
Solomon & Smith
- Épisodes
- 57
- Parution
- hebdomadaire
- Dernier épisode
- 6 Nov 2026
À propos du podcast
Solomon & Smith discuss literature, philosophy, history, film, and the meaning of the universe.
Épisodes 57
The 20 Greatest Movies Ever Made | Jake Kuhn & Noah Stratton-Twine’s Picks
*Jake and Noah's full lists pasted below* Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith 1920s Noah: Go West, dir. Len …
Notes de l’épisode
*Jake and Noah's full lists pasted below*
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
1920s
Noah: Go West, dir. Len Powers
Jake: Seven Chances, dir. Buster Keaton
1930s
Noah: Young Mr. Lincoln, dir. John Ford
Jake: Boudu Saved from Drowning, dir. Jean Renoir
1940s
Noah: How Green Was My Valley, dir. John Ford
Jake: Children of Paradise, dir. Marcel Carné
1950s
Noah: Harvey, dir. Henry Koster
Jake: A Face in the Crowd, dir. Elia Kazan
1960s
Noah: The Odd Couple, dir. Gene Saks
Jake: PlayTime, dir. Jacques Tati
1970s
Noah: Being There, dir. Hal Ashby
Jake: Walkabout, dir. Nicolas Roeg
1980s
Noah: The King of Comedy, dir. Martin Scorsese
Jake: Raising Arizona, dir. Joel Coen
1990s
Noah: The Straight Story, dir. David Lynch
Jake: Van Gogh, dir. Maurice Pialat
2000s
Noah: Birth, dir. Jonathan Glazer
Jake: The Taste of Tea, dir. Katsuhito Ishii
2010s
Noah: The Master, dir. Paul Thomas Anderson
Jake: Stranger by the Lake, dir. Alain Guiraudie
2020s
Noah: Digger, dir. Alejandro G. Iñárritu
Jake: The Love That Remains, dir. Hlynur Pálmason
00:00 Introduction
03:05 Noah & Jake Enter
09:10 Noah - 1920s
13:38 Jake - 1920s
17:36 Noah - 1930s
21:54 Jake - 1930s
26:49 Noah - 1940s
30:41 Jake - 1940s
34:01 Noah - 1950s
40:51 Jake - 1950s
44:25 Noah - 1960s
48:22 Jake - 1960s
53:24 Noah - 1970s
58:45 Jake - 1970s
1:03:08 Noah - 1980s
1:08:36 Jake - 1980s
1:13:17 Noah - 1990s
1:19:09 Jake - 1990s
1:23:20 Noah - 2000s
1:28:48 Jake - 2000s
1:33:04 Noah - 2010s
1:38:25 Jake - 2010s
1:41:39 Jake - 2020s
1:44:50 Noah - 2020s
1:50:30 Closing Thoughts
1:51:25 The Peril at Pincer Point Trailer
1:53:01 Monkey Time
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
How the 20th Century Made Us Confused and Lonely, from Pooh to Pynchon | Sam Royer
* Sam's full list pasted below * Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith 1900s: The Wind in the Willows …
Notes de l’épisode
* Sam's full list pasted below *
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
1900s: The Wind in the Willows - Kenneth Grahame
1910s: Kokoro - Natsume Sōseki
1920s: Winnie the Pooh - A. A. Milne
1930s: Auto De Fé - Elias Canetti
1940s: The Invention of Morel - Adolfo Bioy Casares
1950s: Lolita - Vladimir Nabokov
1960s: The Dream Master - Roger Zelazny
1970s: Gravity's Rainbow - Thomas Pynchon
1980s: The Sandman - Neil Gaiman
1990s: Ark - Ronald Johnson
00:00 Intro
03:38 Sam's life
05:01 1900s
10:04 1910s
14:06 1920s
18:30 1930s
27:03 1940s
31:08 1950s
39:42 1960s
42:29 1970s
49:20 1980s
52:48 DOG INTERLUDE - Peter Jackson's King Kong
54:28 1990s
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
The Greatest (and Weirdest) 19th Century Fiction, from Frankenstein to Karamazov | Sam Royer
* Sam's full list pasted below * Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith 1800s - Shank's Mare - Ikku Jippensha …
Notes de l’épisode
* Sam's full list pasted below *
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
1800s - Shank's Mare - Ikku Jippensha
1810s - Frankenstein - Mary Shelley
1820s - Ballads and Romances - Adam Mickiewicz
1830s - Eugene Onegin.- Alexander Pushkin
1840s - Courtesans and Opium - The Ignoramus of Yangzhou
1850s - Moby Dick - Hermann Melville
1860s - Alice's Adventures in Wonderland - Lewis Carroll
1870s - The Gaucho Martin Fierro - Jose Hernandez
1880s - The Brothers Karamazov - Fyodor Dostoevsky
1890s - Selected Writings - Leopoldo Lugones
00:00 Introduction
04:40 Apocalyptic American Culture
06:26 How Sam Got into Reading
09:19 1800s
13:09 1810s
16:09 1820s
19:52 1830s
23:40 1840s
30:16 1850s
33:17 1860s
38:03 1870s
42:11 1880s
48:10 1890s
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
Does Canon Even Matter? | The Bible, Star Wars, and Pop Culture Dogmatism
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith 00:00 Intro 03:52 What is Canon? 05:38 Canon debates in Abrahamic …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
00:00 Intro
03:52 What is Canon?
05:38 Canon debates in Abrahamic Religions
08:50 How this maps onto Star Wars (in depth)
17:41 Lore, Doctrine, and Talmudic gloss
19:06 Why does Canon matter so much? Ancient Greece
24:17 The obsession with continuity and internal errors
28:47 Pirate editions, off-brand intellectual property, Virgil, Dickens, and Cervantes
33:30 True Canon exists in human imagination
35:29 Adaptation: books to films - Tolkien’s obsession with Canon
40:18 Tennyson and Milton - Jackson is to Tolkien what Virgil is to Homer what Christianity is to Judaism
45:46 Liberty to contradict
47:40 A chamber drama set on Kamino - gibberish words
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
This Film Changed English History (Forever?) | Jarman & Christopher Marlowe
Theo Rollason joins Milo and Jack to discuss Queer Edward II, their new film built from thirty hours of unseen footage shot during the making of Derek Jarman’s Edward II, and to trace Jarman’s film back through …
Notes de l’épisode
Theo Rollason joins Milo and Jack to discuss Queer Edward II, their new film built from thirty hours of unseen footage shot during the making of Derek Jarman’s Edward II, and to trace Jarman’s film back through Christopher Marlowe to the medieval king himself. Along the way: Jarman turns Renaissance history into Thatcher-era queer politics, Marlowe makes class more scandalous than homosexuality, Tilda Swinton transforms Isabella into a vampiric villain, Edward’s murder becomes entangled with AIDS and Jarman’s own mortality, Peter Greenaway attracts some professional jealousy, and a lost archive reveals the funny, chaotic, intimate reality of making one of British queer cinema’s defining films.
00:00 – Introduction
05:36 – Theo Rollason enters
11:52 – What Makes a Derek Jarman Film?
22:01 – How Jarman Reimagined Edward II
29:23 – Gay Love and Gay History
37:05 – Tilda Swinton: Queen of Thatcher
45:36 – Marlowe and Jarman: Kindred Artists
50:48 – Death & the AIDS Crisis
58:38 – 30 Hours of Lost Edward II Footage
1:03:50 – Derek Jarman vs Peter Greenaway
1:09:45 – What was Jarman like on set?
1:16:30 – Clip from Queer Edward II
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
Epstein, Lolita, and the P*rnification of Childhood
00:00 Introduction 04:38 Lolita Summary 10:50 Did Epstein actually read/like Lolita? 14:32 Epstein's upbringing - boomer sexuality 19:51 Did male boomers create modern sexuality? 24:21 Differences between …
Notes de l’épisode
00:00 Introduction
04:38 Lolita Summary
10:50 Did Epstein actually read/like Lolita?
