwhelmed.
Why isn’t visitation to the Vatican limited to Catholics, like how visitation to Mecca has restrictions for non-Muslims? Would it just be too difficult logistically?
I feel like having separate dedicated times/areas for Catholics + non-Catholics would relieve crowding and make visiting more pleasant for everyone.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/30/26 – Fr. Francisco Nahoe, OFM Conv. - What is the Church's View on the Q Source?
Fr. Francisco Nahoe, OFM Conv., has served the Church and the Franciscan Order in Catholic education, campus ministry, parochial ministry, and catechesis. He is a chaplain at Thomas Aquinas College in Santa …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Francisco Nahoe, OFM Conv., has served the Church and the Franciscan Order in Catholic education, campus ministry, parochial ministry, and catechesis. He is a chaplain at Thomas Aquinas College in Santa Paula, California, and focuses his scholarly efforts on Renaissance rhetoric and Polynesian ethnohistory.
In Today's Show:
@Felix
Some say the Gospels use an older source nicknamed Q. For various reasons, what is the Church view on this Q source?
@Fierceandtakesnone
Can lay people give blessings to each other? Like St. Therese mentions how her dad would give her a blessing.
@ChristaDeMark
I have a question about the role of faith in the miracle of the wedding feast in Cana. The workers who filled the jugs with water had a tremendous task. There was no running water- it would have been filled at a well. Was that effort of faith what helped make the miracle so fruitful?
@Thomas-p7x1w
Should Catholics be opposed to the separation of Church and State? What are perhaps some legal principles to oppose it if so?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Florida
My wife is going through breast cancer treatment and has a double mastectomy coming up. Recently, I have been watching videos of women who have undergone the procedure to understand what my wife may experience and what her body might look like afterward. My intention is to prepare myself for the changes she will go through so that I can better understand her situation and support her.
However, some of these videos show women lifting their shirts to show their breasts, sometimes in casual, everyday settings. Although my intention is not sexual, I feel uncomfortable watching these videos. I am struggling to determine whether watching these videos could constitute a sin or a near occasion of sin. I want to approach this in a way that respects Catholic teaching while also helping me prepare to support my wife through this difficult time. I would greatly appreciate your guidance.
EMAIL: Maria from Texas
My father-in-law and his current wife—who are legally married, but not in the Catholic Church—are visiting us from abroad. (His first wife, to whom he was married in the Church, passed away years ago). My husband hasn’t seen his father in over ten years, and this may be the last time they see each other. On top of that, we believe he may be a Freemason. Is it morally permissible for us to host them in our home, and how should we navigate this with charity and prudence?
EMAIL: Anthony from Columbus, Ohio
What is the general teaching on paranormal activity as a Catholic? Does the Church acknowledge that a Catholic can be oppressed or have their homes “haunted”?
@Mikeessia
Father, if a married couple of 30-plus years in their 50s use contraceptives after they already have 3 kids, are they in mortal sin? Asking for a friend…
@CriticalThought369
Is the "consensus patrum" used to define dogmatic aspects of the faith, but also to be used in Traditional exegesis of scripture?
I'm looking for dogmatic justification to use patristics as a commentary. Trent and Vat. 1 mention consensus patrum, Im checking if it's for exegesis or just to expound the Faith
Trent and Vatican 1 say that consensus patrum is to be used in interpretation of the bible regarding Faith and Morals. What does Faith here mean, what is covered in patristic exegesis of the Bible?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/29/26 - Fr. John Brancich, FSSP - Are Unconsecrated Hosts Supposed to be Treated with Reverence too?
Fr. John Brancich, FSSP, is the pastor of St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained into the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter in 2004. In Today's Show: EMAIL: John from Buffalo …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. John Brancich, FSSP, is the pastor of St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained into the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter in 2004.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: John from Buffalo, New York
In the case of the upcoming New York State gubernatorial election where both candidates are pro-choice, could a Catholic in good conscience vote for either one of them?
EMAIL: Donna from New Hampshire
Can someone who does not believe that Christ is God and our Savior be saved from hell at the moment of their death?
Caller: Lugboxer from Olean, NY - YouTube
Looking for biblical support for the need for one to be in a state of grace for salvation.
EMAIL: Anonymous from Taiwan
Are unconsecrated hosts supposed to be treated with reverence too? I have seen in my parish that the altar server coordinator allows other altar servers to eat the unconsecrated host stored in the sacristy for fun. Is that irreverent?
EMAIL: Anonymous
I’m an 84 yr old widow. My husband passed in March. My grief has been surprisingly strong.
I was married for 45 yrs. He had 4 children; their mother died young.
I was recently given a citation by them as they want money. They and their children have shunned me, almost from the beginning. I’m stunned, hurt, and no longer trust any of them. Can I in good conscience remove them from any future relationship?
@eileenrehn9875
Hi Fr. Brancich. What is the significance of the biretta that the priest wears to and from the altar at the traditional Latin Mass?
@JasonTsai-rd5ul
Hello, I have a question for the priest: is the theory of evolution truly compatible with the Catholic faith? I’ve heard some Catholics trying to justify evolution but it doesn’t sound compatible.
Caller: Michelle from Spring, Texas - YouTube
Michelle wanted to ask Fr. about Being a chaplain for the fire department. What is that like as a Catholic priest?
