Aller au contenu

608 – Are We The Baddies?

4 octobre 2026

Notes de l’épisode

Hey guys, are we the baddies? Because the Lord of Shadows sure is asking us to kick a lot of puppies. This week, we discuss characters who realize they’re on the wrong side of history and where to go from there. What do such characters need to do to redeem themselves? How bad can they be before readers stop believing that they can change? What circumstances make such a radical change of heart realistic? Find out with us on this week’s episode.

Show Notes Transcript

Generously transcribed by Weed Eater. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.

Oren: And welcome everyone to another episode of the Mythcreants podcast. I’m Oren.

Chris: And I’m Chris.

Oren: Now, as the captain of the HMS Orphanage Burner, I am proud to command an elite crew of puppy devourers. Surely, we are on the side of justice. You can tell because our courthouse says, “Guilty until proven innocent.”

Chris: Hmm. Very justice.

Oren: Uh-oh. Actually, wait. Maybe we’re the bad guys in this scenario. Is that possible, do you think, our very subtly named side could be the bad guys?

Chris: But see, if you didn’t eat puppies, then there would be puppies, and clearly that’s for evil.

Oren: Yeah, that just makes sense.

Chris: Maybe all good and evil is relative, man.

Oren: Yeah, we just need a balance, a balance between good and evil.

So today we are talking about heroes realizing that they are “the baddies” — AKA that one Mitchell and Webb skit from 2006. Which is funny because that, that skit is about two SS officers realizing they might be evil because they have very evil looking uniforms with skulls on them. And don’t get me wrong, that particular uniform does make for a very good, intimidating-looking villain. But it is worth noting that the skull as a military icon is not unique to the Nazis. It was actually quite popular–and it became less popular after World War II because of the Nazi connection–probably because soldiers kill people, and so a death symbol seemed kind of obvious.

Now, I’m not suggesting that things like the Totenkopf are not evil. They absolutely are. Don’t run for Senate if you have one tattooed on you.

Chris: Oh, gosh.

Oren: But I’m pointing out that historically, one of the reasons we think of them as symbols of evil is because of who they are associated with and so it adds a little bit of irony to that skit.

Chris: Mm-hmm. Interesting. The more you know.

Oren: Yeah. Dun, dun, dun, dun. Now, I actually tried to write an article about this, about having heroes who start off on Team Evil and then realize they’re the bad guys, and I realized I couldn’t because it’s actually not really a specific thing. It’s just basic character karma.

And, so once you realize that, it’s hard to write an article about it because at that point the only thing left to talk about is the bazillions of possible permutations that it could take in the story. But what else are podcasts for, if not talking about the bazillions of different permutations it could take inside a story?

Chris: Yep, yep, that’s where the podcast conversational mush really comes in handy.

Oren: Yeah, good. Thank you for the format, podcasting. But, the problem… the reason why this is something people think about is that if they want their hero to start on Team Evil, the problem is that they are on Team Evil, and that’s Bad.

And it’s not a problem for villains because it’s assumed that villains will be defeated at the end, and then when they are, the bad stuff isn’t really a big deal. Now, you do occasionally get stories that don’t have sufficiently bad things happen to their villains and that’s frustrating, but it’s not a huge problem. For one thing, most authors just kill the villain because that’s simplest, and that’ll get the job done. So, in this case, the author’s desire to tie up loose ends matches up with the karmic requirements of the story.

But in this case, you have a hero who starts off on Team Evil and they are at least related to some evil things. So, what happens when they decide that they’re not gonna be evil anymore?

Chris: Right. So, the question is: did they do anything bad while they were on Team Evil? Reasonably, they would have. Or there’s a scenario where no, they didn’t do anything bad, but that’s completely unbelievable and an “I don’t buy it” kind of a situation.

Oren: And, if they really didn’t do anything bad, it kind of feels like “why are you having them start on Team Evil” then, right? It feels like you’re not committing to the bit at that point.

Chris: Or are they on a Team Evil, where they’re going around saving cats while all of their teammates are kicking puppies? And it’s like, okay, why were they there? Didn’t they notice the rest of the team was kicking puppies? What did they think of that?