14:32 Epstein's upbringing - boomer sexuality
19:51 Did male boomers create modern sexuality?
24:21 Differences between Epstein and Humbert
28:29 Do we all want to be children forever?
30:35 Our desires have been created for us
32:27 The modelling industry
34:55 Creation: of oneself, of others
36:30 Britney Spears, Olivia Rodrigo, Sabrina Carpenter
38:37 Piper Rockelle: the Gen Alpha twist on the American Dream
41:53 Creation in Lolita - The ending
45:34 Lolita - controversial then and now, for different reasons
48:19 To write a book properly, it needs to be misread
50:48 The paradoxes of our age around children and sex
53:13 Why Gen Z are turning away from boomer sex
57:10 Conclusion - Epstein is a boring loser.
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
Does Artistic Genius Come From the Devil? | Faust, Yeats, and the Poetic Sublime
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith Richard Barakat's *Faust the Magician* is available here …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
Richard Barakat's *Faust the Magician* is available here: https://shorturl.at/CDWx0
See also the below discussions:
Richard Barakat: The Literary Collective (Spring 2025): https://youtu.be/rwecUdt0p28
Richard Barakat: Philosophic Dialogues from La Frontera (Spring 2024): https://youtu.be/YiiZbUErFcA
Richard Barakat joins us to explore the strange relationship between poetry, magic, and the Devil, beginning with Marlowe and Goethe’s Faust tellings and ending with Richard’s own apocalyptic Faust for the 21st century. Along the way: Pindar raises men towards the gods, Ovid turns poetry into immortality, Yeats makes images into magical powers, paganism and Christianity collide and combine, artistic genius edges towards possession, and Faust’s desire to transcend the human becomes inseparable from the old suspicion that the arts are, somehow, the Devil’s domain.
00:00 – Are the Arts the Devil’s Domain?
06:24 – What Is the Magic of Poetry?
10:15 – Marlowe, Goethe, and their Fausts
19:37 – Pagan Gods, Christianity, and Syncretism
27:43 – Pindar and Becoming Like the Gods
38:52 – What Makes Great Art Ineffable?
41:42 – Writing a Darker Faust for the 21st Century
49:50 – Faustian Knowledge, Faustian Power
52:32 – Yeats the Magician
57:20 – Ovid, Transformation, and Artistic Immortality
01:07:16 – Yeats: Leda and the Byzantium Poems
01:22:33 – Satan's Faustian Bargain
01:30:13 – Can Art Create Gods?
Chapitres
Chargement des chapitres…
Is the Quran the EXACT Speech of God? Islamic Theology Explained | Ramon Harvey
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith 00:00:00 Intro 00:05:30 Ramon arrives - poetic epigraph 00:06:30 What …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
00:00:00 Intro
00:05:30 Ramon arrives - poetic epigraph
00:06:30 What does it mean for God to Speak?
00:09:47 Is Arabic Special? Is it older than Nature?
00:12:04 Is the Quran translated into Arabic from Transcendent Speech?
00:14:11 Could putting God's words in a human language degrade them?
00:18:41 Are Arabic speakers especially chosen by God? Is Islam exclusive?
00:23:05 Should all Muslims learn Classical Arabic?
00:25:48 If you have two sentences that say the same thing in different words, could they both be from God?
00:32:49 What is the basis of the Quran's authority?
00:39:21 Variants of the Quran
00:48:22 The first printed Qurans. Literacy.
00:52:55 Can deaf illiterate people experience the Quran?
00:56:55 The mysteries of meaning. How do words mean things?
01:01:40 Is beauty truth? Is the Quran beautiful?
01:12:37 Would God choose to reveal himself in common language?
01:16:13 Did anyone ever try to write a better Quran?
01:22:25 The proof of the Quran lies in its effect on people.
01:27:16 Why did God stop revealing himself? Why are there no prophets after Muhammad?
01:32:10 Is God active in the lives of all humans?
01:34:22 Did the companions' editorial power cease after their death?
Consciousness is NOT an illusion... REALITY IS | William Seager
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith 00:00:00 Intro 00:07:38 Why Does Consciousness Break Science 00:10:40 Is …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
00:00:00 Intro
00:07:38 Why Does Consciousness Break Science
00:10:40 Is Life Special? Biophychism: Is Life Consciousness?
00:14:40 Are Observations (Quantum Physics) Dependent on Consciousness?
00:18:10 A Unique Element of Consciousness, distinguishing it from Life
00:21:25 Why is Consciousness Not A Vague Concept?
00:26:40 Are Our Brains Lying to Us? Is Consciousness an Illusion
00:32:58 Is Artificial Intelligence Conscious?
00:35:00 Epiphenomenalism
00:39:25 The Matrix and Divorce of Mind and Reality
00:42:25 How Much of Our Awareness Relies on Sense Data?
00:48:40 Pure Being and Pure Consciousness
00:52:12 Panpsychism, and how it solves the problem of consciousness
00:56:45 Mysterianism and Colin McGinn
00:59:06 Is Panpsychism just sexed-up materialism?
01:03:17 Weak vs. Strong Emergence
01:07:25 Is Panpsychism an Imaginary Science?
01:10:45 Consciousness is Integrated Information
01:14:08 Cosmopsychism
01:20:13 Physical Reactivity is the Signature of Consciousness
01:23:39 Could dark matter or antimatter be without consciousness?
The Dark Religion of American Literature | Taylor Caron on the Neo-Gnostics
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith Taylor returns to take Milo and Jack through ten great works of American …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions on Patreon, or follow us on other Podcast channels here: https://linktr.ee/solomon_smith
Taylor returns to take Milo and Jack through ten great works of American "Gnostic" literature, beginning with Emerson’s Nature and ending, exactly a century later, with Faulkner’s Absalom, Absalom! Along the way: Jones Very believes himself to be Christ, Hawthorne discovers the stain in creation, Ahab declares war on visible reality, Whitman meets the “real Me”, Dickinson confronts an inaccessible God, and Melville, Bierce, West, and Faulkner push the American suspicion of the world into ever darker territory.
Part two of our Gnostic Bonanza; the first part - on the original Gnostics - available here: https://youtu.be/brOyXDlaA-Y?si=DQGCLCq61lwZm4PG
CHAPTERS
00:00 Introduction
03:24 I. Ralph Waldo Emerson – Nature (1836)
11:15 II. Jones Very – Essays and Poems (1839)
18:48 III. Nathaniel Hawthorne – Mosses from an Old Manse (1846)
24:46 IV. Herman Melville – Moby-Dick (1851)
34:55 V. Walt Whitman – Sea-Drift / “As I Ebb’d with the Ocean of Life” (1860)
41:21 VI. Emily Dickinson – Poems (1861–65)
50:53 VII. Herman Melville – Clarel (1876)
59:01 VIII. Ambrose Bierce – Tales of Soldiers and Civilians (1891)
1:04:10 IX. Nathanael West – Miss Lonelyhearts (1933)
1:07:38 X. William Faulkner – Absalom, Absalom! (1936)
1:21:04 American Gnosticism – Final Thoughts
The Christians Who Thought God Was Evil | Taylor Caron on the Gnostic Gospels
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith Solomon & Smith on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/solomon-smith/id680868193 …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
Solomon & Smith on Apple:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/solomon-smith/id6808681930
On Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/2DkVPzTS5lHkynSlHMyOL2?si=FsVpIakbR861Vg9jM3WZvQ&utm_source=copy-link
On Amazon:
https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/7ca1e4c1-2e5a-4691-9c32-35c05fc01f05
On iHeart:
https://iheart.com/podcast/343165456
In this episode of Solomon and Smith, Jack and Milo speak with Taylor Caron about the Gnostics: those strange, alluring, heretical early Christians who believed that the physical world was corrupt, that its creator was not the highest God, and that salvation came through secret knowledge of the divine world beyond this one.