EMAIL: Jane from Idaho
Does talking about a confession without identifying the penitent break the confessional seal?
@AskTheKid
Was there ever a time in the Church when there was a conversation over baptism of desire? I have heard very convincing arguments against it. Would father be interested in looking more into it?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/27/26 - Fr. William Rock, FSSP - How Do I Handle a Family Member "Married" to the Same Sex?
Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America Missive Blog. Fr. Rock is also currently contributing to TAN Books “Year of the Latin Mass.” Fr. Rock’s video contributions can be found on TAN Books YouTube page.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Margaret from Connecticut
Can we automatically "canonize" young children (below the age of reason) who were baptized Catholic and have sadly passed away since; can we pray to them/ask them to pray for us?
EMAIL: Mary
I have not been to confession in 20 years as I had lapsed in my faith. Where do I begin? How do I start?
EMAIL: Dawn from New Hampshire
I recently attended Mass at a different church. During the Mass, the priest recognized a married couple’s wedding anniversary and asked everyone to extend their hand toward the couple as he prayed a blessing. To me, this didn't seem right, and I didn't join them in raising my hands. Should I have joined in, or was I correct in refraining?
Message from Caller: Anonymous
As a Catholic how do I handle a situation where a member of my family is “married” to the same sex? How do we not exclude this person from family events especially with the holidays coming around?
EMAIL: Anonymous
Father, I noticed that there seems to be a great deal of “legalism” in traditional Catholicism.
Is being a “spiritual dictator” the correct conclusion from the Gospels?
EMAIL: Anonymous
I would like a better understanding of papal infallibility. It was my belief that any teaching from the pope regarding faith and morals is infallible. Recently, that seems to have been restricted solely to ex cathedra statements. The Catechism of the Catholic Church uses the expression that the pontiff enjoys infallibility when “he proclaims by a definitive act a doctrine pertaining to faith or morals”. Can you clarify this, Father?
@crazyfaith77
Is annulment only necessary if you had a Catholic ceremony?
Caller: Karen from Utica, NY
Her son is going to be ordained a Catholic priest in June. They are planning a reception for him. They have family members who are in a same sex relationship. Would it be okay for them to invite them?
@TorinDraven
Fr., after you have already defeated habitual sin and you live in grace, how do you forgive yourself interiorly for the things in your past life? Or should I hold onto the guilt as compunction for sins?
@gloriapatri1
What is a votive Mass?
@incordejesu
How much noise from a child is too much during Mass, to the point they should be taken out?
@crazyfaith77
Can the Devil show you things in a dream that might be affecting the Church?
@CriticalThought369
1) are the writings of the holy fathers a part of Tradition? 2) Does reading the Bible in the Tradition of the Church imply the "Consensus Patrum" rule as mentioned by Trent, V1, and other texts?
@GraciasTaco
Is there a significance to the feast of Christ the King being the last Sunday in October? And to it’s being moved to the last Sunday of the liturgical year?
EMAIL: Bianca from Florida
What happens if a Mass cannot be finished due to an emergency such as the priest falling ill or a fire breaking out?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/23/26 - Fr. Paul Born - Is It Okay to Dress up as a Priest on Halloween?
Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts. In Today's Show: @Felix Would it be bad to dress up on Halloween like a priest? @TeqTony …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts.
In Today's Show:
@Felix
Would it be bad to dress up on Halloween like a priest?
@TeqTony
Father, why do you think the majority of Catholic influencers and apologists are married?
I hardly know any that are single with no children.
@prcvids2024
What's Father’s opinion on the Cross falling on the priest in Ecuador and killing him on live TV? Was this a coincidence, or is there a message from God behind this
@Thomas-p7x1w
Is a Catholic confirmation valid if the recipient is an atheist forced into it by family pressure? If its validity is doubtful, what is the Church's official rite or conditional formula for rectifying it?
EMAIL: Peter from Pennsylvania
The Church is currently meeting to reinforce Amoris Laetitia. Is it truly moral that divorced and civilly "remarried" persons can still receive Holy Communion if living together in chastity for them is not "feasible"?
EMAIL: Michelle
I recently attended a Mass that was preceded by a miraculous medal novena. When it came time to celebrate the Mass, the priest omitted everything up to the Collect, including the Confiteor and Kyrie.
If the priest omits the Confiteor/Kyrie (with no other replacement for the Penitential Act), should the faithful refrain from receiving Holy Communion as their venial sins were not forgiven? Also, was this Mass valid with these omissions?
EMAIL: Stephen from Foxborough, Massachusetts
What is your opinion on the current archaeology survey to find Noah's Ark near Mount Ararat in Turkey? Is it a waste of time or should we take it seriously?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/22/26 - Fr. Michael Rennier - Ss. Peter and Paul School Special
Fr. Michael Rennier graduated from Yale Divinity School and lives in St. Louis, Missouri, with his wife and 6 children. He is an ordained Catholic priest through the Pastoral Provision for former Episcopal …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Michael Rennier graduated from Yale Divinity School and lives in St. Louis, Missouri, with his wife and 6 children. He is an ordained Catholic priest through the Pastoral Provision for former Episcopal clergymen that was created by Pope St. John Paul II.
In Today's Show:
5th Grader
How did you become a priest? What is your priesthood story?
7th Grader
How do we know Christianity is the true faith? What about Muslims, Jews, Hindus, and others?
