
Guilty Plea for a Cheesesteak: The Bizarre Courtroom Demand in a Florida Murder Case
Notes de l’épisode
In a Tampa courtroom, 74-year-old murder defendant Robert Kessler reportedly offered to plead guilty in exchange for a Philly cheesesteak, french fries, and a Pepsi. Behind the unusual request was a disturbing 2021 homicide investigation involving the death and dismemberment of Stephanie Crone-Overholts, a woman Kessler allegedly invited into his home after meeting her at a McDonald’s. This episode examines the evidence against Kessler, the significance of his daughter’s statements to investigators, and the forensic psychological questions surrounding competency, courtroom behavior, and a defendant’s attempts to control criminal proceedings.