This is the first part of a two-part conversation. In this episode, we begin with the original Gnostics: the lost gospels, the Nag Hammadi texts, the Gospel of Thomas, the Secret Book of John, the Gospel of Judas, Valentinus, the Gospel of Truth, Thunder, Perfect Mind, the Epistle to Flora, the Gospel of Philip, and the Second Treatise of the Great Seth. In the next part, we turn to American Gnosticism and the strange afterlife of these ideas in modern literature.
What is Gnosticism? Is the material world evil? Was Yahweh the demiurge? Who or what is Barbello? Why does Jesus keep appearing as a child, an old woman, a voice, a double, a robe, a cosmic emissary, or a being laughing from outside the crucifixion? And how did a collection of bizarre early Christian texts found in Egypt in 1945 come to haunt modern religion, literature, conspiracy, pop culture, Harold Bloom, The Da Vinci Code, and the idea of hidden knowledge itself?
Chapters:
00:00 Was Valentinus better than the Bible?
01:10 Introduction
05:47 Taylor enters
07:50 What is Gnosticism?
09:30 Nag Hammadi and the lost texts
11:01 The basic Gnostic worldview
15:18 I. The Gospel of Thomas
20:30 II. The Secret Book of John
23:18 Barbello, Sophia and the demiurge
29:42 III. The Hymn of the Pearl
34:15 IV. The Gospel of Judas
38:38 Crucifixion, flesh and anti-natalism
40:09 V. Valentinus' Fragments
45:24 VI. The Gospel of Truth
52:16 VII. Thunder Perfect Mind
56:20 VIII. The Epistle to Flora
1:01:18 Jesus and the Hebrew Bible
1:05:27 IX. The Gospel of Philip
1:10:46 X. The Second Treatise of the Great Seth
1:15:48 Orthodoxy, heresy and the stakes of the crucifixion
Youtube Just Made Views Worthless | Hyper Viewflation
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith What is a view? What is attention? Does a number become more real if it is larger? Are …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
What is a view? What is attention? Does a number become more real if it is larger? Are advertisers being ushered into a hall of mirrors? And if every video, every creator, every athlete, every billionaire, and every man on earth can be given a bigger number, have we made the world better — or simply made value meaningless?
We discuss YouTube views, attention inflation, dead internet paradise, advertisers, Zimbabwean trillionaires, egalitarianism, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, cinema box office inflation, World of Warcraft stat squish, the psychological horror of decline, the impossibility of measuring attention, the parable of the workers in the vineyard, angelic value, Christianity, equality, and whether every mote of dust has infinite worth.
Chapters:
00:00 The number goes up
00:51 Introduction
04:45 YouTube changes the view count
08:02 Advertisers and the fantasy economy
12:40 Do labels change reality?
14:47 Egalitarianism, power and resentment
19:03 Do big numbers hide inequality?
22:35 Cinema, inflation and fake success
24:22 Stat squish and the horror of smaller numbers
27:14 What can value actually measure?
31:07 Can attention ever be quantified?
36:01 The workers in the vineyard
38:01 Earthly numbers and angelic value
42:36 YouTube views in heaven
43:38 Christianity, equality and infinite worth
Why We May Never Understand Consciousness | Colin McGinn on Mind and Language
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith Thinkers mentioned: Richard Dawkins, Noam Chomsky, Jerry Fodor, Charles Darwin, Paul …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
Thinkers mentioned: Richard Dawkins, Noam Chomsky, Jerry Fodor, Charles Darwin, Paul Grice, Fred Dretske, Gottlob Frege, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Saul Kripke, Richard Montague, Iain McGilchrist, Alfred Tarski
00:00:00 Introduction
00:04:49 Knife Throwing, Other Athletic Activities
00:11:57 Poetic Epigraph
00:13:05 How to integrate Philosophy, Linguistics, and Biology? Should philosophers read Dawkins? Should biologists read Tarski?
00:20:15 Origins of language. Are any aspects of language as old as consciousness?
00:27:39 Can we only discuss language in language?
00:29:06 Are all philosophical problems linguistic? Analytic philosophy
00:32:45 Fodor and the Language of thought. Language without communication
00:34:50 Consciousness and the limits of knowing
00:39:38 Can something exist without you knowing it?
00:42:40 Can we understand/build a mind?
00:43:49 Links between Mysterianism and Apathatic theology?
00:48:13 Does McGinn's Mysterianism conflict with his Naturalism?
00:50:10 Why do we have introspection?
00:55:28 Do our brains see the world dualistically to support the existence of language?
01:01:35 Wittgenstein's Investigations. Split brains. McGilchrist.
01:03:43 The brain has over-invested in spatial reasoning.
01:06:16 Communication without symbols, without linguistic utterance.
01:11:38 Philosophers don't pay enough attention to animals. Darwin, etc.
01:14:35 Philosophers read too much psychology, and don't understand it.
Is AI About to Kill Mathematics? | Kirwin Hampshire
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith Kirwin's article on mathematics is available here …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
Kirwin's article on mathematics is available here: https://kirwinhampshire.substack.com/p/the-dark-night-of-mathematics
In this episode of Solomon and Smith, Jack and Milo speak with Kirwin Hampshire, mathematics PhD and author of the Substack Ossuray Lost at Sea.
Is mathematics discovered or invented? Is it a formal game, a spiritual art form, a machine for generating truth, or the highest expression of human creativity? And what happens when AI begins solving open problems, producing counterexamples, and doing the thing mathematicians thought belonged to the strange, private, intuitive life of the mind?
We discuss what a number is, why mathematics feels certain in a way other forms of knowledge often do not, whether infinity and zero expand the limits of thought, and why mathematical discovery can feel closer to art, wizardry, or religious revelation than to ordinary technical work. Then we turn to the nightmare: AI-generated mathematics, the psychology of being scooped by a machine, and the possibility that human mathematicians may be reduced to checking, verifying, and understanding what machines have already produced.
Is AI killing maths? Or is it revealing what mathematics really was all along?
Topics include: AI and mathematics, mathematical creativity, open problems, counterexamples, proof, intuition, infinity, zero, Gödel, Cantor, mathematical beauty, the philosophy of maths, AI art, chess engines, human purpose, dangerous knowledge, truth versus goodness, and whether machines are about to ruin the most beautiful thing humans ever made.
Chapters:
00:00 AI and the human gap
01:15 Introduction
05:58 The challenge
07:37 Kirwin enters
10:00 Poetic epigraph
11:37 What is a number?
17:11 Maths, mind, and reality
20:37 Mathematics as creativity
22:30 Infinity and the machinery of thought
26:45 Falling in love with maths
32:15 Discovery, invention and the unfinished painting
37:14 Has maths become too arcane?
41:35 AI enters mathematics
44:11 AI counterexamples and open problems
49:39 Chess, machines and the loss of spark
52:36 Humans as the AI’s assistant
57:22 Intuition and the human gap
1:02:34 Dangerous truth and the Copernican trauma
1:06:50 The Impossible Luddite
1:13:40 Why does AI hurt?
1:16:12 Is AI just another tool?