1st Grader
Why did God make the angels?
8th Grader
Father, how should I correctly deal with peer pressure?
Kindergartener
While I’m playing with my toys, does Jesus look through my closet?
6th Grader
Father Michael, how do I know that God is real when there is so much evil in the world?
3rd Grader
Have you ever had a vision?
2nd Grader
Why do we have to obey God?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/21/26 - Canon Benjamin Norman, ICKSP - Are the Riots in France a Sign of the End Times?
Canon Benjamin Norman, ICKSP, was ordained in 2018. He currently serves at Most Holy Rosary Chapel (St. Vincent's School For Boys) in the Archdiocese of San Francisco. In Today's Show: EMAIL: Randy from …
Notes de l’épisode
Canon Benjamin Norman, ICKSP, was ordained in 2018. He currently serves at Most Holy Rosary Chapel (St. Vincent's School For Boys) in the Archdiocese of San Francisco.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Randy from Buffalo, New York
Are the riots that are currently ongoing in France a sign of the end times? Are we waiting for the antichrist's arrival any day at this point for the seven years of peace? France and other countries are in uproar because of mass immigration issues, and the media disguises the issue in France as students being unhappy with education and other things. Could you weigh in on this, Father?
Caller: Ari from Oakland CA
How should Catholics participate in Halloween?
EMAIL: Anonymous from New Hampshire
Father, what are some practical things I can do to avoid the sin of lust?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Texas
A parent obtained an SAT fee waiver using inaccurate income information without the student's knowledge. After discovering this, the student offered to repay College Board, but they refused payment.
The student knows they were ineligible and would make no further false statements. Is it morally permissible to continue using the remaining free SAT score sends, or must the student stop to avoid continuing to benefit from an injustice?
@USGymie
How can I learn more about detachment, and how to go about doing it?
Caller: Patrick from South Carolina
There are Eucharistic adoration chapels with 24hour access, and have what looks like a tabernacle with the monstrance inside, that has a sign that says to 'open when arriving and close when leaving'. Is that allowed for regular laity to come in and out of, or should something like that only be accessible for priests?
Caller: Alex from Illinois
How can we dress modestly as men, specifically, do we need to cover our arms?
@TorinDraven
Why does it seem like the most offensive thing nowadays is telling someone "no"? People seem to get hostile and even violent if you imply you don't approve of their choices in life.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/20/26 - Fr. Michael Copenhagen - Why Has Fr. Chad Ripperger Been Silenced?
Fr. Michael Copenhagen is a Melkite (Eastern Catholic) priest, husband, and father at St. Nicholas the Wonderworker Melkite Catholic Church in Gates, New York. He holds a Bachelor's of Sacred Theology from the …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Michael Copenhagen is a Melkite (Eastern Catholic) priest, husband, and father at St. Nicholas the Wonderworker Melkite Catholic Church in Gates, New York. He holds a Bachelor's of Sacred Theology from the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas in Rome.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Mary
My family was brought up Catholic, but one part of my family is now Shia Muslims and another part is non-Catholic Christians. Can you suggest how we should properly live with these differences and how to pray for them?
Caller: Gary from Buffalo, NY - 101.7
Has a non catholic friend who depends on the Holy Spirit for everything. Doesn't think he needs the Church or the sacraments. How does the church fit in for someone like this? What is the best way to explain it?
EMAIL: Anonymous from North Dakota
How do I know if I should take my vocational discernment seriously? I think about becoming a friar every day, and it's a life I genuinely want. Should I look into it more?
Caller: Andrew from Nevada - YouTube
Has a question about the filioque - why is it a big matter if someone believes in it or not?
Caller: Joanne from Denton, Texas
How do we keep going when someone that we get a lot of spiritual help from personally is cancelled? She recently came back to the church and feels like the same things that drove her parents away from the church are happening again.
Caller: Lourdes from Salem, MA - 1060AM
What is the correct way to get rid of an old scapular if burning or burying them is not an option?
@Wallace0333
Good afternoon Rudy and Fr Copenhagen! Curious why bishops are “silencing” priests such as Msgr. Rosetti and now Fr Ripperger?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/16/26 - Canon Stephen Sharpe, ICKSP - Which Words are Necessary for Absolution?
Canon Stephen Sharpe, ICKSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Joseph Shrine in Detroit, Michigan. He was ordained in 2020. In Today's Show: EMAIL: Anonymous from Edmonton, Canada Our 22-year-old granddaughter …
Notes de l’épisode
Canon Stephen Sharpe, ICKSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Joseph Shrine in Detroit, Michigan. He was ordained in 2020.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Anonymous from Edmonton, Canada
Our 22-year-old granddaughter got married last month and had an outdoor civil marriage.
Was it wrong for us to attend as grandparents?
EMAIL: Anonymous from New York
How does the church feel about combining a baptism and birthday celebration? Should they remain separate to focus on the importance of baptism?
EMAIL: Joseph
I forgot what my Penance was, and I no longer remember which priest gave it to me. Do I have to go back to confession and re-confess my sins?
@LandworkerGardnerofsoul
My friend is in the process of conversion and the other night something came through him screaming "I will not partake in his passion" and he has no memory of it. I have to live with this person how do I handle this in the meantime? there's been a lot more but that was a very conformational experience. Also, should lay people engage in “deliverance prayers”
Caller: Andrew from Venice, Florida - YouTube
What words are necessary from the Priest for absolution?
@Thomas-p7x1w
Hello, I have a question for the priest: I live in one diocese, but I’ve registered and go to an ICKSP parish in a neighboring diocese—I don't attend my local parish. Can my family receive sacraments like baptism or confirmation there without approval from my home diocese's priest, since it’s a non-territorial parish?
@TheCatholicPolis
Should I start driving 3 hours from one way to come to ICKSP? (Btw great speech at the homeschooling conference a couple months back).
EMAIL: Chilam from Texas
Can priests of the ICKSP become bishops? If they can, would they then be obliged to celebrate the New Mass?
EMAIL: Julie
What is the difference between a Catholic mystic and a medium/psychic?
EMAIL: Michal from Poland
Would it be inappropriate to read the Bible while riding the exercise bike?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/15/26 - Fr. Christopher Mahar - How Do I Stop Having Digital Vanity?
Father Christopher Mahar earned a Bachelor of Science in Philosophy from Providence College in 2000 and subsequently completed his Bachelor's degree in Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University …
Notes de l’épisode
Father Christopher Mahar earned a Bachelor of Science in Philosophy from Providence College in 2000 and subsequently completed his Bachelor's degree in Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome in 2003. He was ordained a deacon in St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome in 2003 and a priest in the Diocese of Providence in 2004. He currently serves as Pastor at St. Augustine Church in Providence, Rhode Island.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Troy from Spencerport, NY
Recently I've been so addicted to scrolling, social media, and just the digital vanity as a whole; I've neglected my prayer life, I've put off confession, and hence I've put off daily Mass. It's been incredibly difficult to try and break this habit, and I don't know what to do. Do you have any advice?
EMAIL: Jeremy
I treat my life as a job application for Heaven. My wife and I try to totally detach from the material world and focus on what comes next. Whatever God has in store for us, we want to be prepared. We do try to live as if our life is a job application for what comes next in Heaven. Is that the wrong mindset?
In my opinion, even if we're wrong, we are still serving our Lord while on earth.
Caller: Lugboxer from Olean, New York
In Acts 2 the end times are described in verse 21, 'and it shall come to pass that whoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved' Why is anything other than calling on the name of Lord needed to be saved?
EMAIL: Wilson from Greenwood, South Carolina
I watched a Catholic podcast yesterday that featured two prominent priests, and both of them believed that Halloween is "the devil's favorite holiday". When I scrolled down to the comments section, many seemed to be in agreement, and I just don't get it. Halloween was a historically Catholic holiday, and its name is short for "All Hallows Eve". Why do so many Catholic personalities seemingly have an agenda against it?
Caller: Teresa from Syracuse - YouTube
The priest at her parish first said that Christ is present in the Eucharist, then said that they are no longer offering the cup because of the cold and flu season. How does this not contradict the belief that Christ is truly present in both the host and the cup, if they are now withholding the cup for fear of illness? She would like Fr. Mahar's opinion.
@AmirReza_Harandeh
I am from Iran and in Iran Muslims who change their religion will be executed. I can't have access to baptism and catholic religious works . What do I have to do ?
@De-Evilizer
What is the history or meaning of the white collar that priests wear?
@phillipdela
How do I lovingly reach out to my niece who committed adultery, and not condone her actions?
@IJ72
Do people who take their life go to hell or purgatory? Or do we not know?
Caller: Debbie from MA - 1060AM
How can someone stop being judgmental of others, if they recognize that tendency in themselves?
@Felix
Last time on the show, you said that parts of Genesis can be considered mythical. If Genesis is sometimes mythical and sometimes not, how are we to know which parts are mythical and which ones are not?
@prcvids2024
What is Father's take on those who say that adopting abandoned embryos of IVF and having them implanted into surrogates to give birth to them is called being PRO LIFE?
Caller: James from Iowa - YouTube
When at mass, and girls are dressed immodestly distributing Holy Communion, should he step outside the line, or just accept it?
EMAIL: Aaron from Boston, MA
Why are pilgrimages seen as penance? It feels like taking a break and going on a nice vacation but just focusing the experience on God.
EMAIL: Bradley from Redmond, Washington
What are your thoughts on invincible ignorance? What about a gentile in some tribal society that sees no missionaries who have not reached that tribe?
EMAIL: Anonymous from New Orleans
Is a confession valid if the priest alters the words? For example, if he says "I pardon you..." instead of "I absolve you..." Should I ask the priest to give the absolution again correctly if this mistake happens again?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Texas
My husband feels he doesn’t need to go to confession because he doesn’t do anything bad. I’ve told him we are all sinners, but he isn't receptive. What words can I say to him so he will understand the importance of this holy sacrament?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/14/26 - Fr. Robert Spitzer, S.J. - Is Catholicism Compatible with the Natural Sciences?
Fr. Robert J. Spitzer, S.J., PhD, is the President of the Magis Center of Reason and Faith, one of the largest science-based Catholic apologetics institutes in the world. Father Spitzer has his own weekly EWTN …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Robert J. Spitzer, S.J., PhD, is the President of the Magis Center of Reason and Faith, one of the largest science-based Catholic apologetics institutes in the world. Father Spitzer has his own weekly EWTN television show, Fr. Spitzer’s Universe. He has appeared on the Larry King Show (with the late Stephen Hawking discussing the origins of the universe). He has also appeared on the History Channel, the Today Show, and a PBS series.