1:21:17 Truth, beauty and incompatible desires
1:24:08 Process versus result
Performance of the second movement from Bartók's second quartet by the Carmel Quartet, used under the following license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en
Classic Literature Is WAY More Fun Than You Think (1710-1840) | Emma Schilders
*Emma's list is pasted below* Please help us to continue having these conversations on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership Emma's channel can be found at …
Notes de l’épisode
*Emma's list is pasted below*
Please help us to continue having these conversations on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
Emma's channel can be found at: https://youtube.com/@sarcastic_fish?si=J3bGM11vCKSxpt3p
1710s - Robinson Crusoe: Daniel Defoe
1720s - Roxana: Daniel Defoe
1730s - Manon Lescaut: Abbé Prévost
1740s - Pamela: Samuel Richardson
1750s - The Female Quixote: Charlotte Lennox
1760s - Barren Decade - TBR: Castle of Otranto, A Sentimental Journey
1770s - The Sorrows of Young Werther: Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
1780s - Dangerous Liasons: Pierre Choderlos de Laclos
1790s - Justine: Marquis de Sade
1800s - Corinne, or Italy: Madame de Staël
1810s - Frankenstein: Mary Shelley
1820s - Barren Decade - TBR: The Betrothed
1830s - The Charterhouse of Parma: Stendhal
1840s - The Count of Monte Cristo - Alexandre Dumas
00:00:00 Intro
00:04:35 What's so interesting about the 1700s?
00:06:53 1710s
00:11:30 1720s
00:14:54 1730s
00:20:19 1740s
00:24:04 1750s
00:29:38 1760s
00:33:00 1770s
00:36:00 1780s
00:43:40 1790s
00:49:26 1800s
00:54:51 1810s
01:05:34 1820s
01:09:03 1830s
01:13:05 1840s
Why Understanding Reality Isn’t Enough | Igor Kufayev
Please help us to continue having these conversations on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership You can buy Igor's books directly from his publishing house here …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us to continue having these conversations on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
You can buy Igor's books directly from his publishing house here: https://songpublishing.org/?v=b6bb43df4525
In this wide-ranging conversation, artist and spiritual teacher Igor Kufayev talks with Jack and Milo about consciousness, meditation, Kashmir Shaivism (Trika Shaivism), aesthetics, creativity and the relationship between spiritual experience and everyday perception.
He reflects on a profound early meditation experience that transformed his relationship with his body and consciousness, and the moment he put Heidegger aside in favour of seeking direct experience rather than intellectual understanding.
The conversation moves from Western philosophy to the Bhagavad Gita, Kashmir Shaivism, Abhinavagupta and the concept of camatkāra—the rapture or astonishment of aesthetic experience. We also explore how ordinary reality became dull, whether consciousness actually creates the world we experience, and why the promise of extraordinary spiritual experiences distracts us from the extraordinary nature of everyday life.
00:00:00 Introduction
00:05:33 Uzbek Fruits/Raisins - Poetic epigraph
00:09:07 The meaning crisis began with the search for meaning
00:12:19 Bronze Age Greece, The Odyssey, Greek sculpture
00:16:10 Modernity and Meaning - Life Under Socialism
00:23:57 The Anatomy of Experience - Fire and Karl Marx
00:32:10 Loving the West in Central Asia
00:37:37 Disillusionment with Michelangelo, waiting for the Muse
00:41:04 Adi Shankaracharya vs. Abhinavagupta
00:47:52 Existentialism. Kung-fu Art Philosopher Musician Sage, murdered by the Mafia
00:52:05 Tragedy, Faith, Sri Aurobindo
00:56:39 Initiation into Meditation in a Dream
01:01:56 Can you have a moment of absolute transcendence which you don't notice?
01:07:10 Idealism. We animate reality by perceiving it.
01:11:35 Outright rejection of Heidegger and Western Philosophy
01:17:50 Outright love of Western Art
01:19:47 Reading Indian Spiritual Classics
01:23:55 Swami Muktananda and discovering Trika Shaivism
01:26:54 Camatkara, the bridge between art and spirit
01:34:32 Final Question
The 20 Best Books Ever Written | Cecily Carver’s Picks
*- Cecily's list is pasted below -* Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership Check out Cecily's Substack here …
Notes de l’épisode
*- Cecily's list is pasted below -*
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
Check out Cecily's Substack here: https://cecilycarver.substack.com/
Tremolo expertly demonstrated by Edson Lopes, who can be heard here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WTBiNRT3GPM
1800s
The Earthquake in Chile - Heinrich von Kleist
1810s
Persuasion - Jane Austen
1820s
The Tale of Kieu - Nguyen Du
1830s
The Queen of Spades - Alexander Pushkin
1840s
Cousin Bette - Honoré de Balzac
1850s
Madame Bovary - Gustave Flaubert
1860s
Great Expectations - Charles Dickens
1870s
Middlemarch - George Eliot
1880s
The Portrait of a Lady - Henry James
1890s
The Seagull - Anton Chekhov
1900s
The House of Mirth - Edith Wharton
1910s
In Search of Lost Time - Marcel Proust
1920s
The Magic Mountain - Thomas Mann
1930s
Rebecca - Daphne du Maurier
1940s
Mildred Pierce - James M. Cain
1950s
Lolita - Vladimir Nabokov
1960s
The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie - Muriel Spark
1970s
Fifth Business - Robertson Davies
1980s
Hotel du Lac - Anita Brookner
1990s
A Place of Greater Safety - Hilary Mantel
0:00 Introduction
2:42 Cecily arrives
6:47 1800s
11:21 1810s
15:05 1820s
19:02 1830s
22:37 1840s
30:00 1850s
33:52 1860s
37:57 1870s
42:38 1880s
46:42 1890s
50:51 1900s
56:57 1910s
1:04:03 1920s
1:10:12 1930s
1:13:58 1940s
1:19:04 1950s
1:26:01 1960s
1:30:47 1970s
1:34:37 1980s
1:40:00 1990s
1:49:31 Conclusion
The Trinity is Even WEIRDER Than You Thought | Karen Kilby
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith Karen Kilby is the Bede Professor of Catholic Theology at Durham University, and one of …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
Karen Kilby is the Bede Professor of Catholic Theology at Durham University, and one of the most interesting contemporary thinkers on the Trinity, apophatic theology, and the limits of theological understanding.
In this conversation, Jack and Milo talk to Karen about whether Christians should expect to make sense of their own beliefs. Is theology a noble intellectual discipline, a useful service to the Church, or sometimes just a very elaborate waste of time? Do theologians know more about God than ordinary believers? Or is the attempt to master God intellectually already a mistake?
The discussion focuses especially on the Trinity. What does it mean to say that God is Father, Son, and Holy Spirit? Is the doctrine clearly present in Scripture, or was it developed by the early Church as Christians tried to make sense of their worship of Christ? Why three persons rather than two, four, or seventeen? What is wrong with Arianism or Unitarianism? And how can a doctrine be defended if part of its meaning is that it cannot be fully understood?
Subscribe if you enjoy discussions of theology, philosophy, literature, history, and the mysteries that resist being turned into neat little systems.
Topics discussed:
Karen Kilby's path from mathematics to theology
Faith, questioning, and the life of the mind
Apophatic theology and divine mystery
What the doctrine of the Trinity says
Scripture, Jesus, and the early Church
Greek philosophy and theological language
Ousia, hypostasis, and homoousios
Arianism, Unitarianism, and orthodoxy
Why the number three matters — or does not
Aquinas and the limits of proof
What theologians are actually for
The Incarnation and divine solidarity
Social trinitarianism
Human unknowability and divine unknowability
Mysteries, puzzles, science, AI, and dangerous knowledge
If you enjoyed the conversation, please like, subscribe, and leave a comment telling us your favourite heresy — or whether you think theology is a waste of time.
0:00 Is Theology a Waste of Time?
1:09 Introduction
8:19 Karen Kilby Arrives
13:28 Faith, Questions, and Theology
17:35 Apophatic Theology and Mystery
20:32 What Is the Trinity?
22:06 Scripture and the Early Church
30:00 Greek Philosophy and New Language
35:02 Why Three?
40:02 Defending an Unprovable Doctrine
48:22 What Are Theologians For?
55:00 Incarnation and Solidarity
59:28 Social Trinitarianism and Unitarianism
1:10:00 Human Mystery and Divine Mystery
1:20:00 Mysteries, Puzzles, and Dangerous Knowledge
I was a Hard Materialist... Until This INSANE Dream | Jeff Falzone
Please help us to continue having these conversations on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership 00:00:00 Introduction 00:05:34 Jeff arrives 00:11:09 Footballers are the most complete human …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us to continue having these conversations on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
00:00:00 Introduction
00:05:34 Jeff arrives
00:11:09 Footballers are the most complete human beings
0013:57 Do Aliens have human aesthetics? Evolution.
00:17:56 Poetic Epigraph - Goethean Darwinism
00:22:04 What is a Mind?
00:27:27 Hypnotism - Milton Erickson
00:33:34 Dreams and Time, Lucid Dreaming
00:44:50 Dreams and Technology
00:49:19 Why suffering will never end, and why that's okay
00:53:00 Stanford Prison Experiment - other experiments
01:00:45 Post Modernism and its Discontents
01:02:15 The Insane Dream that Melted Jeff's Brain
01:10:07 Eugene Gendlin - pausing
01:22:14 Plato's epistemology - inaccessible knowledge - ambiguity
01:27:48 Are eloquent people doomed to insanity? David Foster Wallace - Hamlet
01:37:45 Shakespeare's Sonnets
01:45:45 Shakespeare's Self-Sabotaging Empathy
01:50:55 Gateway Sonnets - Some of our favourites
02:01:43 Sonnet 31 - Wow!
02:04:29 Crazy Numerological Patterns in the Sonnet Sequence
02:14:06 Shakespeare is Impulsive
02:20:33 Final Sonnet - Crazy final gambit
The Greatest Books You’ve Never Read (1800-2000) | Adam Walter’s Picks
*- Adam's list is pasted below -* Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership In this video Adam discusses his favourite …
Notes de l’épisode
*- Adam's list is pasted below -*
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
In this video Adam discusses his favourite works of fiction decade by decade, starting in 1800 and going 200 years, decade by decade, until they reach the borders of our present century. If you would like to be interviewed by us about your favourite books, please send an email.
1800s
Elective Affinities - Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
1810s
The Golden Pot - E.T.A. Hoffmann
1820s
Melmoth the Wanderer - Charles Maturin
1830s
The Charterhouse of Parma - Stendhal
1840s
Lost Illusions - Honoré de Balzac
1850s
Sylvie - Gérard de Nerval
1860s
Our Mutual Friend - Charles Dickens
1870s
Demons - Fyodor Dostoevsky
1880s
The Posthumous Memoirs of Brás Cubas - Machado de Assis
1890s
The Christ and Antichrist Trilogy - Dmitry Merezhkovsky
1900s
Hadji Murat - Leo Tolstoy
1910s
In Search of Lost Time - Marcel Proust
1920s
Rakes of the Old Court - Mateiu Caragiale
1930s
A Glastonbury Romance - John Cowper Powys
1940s
The Death of Virgil - Hermann Broch
1950s
Memoirs of Hadrian - Marguerite Yourcenar
1960s
Riders in the Chariot - Patrick White
1970s
The Obscene Bird of Night - José Donoso
1980s
Repetition - Peter Handke
1990s
The Rehearsals - Vladimir Sharov
0:00 Introduction
2:23 Adam arrives
7:27 1800s
10:22 1810s
14:28 1820s
18:40 1830s
21:55 1840s
27:42 1850s
30:30 1860s
36:04 1870s
42:30 1880s
44:18 1890s
48:32 1900s
51:12 1910s
59:40 1920s
1:03:19 1930s
1:06:46 1940s
1:10:46 1950s
1:12:55 1960s
1:15:41 1970s
1:21:58 1980s
1:23:35 1990s
1:28:45 Conclusion
The Greatest Playwright of the 17th Century (after Shakespeare) | Elaine Hobby
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith Elaine Hobby is one of the foremost experts in the work of Aphra Behn: the greatest …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
Elaine Hobby is one of the foremost experts in the work of Aphra Behn: the greatest playwright of the Restoration, and one of the greatest woman writers of all.
In this conversation, Jack and Milo talk to Elaine specifically about Aphra Behn's theatre: how did it differ from her contemporaries; what made it so great; how did a woman who began her career as a spy in the employ of Charles II find her way to the stage; and what was the secret to her enduring popular success?
The discussion also covers the history of the Restoration stage, returning as it did from the ban under Cromwell's Commonwealth. How did women end up acting, a profession once restricted to men? How did Charles II's personal tastes influence the theatre? We also analyse the types and plots used by Behn in her plays, and the way she bends traditional structure to her art. Was her theatre entirely comic? Or does it contain a pathos, or even a subversive character?
Subscribe if you enjoy discussions of literature, philosophy, history, and the greatest plays ever written.
Topics discussed:
Elaine Hobby's fascination with Aphra Behn and her period
Women on the stage
The backstory of Aphra Behn
Her travels and her espionage
The nature of the Restoration Stage
Behn's early hits
The Lucky Chance
The Feigned Courtesans
The Rover, her biggest and most enduring hit
The Emperor of the Moon
Rakes, racounteurs, and clever women
Aphra Behn's ideas on marriage and friendship
If you enjoyed the conversation, please like, subscribe, and leave a comment telling us your favourite Behn play - or if you're planning on reading her after watching!
0:00 Introduction
7:09 Elaine Hobby Arrives
15:21 Feminism and the Rediscovery of Women Writers
22:40 Charles II, the Restoration, and Women on Stage
33:04 The Mysterious Early Life of Aphra Behn
38:02 Espionage, Antwerp and the Surinam Question
48:05 What Made Behn’s Plays Different?
55:05 The Rover: Sex, Money, Women
1:10:53 Behn and the Marriage Comedy
1:17:30 Reading and Performing Restoration Drama Today
1:24:00 The Emperor of the Moon and Theatrical Spectacle
1:42:59 Why Behn Still Matters
The music used is Fanny Hensel's Piano Trio, performed by the Claremont Trio under the following license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/
The Greatest Films of Every 5 Years (part two - 1970-2024) | Jack and Milo’s Picks
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith - Our full lists are pasted below - 1970-1974 Jack's Pick: Amarcord, dir. Federico …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
- Our full lists are pasted below -
1970-1974
Jack's Pick: Amarcord, dir. Federico Fellini
Milo's Pick: Aguirre, the Wrath of God, dir. Werner Herzog
1975-1979
Jack's Pick: Monty Python's Life of Brian, dir. Terry Jones
Milo's Pick: All That Jazz, dir. Bob Fosse
1980-1984
Jack's Pick: Koyaanisqatsi, dir. Godfrey Reggio
Milo's Pick: The Draughtsman's Contract, dir. Peter Greenaway
1985-1989
Jack's Pick: Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown, dir. Pedro Almodóvar
Milo's Pick: Ran, dir. Akira Kurosawa
1990-1994
Jack's Pick: 32 Short Films About Glenn Gould, dir. François Girard
Milo's Pick: The Long Day Closes, dir. Terence Davies
1995-1999
Jack's Pick: Eyes Wide Shut, dir. Stanley Kubrick
Milo's Pick: The Thin Red Line, dir. Terrence Malick
2000-2004
Jack's Pick: Mulholland Drive, dir. David Lynch
Milo's Pick: The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, dir. Peter Jackson
2005-2009
Jack's Pick: King Kong, dir. Peter Jackson
Milo's Pick: My Winnipeg, dir. Guy Maddin
2010-2014
Jack's Pick: The Master, dir. Paul Thomas Anderson
Milo's Pick: The Master, dir. Paul Thomas Anderson
2015-2019
Jack's Pick: The Love Witch, dir. Anna Biller
Milo's Pick: A Hidden Life, dir. Terrence Malick
2020-2024
Jack's Pick: Killers of the Flower Moon, dir. Martin Scorsese
Milo's Pick: ???