In Today's Show:
Caller: Patrick from South Carolina
Has an atheist friend who needs to be convinced that our world would require an intelligent force to create it. What does Fr. Spitzer suggest would be a good way to explain this?
Caller: Heather from Cairo, Ohio - ICR
Her teenager asked her this question and she wasn't sure of the answer: If a married couple was in a fatal car accident, would they have their funeral and be buried at the same time or separately?
EMAIL: Damon from Buffalo, NY
Are priests allowed to pursue an academic career alongside the priesthood? I know historically this was quite common, but I am curious about what it's like today.
I have an affinity towards science and philosophy and hope to be a part of the scientific community one day, but I have also been discerning the vocation towards priesthood. I am curious whether I could work towards a PhD after seminary or maybe get a different degree altogether?
EMAIL: Ashtar from Niagara Falls, Ontario
Father, statistics have shown that there has been a significant increase of young adults converting to Catholicism (or returning) in the US; why do you think this is happening?
EMAIL: Sean from Cleveland, Ohio
Father, what is your response to those that say Catholicism is incompatible with the Natural Sciences as Catholicism is faith-based rather than evidence-based?
@VaticanTheThird
Father, how come there are Jesuits in the Eastern Rites? Are they biritual?
Message from Caller: Ed from MA
He wants to promote Magis AI. Is there a business card that has a provoking question and a QR code on it? Would you make something like that? If not, what's a good way he can promote it?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/13/26 - Fr. William Rock, FSSP - Are There Still Hermits?
Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America Missive Blog. Fr. Rock is also currently contributing to TAN Books “Year of the Latin Mass.” Fr. Rock’s video contributions can be found on TAN Books YouTube page.
In Today's Show:
@De-Evilizer
Are there still hermits? Do you have to be a priest or a Sister/Nun to be one? Can a lay Catholic woman be a hermit? And how does one go about this? Serious question, not trying to be silly.
EMAIL: Anonymous from Missouri
Can you explain how Dignitatis Humanae from Vatican II does not contradict prior Papal teaching? (ie Mirari Vos, Quanta Cura, and Syllabus of Errors) On the surface, it seems like a bit of a contradiction, but I am just an average layman who is not a Theologian.
EMAIL: Anonymous (For Fr. Rock)
For the last 5 months, my wife and I have been attending our local FSSP parish and discerning whether we should register there and raise our kids with the Traditional Mass. It has been a very difficult and trying time for us. I love the TLM and know the FSSP is a good thing for the Church, but we struggle with the parish dynamic. I know the priests mean well, but sometimes the tone of preaching comes across as angry or harsh. I have heard other FSSP priests preach, and it is typically not like this. It doesn't bother me all the time, and the homilies are quite good most of the time, but it does concern my wife that our kids would end up believing God is harsh rather than a loving Father. I feel very conflicted and don't know what God wants me to do. Do you have any advice?
Caller: Kevin from Massachusetts
Did the rosary exist before it was given to St. Dominic by Mary?
Caller: Molly from Saskatchewan, Canada - YouTube
Are a boyfriend and girlfriend allowed to stay under the same roof temporarily (a week or so) if they have separate rooms and other people are staying there with them?
EMAIL: Courtney from St. Louis, Missouri
Can a biblically faithful, born-again Protestant have eternal salvation WITHOUT the catholic church?
Caller: Andrew from Nevada - YouTube
Is it acceptable for someone to go to confession in a state of mortal sin as a candidate for confirmation?
Message from Caller: Brother Knight Scott
Why has Bella Dodd never been considered for canonization by the Vatican? He sees her as a lot like St. Paul because she was a convert who was originally a communist.
@prcvids2024
Can someone be admitted to Seminary if they reject fiducia supplicans?
@jay..._a_g
Question for Fr Rock: I was recently asked to be a lector at my Ordinariate parish. I was hesitant, but resolved that if it's a need of my parish it would be charitable to lend a hand. Is this sound logic? Any advice for me?
@gracieobunny9916
Fr Rock, I have no family practicing the Faith. I’m 60 and single. What you think about pre planning funeral? I am concerned as I have no one to ensure a Catholic funeral etc
EMAIL: Anonymous from Detroit, Michigan
I was at the Detroit Institute of Arts when I observed on display the reliquary of an “unknown” Saint that was on display. Inside the reliquary were the apparent remains of the Saint. The reliquary dated to the 1300s. I was very sad that this was a museum piece and not in the hands of the Church. Is this a common occurrence? Is there anything that can/should be done?
Caller: Tom from Massachusetts
Has a niece who is in a gay relationship. Are he and his wife prohibited from attending the wedding if they marry civilly?
EMAIL: Anonymous
When we are given crosses for which we have no choice but to bear, will God hold it against us if we do our duty for the sake of the duty and for Him, but do not do so joyfully, willingly, or patiently? I think there is grace to be earned in quarreling with ourselves and hopefully coming around to the right conclusion for any hardship we must bear. But will God be angry with us if we only do our duty because we must and not because we want to?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/12/26 - Fr. Casey Jones - Is Cremation Moral?