00:00:00 Introduction
00:02:42 1970-1974
00:14:47 1975-1979
00:27:26 1980-1984
00:42:45 1985-1989
00:58:39 1990-1994
01:16:57 1995-1999
01:42:26 2000-2004
02:02:27 2005-2009
02:16:29 2010-2014
02:22:48 2015-2019
02:34:34 2020-2024
02:42:07 The Final Film
You’ve Never Heard of Russia’s Strangest Literary Genius | Oliver Ready on Dostoevsky and Sharov
Oliver Ready is one of the world's greatest translators of Russian literature, most famous for his translation of Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. In this conversation with Jack and Milo, he speaks …
Notes de l’épisode
Oliver Ready is one of the world's greatest translators of Russian literature, most famous for his translation of Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. In this conversation with Jack and Milo, he speaks about what makes Dostoevsky's prose so distinctive, direct, and contemporary, and why Vladimir Sharov may be the greatest Russian novelist you've never read.
The discussion covers Dostoevsky's literary reputation, Nabokov's famous criticism of his work, the art of literary translation, Russian history, and, in the latter part, Sharov's astonishing novels, which blend theology, politics, history, and surreal imagination into something unlike anything else in modern literature.
Subscribe if you enjoy discussions of literature, philosophy, history, and the greatest novels ever written.
Topics discussed:
Oliver Ready's translation of Crime and Punishment
What makes Dostoevsky's writing unique
Nabokov vs. Dostoevsky
Vladimir Sharov's extraordinary novels
Before and During
The Rehearsals
Russian literature and literary translation
Soviet history, theology, and magical realism
How translators recreate style across languages
Books Mentioned
Crime and Punishment — Fyodor Dostoevsky
The Brothers Karamazov — Fyodor Dostoevsky
Notes from Underground — Fyodor Dostoevsky
The Double — Fyodor Dostoevsky
Before and During — Vladimir Sharov
The Rehearsals — Vladimir Sharov
Be as Children — Vladimir Sharov
The Master and Margarita — Mikhail Bulgakov
If you enjoyed the conversation, please like, subscribe, and leave a comment telling us your favourite Russian novel—or whether you're planning to read Vladimir Sharov after watching.
00:00:00 General Introduction
00:04:00 Vladimir Sharov Synopsis and Discussion
00:13:10 Oliver Ready Arrives, Discussion of Insomnia
00:17:44 Poetic Epigraph
00:20:14 Dostoevsky's Reputation, Nabokov's Slander
00:24:40 Translating Crime and Punishment, prose style etc.
00:39:05 Do certain authors suit English better than others?
00:42:37 Translating Sharov vs. Dostoevsky
00:45:55 Post Soviet Literary Culture, Sharov's place in it
00:50:12 Sharov's uncompromising style and voice
00:54:20 Does Sharov make sense to a non-Russian?
01:00:43 Before and During, and the Religiosity of Communism
01:06:00 Innocence, Experience, and the Gulags
01:10:47 Master and Margarita, Russian History as Commentary to the Bible
01:18:38 Sharov, Magic Realism, and originality
01:24:20 What was Sharov like?
01:31:44 The Russian Tradition of the Fantastical
01:36:38 Sharov's fairytales, Sharov's crowds, Sharov's walks
01:41:28 Ready's first exposure to Sharov
01:45:00 White Moss, Reductive 'Problematic' criticism of other cultures
01:48:25 Sharov 'Not Obvious Enough'
The Greatest Films of Every 5 Years (part one - 1915-1969) | Jack and Milo’s Picks
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith - Our full lists are pasted below - 1915-1919 Jack's Pick: Intolerance, dir. D.W …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
- Our full lists are pasted below -
1915-1919
Jack's Pick: Intolerance, dir. D.W. Griffith
Milo's Pick: Terje Vigen, dir. Victor Sjörström
1920-1924
Jack's Pick: Häxan, dir. Benjamin Christensen
Milo's Pick: Die Niebelungen, dir. Fritz Lang
1925-1929
Jack's Pick: Sunrise, dir. F.W. Murnau
Milo's Pick: Napoleon, dir. Abel Gance
1930-1934
Jack's Pick: M, dir. Fritz Lang
Milo's Pick: Twentieth Century, dir. Howard Hawks
1935-1939
Jack's Pick: The Adventures of Robin Hood, dir. Michael Curtiz
Milo's Pick: Olympia Part 1 (prelude), dir. Leni Riefenstahl
1940-1944
Jack's Pick: Fantasia, dir. Various
Milo's Pick: Ivan the Terrible Part 1, dir. Sergei Eisenstein
1945-1949
Jack's Pick: It's a Wonderful Life, dir. Frank Capra
Milo's Pick: The Third Man, dir. Carol Reed
1950-1954
Jack's Pick: Singin' in the Rain, dir. Stanley Donen
Milo's Pick: Early Summer, dir. Yasujiro Ozu
1955-1959
Jack's Pick: Madhumati, dir. Bimal Roy
Milo's Pick: The Cranes are Flying, dir. Mikhail Kalatozov
1960-1964
Jack's Pick: Lawrence of Arabia, dir. David Lean
Milo's Pick: Dr Strangelove, dir. Stanley Kubrick
1965-1969
Jack's Pick: Andrei Rublev, dir. Andrei Tarkovsky
Milo's Pick: Playtime, dir. Jacques Tati
00:00:00 Introduction
00:05:24 1915-1919
00:11:57 1920-1924
00:21:20 1925-1929
00:29:20 1930-1934
00:38:53 1935-1939
00:50:44 1940-1944
01:02:53 1945-1949
01:18:03 1950-1954 (Milo late 50s)
01:32:27 1955-1959 (Milo early 50s)
01:47:56 1960-1964
02:05:23 1965-1969
Was Paradise Already Lost? | Achsah Guibbory on Milton’s Theology of Desire
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership In this conversation, Achsah Guibbory joins Jack and Milo to discuss John Donne …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
In this conversation, Achsah Guibbory joins Jack and Milo to discuss John Donne, John Milton, love, sex, sin, marriage, desire, Paradise Lost, and the problem of whether erotic love can ever be holy.
Donne and Milton are two of the great Johns of seventeenth-century English poetry, claimed by some to be entirely different men. Donne is witty, erotic, devotional, cynical, sacred, obscene, metaphysical, and impossible to pin down. Milton is austere, sublime, political, theological, revolutionary, authoritarian, and not much fun at a party. Yet both poets return, in radically different ways, to the same infinity: love.
The discussion begins with the word itself. What did “love” mean in the seventeenth century, before Darwin, before Freud, and before modern romantic individualism? How did English poetry inherit older distinctions between erotic love, spiritual love, charity, friendship, desire, marriage, and the love of God? And why does one little English monosyllable have to carry so much metaphysical weight?
Guibbory places Donne and Milton against the long Christian tradition that associated sex with sin, chastity with holiness, and desire with the Fall. Augustine looms large: original sin, shame, bodily rebellion, and the problem of sexual desire after Eden. But Donne, in poems such as *The Good-Morrow*, *The Ecstasy*, *The Canonization*, *The Sun Rising*, and *A Valediction: Forbidding Mourning*, offers something stranger and more daring: the possibility that bodily love might itself become spiritual.