Father Casey Jones is a priest of the Diocese of Venice, Florida. He currently serves as the pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton Parish and school in Naples, Florida. In Today's Show: @PvtSchimmy May a Catholic …
Notes de l’épisode
Father Casey Jones is a priest of the Diocese of Venice, Florida. He currently serves as the pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton Parish and school in Naples, Florida.
In Today's Show:
@PvtSchimmy
May a Catholic dissent from Humanae Vitae, even though not practicing birth control itself, and still be admitted to the sacraments?
Meaning, they do not submit their intellect to the teaching.
EMAIL: Anonymous
Is cremation moral according to traditional Catholic teachings? I have heard some Catholics argue that cremation was used by pagans to deny the resurrection.
Message from Caller: Brother Knight Scott
Why hasn't Christopher Columbus had a case open for canonization?
EMAIL: Mary Lou from Amherst, NY
Why is intinction not practiced at most Latin Rite Parishes?
@Felix
I thought it’s odd that Jesus said I came to bring the sword. Seems like in that statement he doesn’t want peace on earth. How should we understand that statement?
@mapa77741
Father, should we be praying 3 or 4 mysteries of the rosary? I heard the Luminous were added later.
EMAIL: Greg
Would it be right for me to baptize a 14-month-old great-grandchild without permission of the mother who has custody and is not Catholic?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/09/26 - Fr. Paul Born - How Should I View the Death Penalty as a Catholic?
Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts. In Today's Show: Caller: Kate from MA Does Catholic school replace the need for faith …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts.
In Today's Show:
Caller: Kate from MA
Does Catholic school replace the need for faith formation?
@JasonTsai-rd5ul
How can Catholics reconcile the Church’s current teaching that the death penalty is inadmissible with its historical acceptance in Scripture, the Church Fathers, and previous popes?
And how can a Catholic judge faithfully rule on death-penalty cases?
EMAIL: Leo from New York
Why do Protestants hate the book of Maccabees so much?
Caller: Jeremiah from Arizona
How are we as a nation supposed to react to the news that there will be a livestreamed execution of a person who committed a heinous crime? How are we reacting to this as Catholics?
@DennisBolanos
Can a person get possessed by an angel?
@JosephWhitted
Why should I be Catholic vs. Orthodox? I'm ignorant currently but am trying to learn.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/07/26 - Father François Bandet, EP - Should Bibles Be Blessed to Become Sacramentals?
Father François Bandet, EP, was ordained a priest on July 22, 2009, for the Clerical Society "Virgo Flos Carmelii." He obtained a licentiate (2009) and a doctorate (2015) in Fundamental Theology at the …
Notes de l’épisode
Father François Bandet, EP, was ordained a priest on July 22, 2009, for the Clerical Society "Virgo Flos Carmelii." He obtained a licentiate (2009) and a doctorate (2015) in Fundamental Theology at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome (Italy) and a licentiate (2021) in Philosophy at the Centro Universitário Ítalo Brasileiro in São Paulo (Brazil). He collaborates with the Thomist magazine "Lumen Veritatis" and is currently a missionary in Brazil.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: Anonymous from Taipei, Taiwan
When is it required to ask for a dispensation when missing Sunday Mass? I remembered there was a traditional saying that if Sunday Mass is out of reach within more than 1 hour, you are automatically excused. Is this true?
Message from Caller: Lugboxer from Olean, NY - YouTube
In Acts 16, the guard asks Paul and Silas how he can be saved. They answer to believe in our Lord Jesus Christ. Why do we need anything more than that to be saved?
@LiteralyMi
If you are in your late 20s to early 30s Catholic and unmarried and feel like you are running out of time, what do you do practically to not feel this way?
EMAIL: Maya from Egypt (Convert / The Problem of Evil)
Hi Father and thank you for your time. I have recently started to believe in Jesus Christ, Son of God, and I have a question. I live in the Middle East, and maybe you heard about it, but life here involves a lot of suffering for women.
If God sees the evil done across the world, why doesn't He help the victims? Why does God not help people stay safe when he sees everything?
EMAIL: Anonymous
Should prayer books, personal missals, or Bibles be blessed by a priest as a sacramental? I've heard that such books don't need to be blessed because they are the word of God. Is that correct?
EMAIL: John from Ohio
My atheist friend and his wife (both non-practicing Catholics) want to baptize their baby and have asked me to be the Godfather.
However, I asked them why they are doing this if they’re no longer practicing, and they had no answer.
Should I refuse the honor or do it anyway for my friend? I feel conflicted and want to do what is right.
@AmongTheWildflowers8 (Modesty)
What is the morality of temporary cosmetic procedures like Botox or lip fillers?
@daughterofGod1775
Is it acceptable to be a “Messianic Jew”? This is someone who “remains Jewish” but believes that the messiah has come and He is Jesus. I light the candles and sing the Shabbat prayer on Fridays at sundown, but am Christian.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/06/26 - Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I. - How Many Kids Must You Have to Be Considered Open to Life?
Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I., served as Rector of the Shrine Church at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Lacrosse, Wisconsin, from 2016 to 2021. He was ordained in May of 2000. In Today's Show: EMAIL: John …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I., served as Rector of the Shrine Church at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Lacrosse, Wisconsin, from 2016 to 2021. He was ordained in May of 2000.
In Today's Show:
EMAIL: John from Ohio
Is choosing to have only one or two children considered fulfilling the obligation to be open to life?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Buffalo, NY
Is there an age limit for asking someone to be a godparent? For example, could a great-grandparent be asked?
EMAIL: Elizabeth from North Carolina
What is the Catholic church's view of both living and post-death organ donation?
@daughterofGod1775
Would it be OK to donate my body to science?
@catholic123
Are there any types of suffering that we shouldn't offer up?
@Thomas-p7x1w
Should Catholics be opposed to the death penalty? How to reconcile modern teachings of the catechism with older church teachings that explicitly allowed it for the sake of justice?
@ChristaDeMark
Father, if after doing a deep review of your life you find there are sins that you may not have expressly brought up/remembered in confession, should they still be confessed?
@CrisisisComing
Does Charlie Kirk's death count as Odium Fidei?
Message from Caller: Brother Knight Scott
He received an email from a couple who are both trans, and they plan to get married. They want him to be the best "person" at their wedding. He isn't planning to go, but how should he charitably tell them not to go through with it?
EMAIL: Jay
If we die and go to Heaven, can we meet our guardian angel? If not, what happens to them when we pass?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Texas
My fiancé and I are both Catholics and trying to come back to our faith. We have also been saving up for our first home. I want time to look, settle, do necessary renovations, and furnish before getting married. I understand that we cannot live together before we are married, but would owning a home together be an impediment to marriage?
EMAIL: Sandie
I’ve been bringing Sunday Holy Communion to 2 retired nurses for about a year now. Is this ok for me to do if only priests should distribute communion?
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
10/02/26 2026 Fall On-Air Appeal, Day Five - with Canon Stephen Sharpe, ICKSP
EMAIL: Anonymous (ICKSP) Hello Father, I will soon be entering a pre-seminary formation house of the ICKSP. Despite having received a great deal of support from my family (although not all of them are …
Notes de l’épisode
EMAIL: Anonymous (ICKSP)
Hello Father, I will soon be entering a pre-seminary formation house of the ICKSP. Despite having received a great deal of support from my family (although not all of them are practicing), I feel as though they struggle to ultimately 'let go’, particularly those who are not the most devout; for instance, they keep asking about being able to visit a lot or questioning the fact that we won’t have phones, demonstrating a degree of skepticism about the process. While I understand it is difficult for them, any advice on helping them to let go? Thank you.
EMAIL: Jeff
When you hear confessions, do you typically recognize the voice of the penitent if they attend your parish? If so, do you talk to them differently than you would someone you didn't know?
EMAIL: Anonymous
Hi Canon. I am a victim of domestic violence, and the pastor of the church that I am no longer a member of did not take my safety or situation seriously and I feel like I was dismissed. I am strongly considering finding another denomination because of it and feel like giving up on Catholicism. Do you have any advice?
EMAIL: Philip from Georgia
I make Christian crosses, and I had a client request an epoxy cross with the star of David in it. It turned out really nice, so I decided to offer it on Facebook Marketplace. I began to receive daily harassment messages about how blasphemous I am. My question to you: do you feel it is improper to create a cross with the Star of David in it?
EMAIL: Anonymous
I prayed to St Therese for a dire need a while ago and asked for a rose if God would answer my prayer. I received roses and was overjoyed but as almost 2 years have passed, I’ve lost faith in God and the little flower and am beginning to doubt my prayer will ever be answered. The situation I prayed for seems impossible to resolve. It is affecting my faith as holding onto hope that seems like it will never come is too heavy, but letting it go sends me into frustration with God and despair as it is a great need for me and my health. Any advice would be great.
@CigarMode-4good
If someone is Celiac, can they receive the wine at an ICKSP parish?
@sebo_memento
What's the difference between strict and broad mental reservation?
@RosarivmTeutonicvm
If Genesis is not an entirely historical account of events then what's the thing buried in the Durupinar Site (the site where Noah's Ark is believed to be)?
10/01/26 - 2026 Fall On-Air Appeal, Day Four - with Fr. Christopher Mahar
EMAIL: Jonah from Pennsylvania Is the entirety of Genesis a myth? EMAIL: Anonymous from Kentucky What is the proper use for blessed salt and oil? @beautyforashes3436 Why does touching a relic bring a personal …
Notes de l’épisode
EMAIL: Jonah from Pennsylvania
Is the entirety of Genesis a myth?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Kentucky
What is the proper use for blessed salt and oil?
@beautyforashes3436
Why does touching a relic bring a personal blessing?
EMAIL: Stephen from Buffalo, NY
A lot of Protestants say that since Jesus said to "call no man your Father on Earth," it meant that priests shouldn't be called Father. Why is there this misconception?
EMAIL: Anonymous from Spain
I’m 27 years old and 5’2”. Since around the age of 21 or 22, I’ve struggled with intense feelings that I’m unattractive, particularly that there is something wrong with my face and height. A lot of my insecurity comes from comparing myself with people, and even my own family. I often feel like I’m the short, less attractive one in my family, and I find myself thinking about it far more than I want to. How should I understand this struggle from a Catholic perspective? Is there something I may be missing about how God sees me or how I should see myself? And how would you recommend that I pray or respond when these thoughts become overwhelming? I would also be open to seeking professional help, but I would really value guidance from a priest about how to approach this as a Christian.