The conversation then turns to Milton’s *Paradise Lost*. What is sex like before the Fall? Do Adam and Eve desire one another in Eden, or is their prelapsarian love something more equal, mutual, peaceful, and almost desireless? What changes after the fruit is eaten? Why does Milton describe postlapsarian sex as the “seal of guilt”? And why does Adam fall so quickly once Eve has fallen?
Along the way we discuss Milton’s bower scene, Eve’s reflection in the lake, Adam’s loneliness, Satan’s resentment, hierarchy, equality, the strange ending of *Paradise Regained*, and whether Milton gives Satan some of his own political instincts. We also talk about Donne’s contradictions, Milton’s unresolved tensions, Thomas Browne, Kafka's weird humour, and why great writers are often most alive when they have not fully solved themselves.
Expect reflections on:
John Donne and John Milton as rival poets of love
Achsah Guibbory on Donne, Milton, sex, and theology
Augustine, original sin, chastity, and sexual shame
Erotic love, spiritual love, charity, and marriage
Donne’s love poetry and the holiness of consummated desire
Milton’s *Paradise Lost* and sex before the Fall
Adam, Eve, equality, hierarchy, and the bower scene
Desire as lack, danger, or spiritual possibility
Satan, resentment, monarchy, and Milton’s politics
The difference between Donne’s lyric contradictions and Milton’s epic resolutions
The “seal of guilt” and sex after the Fall
Milton’s divorce tracts and the nightmare of “household captivity”
Paradise, the New Jerusalem, and whether we really want a world without desire
If you enjoy long-form conversations on poetry, literature, theology, philosophy, seventeenth-century writing, erotic love, sin, Milton, Donne, and the strange borderlands between body and soul, subscribe to the channel and leave a comment below.
Who writes love better: John Donne or John Milton? And can erotic love ever be holy?
Chapters:
00:00:00 Sex, sin, and Donne’s dangerous poetry
00:01:16 Introduction
00:06:32 Achsah Guibbory appears
00:11:06 Milton’s youthful love poem
00:16:02 Donne versus Milton
00:20:23 What does “love” mean?
00:27:03 Augustine’s sexual legacy
00:29:02 Donne’s sacred eroticism
00:31:17 Plato, Genesis, and desire
00:35:14 Sex before the Fall
00:44:33 Desire, lack, and Satan
00:49:41 Milton’s unresolved epic
00:52:41 Donne’s contradictions
00:56:30 Paradise Regained and grace
01:01:16 Adam’s desire
01:12:20 Eve and Adam fall
01:14:16 Sex after the Fall
01:22:52 The Messiah's Daughter
01:33:23 Marriage, divorce, and captivity
Correction:
2:00 It is, in fact, Barnard.
Reading is... BAD For You Actually
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith The smartphone has quietly assassinated humanity's greatest invention. In this …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
The smartphone has quietly assassinated humanity's greatest invention.
In this discussion, we explore the decline of deep reading. An obligatory video for all book-based channels. We look at the atomic annihilation of literacy, attention spans, memory, and critical thinking. A crazy Faustian twist: though we have access to more information than ever before, we are actually losing the ability to read and think.
Topics discussed:
Why smartphones are changing the way our brains process information
The decline of reading for pleasure
AI, ChatGPT, and the miserable future of literacy
Gen Z, attention spans, and digital culture
Books vs. short-form gunk
The printing press, literacy, and the miserable future of 'civilisation'
Who REALLY Wrote the Quran? | Gabriel Said Reynolds
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith Who wrote the Quran? Did it flow directly from God? Did Muhammad compose it? Did several …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us continue having these discussions by supporting us over on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/SolomonSmith
Who wrote the Quran? Did it flow directly from God? Did Muhammad compose it? Did several authors compose it over several centuries? Does it have the characteristics of a dictated text, or a written text? How simple or complicated is the story of the Quran's origins?
In this episode, Jack and Milo are joined by Islamic studies scholar Gabriel Said Reynolds to explore one of the most controversial questions in Islamic Studies.
The conversation examines the traditional Islamic account of the Quran alongside modern academic perspectives. Reynolds argues that the evidence may point toward a more complex process of composition than is commonly assumed, challenging the long-standing Western, secular scholarly consensus that Muhammad himself was the sole human author.
Topics include:
• Who wrote the Quran?
• Did Muhammad write the Quran?
• The traditional Islamic narrative of revelation
• Academic theories of Quranic authorship
• How the Quran was compiled and transmitted
• Why the Quran is arranged by surah length rather than chronology
• The relationship between the Quran, the Torah, and the Gospel
• The emergence of Classical Arabic
• The literary qualities and inimitability (i'jaz) of the Quran
• Early Islamic history
• Historical-critical approaches to the Quran
• Western scholarship on the origins of Islam
If you enjoy long-form conversations on religion, philosophy, history, and literature, consider subscribing for more discussions with scholars.
This Philosopher Believed in Magic | James D. Reid on Novalis
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership In this conversation, James D. Reid joins Jack and Milo to discuss Novalis: poet …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
In this conversation, James D. Reid joins Jack and Milo to discuss Novalis: poet, philosopher, natural scientist, early German Romantic, and perhaps the greatest pen name in literary history.
Novalis — born Georg Philipp Friedrich Freiherr von Hardenberg — died of tuberculosis just before his twenty-ninth birthday, yet left behind one of the strangest and most suggestive bodies of work in European Romanticism. Reid discusses Novalis as a thinker who refuses ordinary divisions between philosophy, poetry, religion, science, nature, and love. Was he a poet doing philosophy, a philosopher writing poetry, or some bizarre contortion of the two: a philosopher for whom poetry was the only possible means of philosophizing.
The discussion begins with Novalis’s life and intellectual world: Kant, Fichte, Schlegel, Schleiermacher, Schelling, the Freiberg Mining Academy, early German Romanticism, and the extraordinary range of Novalis’s unfinished projects. Reid explains why Novalis should not be reduced to the familiar image of the death-haunted mystical poet, and why his notebooks, fragments, novels, and poems reveal a more precise and incisive mind.
Much of the conversation centres on Kant and the imagination. Reid explains how the German Romantics inherit Kant’s "subjective turn," but extend the imagination far beyond perception and art, into science, morality, politics, religion, and our most basic orientation toward the world. We discuss Fichte, the thing-in-itself, appearances, language, and the Romantic conviction that reality is not simply found, but partly shaped by how human beings attend to it.
The second half of the conversation turns to Novalis’s *Hymns to the Night*, the death of Sophie von Kühn, erotic longing, Christianity, mysticism, darkness, mediation, and the possibility that poetry can do philosophical work which ordinary propositional prose cannot. Reid discusses the challenge of translating Novalis, the relation between philosophy and poetry, the *Monologue*, magical idealism, and the idea that words do not merely describe a world, but help give us one.
Expect reflections on:
Novalis as poet, philosopher, scientist, and early Romantic
Kant, Fichte, imagination, and the thing-in-itself
The fragment as philosophical and literary form
Why Novalis is more than a mystical death-haunted poet
The *Hymns to the Night* and the death of Sophie von Kühn
Christianity, mediation, religion, and heterodoxy
Night, eroticism, death, and mysticism
Poetry as philosophy, and philosophy as a literary form
The problem of translating beauty and precision
Plato, Descartes, Nietzsche, Wagner, Wittgenstein, and the sciences
Magical idealism and the possibility of poetising the world
Mountains, language, ecology, and seeing the world as a “you”
If you enjoy long-form conversations on literature, philosophy, German Romanticism, theology, poetry, metaphysics, and the strange borderlands between science and spirit, subscribe to the channel and leave a comment below.
Is Novalis the greatest literary pen name? And can poetry think things that philosophy cannot?
00:00:00 Words, world, and magical idealism
00:02:00 Introduction to James D. Reid and Novalis
00:08:17 James arrives
00:15:44 Poetic epigraph
00:18:06 Who was Novalis?
00:21:54 Novalis, fragments, and Romantic “memes”
00:24:16 Kant's imagination
00:35:31 Fichte, subjectivity, and things in themselves
00:40:49 Language and perception
00:43:13 Novalis or Hardenberg?
00:46:21 Friedrich Schlegel and the early Romantic circle
00:47:17 What made Novalis unique?
00:52:07 *Hymns to the Night*: origins and textual history
00:58:24 Was Novalis a Christian?
01:08:02 Erotic night, death, and mysticism
01:18:04 Translating Novalis: poetry as philosophy
01:24:14 Kant and the night
01:30:01 The *Monologue* and language
01:31:44 Plato, Descartes, and philosophy as literature
01:34:14 Wagner, Nietzsche, and Romanticism after Novalis
01:37:00 Why philosophers distrust poetry
01:44:41 What is magical idealism?
01:49:01 The magical power of words
01:54:47 Mountains, ecology, and seeing nature as a “you”
01:58:40 The blue flower, longing, and *Heinrich von Ofterdingen*
02:01:37 How James D. Reid came to Novalis
02:08:10 Conclusion
The Greatest Novel of Every Decade (1800–2000) | Andrew Nixon’s Picks
*- Andrew's list is pasted below -* Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership In this video Andrew discusses his favourite …
Notes de l’épisode
*- Andrew's list is pasted below -*
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
In this video Andrew discusses his favourite works of fiction decade by decade, starting in 1800 and going 200 years, decade by decade, until they reach the borders of our present century. If you would like to be interviewed by us about your favourite books, please send an email.
Two bonus decades are available over on Patreon!
1800s
Tales from Shakespeare - Mary & Charles Lamb
1810s
Pride & Prejudice - Jane Austen
1820s
A barren decade.
1830s
The Pickwick Papers - Charles Dickens
1840s
Vanity Fair - William Makepeace Thackeray
1850s
Mada-- Bleak House - Charles Dickens
1860s
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland - Lewis Carroll
1870s
Middlemarch - George Eliot
1880s
Treasure Island - Robert Louis Stevenson
1890s
The Diary of a Nobody - George & Weedon Grossmith
1900s
The Wind in the Willows - Kenneth Grahame
1910s
Howard's End - E.M. Forster
1920s
A High Wind in Jamaica - Richard Hughes
1930s
A Handful of Dust - Evelyn Waugh
1940s
Titus Groan - Mervyn Peake
1950s
The Ginger Man - J.P. Donleavy
1960s
The Lord of the Rings - J.R.R. Tolkien
1970s
Watership Down - Richard Adams
1980s
The Old Devils - Kingsley Amis
1990s
Blue at the Mizzen (representing the full 20-book Aubrey-Maturin series)
00:00:00 Introduction
00:05:11 1800s
00:08:29 1810s
00:13:56 1820s
00:14:45 1830s
00:19:20 1840s
00:22:40 1850s
00:27:48 1860s
00:32:13 1870s
00:38:06 1880s
00:42:20 1890s
00:45:33 1900s
00:51:46 1910s
00:56:20 1920s
01:01:45 1930s
01:08:16 1940s
01:11:51 1950s
01:16:47 1960s
01:22:48 1970s
01:28:06 1980s
01:31:25 1990s
01:36:07 Conclusion
Virgil is the Greatest Poet of Antiquity (Not Homer) | Wright & McGill on The Aeneid
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership In this conversation, Scott McGill and Susanna Wright join Jack and Milo to …
Notes de l’épisode
Please help us to keep having these conversations by supporting us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/solomonsmith/membership
In this conversation, Scott McGill and Susanna Wright join Jack and Milo to discuss their recent translation of Virgil’s *Aeneid*: one of the foundational poems of Roman literature, a work of exile, empire, grief, violence, duty, divine terror, and extraordinary poetic control.
The conversation begins with the problem of collaboration: how do two translators produce one poem? McGill and Wright discuss the six-year process of translating the *Aeneid* together, from early divided drafts to an intensely collaborative line-by-line revision, and reflect on what it means to develop a single poetic voice out of two sensibilities.
Much of the discussion centres on Virgil’s style: his elevation without bombast, his emotional restraint, his “majesty of sadness,” his difference from Ovid, and the challenge of translating a poem that is at once ancient, literary, musical, political, and deeply humane. We talk about Tennyson, Dryden, Emily Wilson, Homer, Ovid, alliteration, metre, syntax, wordplay, and the question of how far a translator should go in making an ancient poem feel modern.
The conversation also explores the *Aeneid*’s relationship to Homer. Is Virgil merely reworking the *Iliad* and the *Odyssey*, or is he creating something radically new out of inherited material? We discuss Roman originality, translation as collaboration with the dead, the poem’s strange “cinematic universe” of myth, and the way Virgil turns Homeric models inside out.
In the second half, we turn to the poem’s darkest and most difficult questions: Aeneas and Turnus, the shocking final killing, whether the poem is Augustan propaganda, the human cost of empire, and Virgil’s extraordinary capacity to extend pity even to enemies and monsters. The episode also ranges through Dido, Mezentius, Lausus, the fall of Troy, the shield of Aeneas, the future of Rome, and the burden of history.
Expect reflections on:
Virgil’s *Aeneid* and why it still matters
How two translators collaborate on one poem
The difference between Virgil, Homer, and Ovid
Emily Wilson, translation, accessibility, and “otherness”
The emotional gravity of Virgil’s Latin
Dido, Aeneas, Turnus, Mezentius, and Lausus
The ending of the *Aeneid* and the killing of Turnus
Whether the *Aeneid* is Augustan propaganda
Empire, violence, pity, duty, and the costs of history
Alliteration, assonance, metre, syntax, and wordplay
Roman originality and the creative use of the past
The fall of Troy and the terror of the gods
If you enjoy long-form conversations on classical literature, translation, poetry, mythology, philosophy, history, and the strange afterlives of ancient texts, subscribe to the channel and leave a comment below.
What is your favourite translation of the *Aeneid*? Is Virgil’s ending a failure, a shock, or the whole point of the poem?
00:00:00 The Fall of Troy and the Terror of the Gods
00:01:06 Introduction to Scott McGill, Susanna Wright, and *The Aeneid*
00:08:04 Guests arrive: Rome, Christianity, and imperial continuity
00:11:47 Poetic epigraph
00:13:04 Two translators, one poem
00:18:38 English poetic traditions, Tennyson, and translation taste
00:22:07 The Emily Wilson Revolution
00:27:58 What is Virgil’s Latin like?
00:35:39 Virgil, Homer, and originality from the past
00:45:29 Turnus, Achilles, and the second Trojan War
00:47:53 The shocking ending of *The Aeneid*
00:53:26 Ecumenical pathos: Empathy in Virgil
00:59:35 The *Odyssey* and unending battle
01:06:46 The shadow of heroism
01:10:00 Ancient endings, unfinished poems, and Lucan
01:14:00 Sound, syntax, alliteration, and Virgilian texture
01:23:25 Roman history, prophecy, and the shield of Aeneas
01:29:36 First encounters with *The Aeneid*
Ich ruf' zu dir, Herr (BWV 639) performed by Chiara Bertoglio and shortened for the video, under the following license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en
Voici les 40 derniers épisodes sur 57. Les épisodes plus anciens se trouvent dans le flux du podcast.
Podcasts similaires
Plus de podcasts : HistoireC’est votre podcast ?
Confirmez-le avec une entrée dans votre flux : vous recevez ici un code, vous l’ajoutez comme podcast:txt dans le canal de votre flux, et nous le vérifions. Votre podcast apparaît ensuite comme « vérifié » sur SoundNode.