EMAIL: Cameron from Orlando, Florida
Would going to haunted houses that use overtly gory or occult images and themes be considered sinful? I've been invited by a friend to go to Universal for Halloween Horror Nights, and some of the houses seem pretty intense.
EMAIL: Anonymous
My question is this: I was married for 10 years to a man who, during that last year, had a mistress who was also married. My husband and the woman conceived a child, which they passed off as belonging to her husband. I have been hearing about soul ties from exorcists and other priests. Since this was going on during our last year of marriage (later annulled), is it possible that I have a soul tie with my husband's mistress and through her, her husband, and the child?
@RosarivmTeutonicvm
My territorial parish recently began using a version of the Stations of the Cross in which the first station is Jesus praying in the Garden of Gethsemane, and the traditional stations depicting Jesus’ falls are omitted. Is this the Scriptural Way of the Cross introduced by Pope St. John Paul II in 1991, and is there a push to replace the traditional Stations?
09/30/26 - 2026 Fall On-Air Appeal, Day Three - with Fr. Michael Copenhagen
EMAIL: Barbara from Washington, D.C. With yesterday having been the Michaelmas, a question I have is why can Eastern Catholics venerate the other unnamed Archangels while Roman Catholics cannot? EMAIL …
Notes de l’épisode
EMAIL: Barbara from Washington, D.C.
With yesterday having been the Michaelmas, a question I have is why can Eastern Catholics venerate the other unnamed Archangels while Roman Catholics cannot?
EMAIL: Anonymous from New York
What is the difference between sacramental wine and the wine you can buy at a liquor store?
EMAIL: Olivia from Ontario, Canada
Last Sunday at Mass, I was sitting behind a disruptive boy in the pew in front of me. He wouldn't stop babbling and banging on the pew, and his mother just let him do it, even during the consecration. I get that we should have some patience when it comes to children in Mass, but it was to the point where I couldn't concentrate. What should we do in a situation like this?
@CrisisisComing
Serious question: What does the Church expect Catholics to do if a serious economic collapse appears likely? (Like the financiers pulling their money out of the country)
Thinking of the Spanish crown in the old days
@Felix
What would bring the Orthodox and Catholic Church back together?
@Francis_tamu
In terms of moral theology, why is alcohol permitted, but weed prohibited, when both cause intoxication? Many argue weed does not always remove the faculties of reason.
09/29/26 - 2026 Fall On-Air Appeal, Day Two - with Fr. William Rock, FSSP
We were live during our Fall Appeal! To donate, call 1-877-711-8500 or visit TheStationoftheCross.com. You can also email us your questions at [email protected]. Visit the show page at …
Notes de l’épisode
We were live during our Fall Appeal! To donate, call 1-877-711-8500 or visit TheStationoftheCross.com. You can also email us your questions at [email protected].
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
9/28/26 - 2026 Fall On-Air Appeal Day One w/ Joe McClane
We were live during our Fall Appeal with Rudy Carlos and Joe McClane! To donate, call 1-877-711-8500 or visit TheStationoftheCross.com. You can also email us your questions at [email protected] …
Notes de l’épisode
We were live during our Fall Appeal with Rudy Carlos and Joe McClane! To donate, call 1-877-711-8500 or visit TheStationoftheCross.com. You can also email us your questions at [email protected].
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!"
9/25/26 – Fr. Francisco Nahoe, OFM Conv. - Do Priests Pay for Seminary?
Fr. Francisco Nahoe, OFM Conv., has served the Church and the Franciscan Order in Catholic education, campus ministry, parochial ministry, and catechesis. He is a chaplain at Thomas Aquinas College in Santa …
Notes de l’épisode
Fr. Francisco Nahoe, OFM Conv., has served the Church and the Franciscan Order in Catholic education, campus ministry, parochial ministry, and catechesis. He is a chaplain at Thomas Aquinas College in Santa Paula, California, and focuses his scholarly efforts on Renaissance rhetoric and Polynesian ethnohistory.
In Today's Show:
- Do priests have to pay for seminary?
- Can Father Francisco explain how different forms of prayer work?
- Father, what is the divine right of kings, and is it biblical?
- Can you explain the context for "Forgive them for they know not what they do"?
- And more.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
9/22/26 - Fr. Casey Jones - How Do I Navigate a Marriage Where My Spouse Won’t Change?
Father Casey Jones is a priest of the Diocese of Venice, Florida. He currently serves as the pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton Parish and school in Naples, Florida. In Today's Show: With marriage being forever, if …
Notes de l’épisode
Father Casey Jones is a priest of the Diocese of Venice, Florida. He currently serves as the pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton Parish and school in Naples, Florida.
In Today's Show:
- With marriage being forever, if a spouse steps outside that marriage but never agrees to change their behaviors, how can one navigate this?
- What is the best way to explain to a Protestant or evangelical the role of works in our salvation?
- Why do people keep raising their hands/arms during Mass?
- When did the Church start using the host as we know it today?
- And more.
Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!
Voici les 40 derniers épisodes sur 727. Les épisodes plus anciens se trouvent dans le flux du podcast.
Podcasts similaires
Plus de podcasts : Religion et spiritualité
C’est votre podcast ?
Confirmez-le avec une entrée dans votre flux : vous recevez ici un code, vous l’ajoutez comme podcast:txt dans le canal de votre flux, et nous le vérifions. Votre podcast apparaît ensuite comme « vérifié » sur SoundNode.