Oren: Right. Like, why are they the one good person who joined the evil recruiting squad? And I mean, if you want to, you can always come up with a situation where they aren’t really on Team Evil. They just happen to have to be there by circumstances. Like, your character could be the equivalent of the German communists who got swept up into the Wehrmacht and didn’t have any choice, and many of whom defected as soon as they could. They’re not really on Team Evil. Like, they didn’t have any other options. The really tragic one is the guy who defected to try to warn the Soviets of the German assault, and they didn’t listen to him. Poor guy.

Anyway, moving on from that. So that’s not really what most people are talking about when they imagine this sort of thing. They are imagining someone who actually believes that they are part of the right side, but they’re actually on the evil side. Otherwise, there isn’t really a realization moment.

Chris: Right. So, we think that we’re doing good, and then we learn–wait a second–maybe we’re the bad guys after all!

Oren: Yeah. And usually what you want is a situation where your character was involved in something but not, personally, with their own two hands inflicting horrible misery. For example, if your character is part of an invading army, that invasion is bad, but if the things we see them do are fight enemy soldiers, they’re probably not unforgivable because there’s an understanding that in a war you fight soldiers even if you’re on the wrong side. That’s not gonna be something that the audience will just never forgive them for doing.

Chris: Also, the assumption is that when you’re fighting the opposing side you don’t have a lot of time to stop and have deep conversations about who they are and what they believe to verify they’re a bad guy and that you’re the good guy. So, it’s just very easy for government propaganda to be like: “No, no, no, they’re the bad ones. You’re the good ones.” And if all you do is fight each other, how would you know better?

Oren: Right. And that’s also a common mitigation tactic, which is realistic, that you were told that they were evil, and that you were propagandized to, and you were convinced. And that also happens in real life. And that can insulate your character a little bit. Readers will be more understanding. But that, then, creates a problem of: “Well then, why–if they are so effectively propagandized–would they realize they are on Team Evil?”

Most soldiers in armies that we would consider to be evil do not desert when they start doing evil things, and it’s not because they were born evil, right? They were convinced to be part of the system through a number of means. So, what makes your character different?

Chris: Or else you get Drizzt.

Oren: Yeah, you could just have Drizzt.

Chris: I read those books so long time ago, the Drizzt trilogy. I don’t even remember what the trilogy was called, but it constantly bothered me the way that Drizzt just had inexplicable different cultural values than the culture he was raised in. Some people suggested, “Oh, well, his father was good and taught him.” I suppose that’s possible it happened somewhere off-screen, but it certainly wasn’t very present in the book. He’s also, for instance, into monogamy or other things besides like, “don’t kill innocents” that are just weird in his context.

Oren: Here’s the thing about Drizzt that is funny; Drizzt is part of a marginalized group within his society because he’s a man and the drow are, you know, big, evil, man-hating matriarchs who want to crush all men. Which is hot, but also evil. And so, actually, that does provide an interesting example of why he would not want to stay on Team Drow.

Because you can do that. You can have a character–it usually wouldn’t be men if you want your world-building to make any sense–but you could have a character who is, for example, part of a marginalized ethnic group within an empire. Even Avatar did this with that one river town, where they are clearly part of some… they are not sharing in the wealth of the Fire Nation, and so it makes sense that they are not as devoted to its cause.

What makes Drizzt weird is that he goes beyond that and also seems to have no cultural upbringing that the rest of the drow have, right?

Chris: Or, you know, what we would expect is a little bit more self-blame and guilt if he’s just inherently very compassionate and he’s taught to kill innocents, right? We would see more of a “Oh, I should be killing innocents” and “What’s wrong with me?” kind of an inner dialogue as opposed to just like: “No, that’s wrong.” That kind of thing. So that we can see, okay, what’s different is that he’s just inherently a little more compassionate and has a harder time doing this than the people around him. But he’s been still taught their values, and it’s gonna take time for him to kind of deprogram himself from those values.

It certainly is easier, though, for “We Are the Baddies,” if you do have a character who is kind of young and impressionable and perhaps is not out fighting yet, right? I think that definitely makes it easier to explain why they believe what they believe, how it is that they came to believe the wrong side is good, and then they haven’t really had enough experience to accumulate too much bad karma yet.

I think this is the tactic that we’re kinda trying to use for Fourth Wing… the only thing is that we have some unbelievable stuff in there. So, Violet grows up in a society where we have these dragon riders, and just like at dragon academy, you can kinda tell they must be the baddies because they’re killing off all of their cadets in dragon rider school when they could easily save them.

Oren: Yeah. I mean, I’ve only read the first Fourth Wing book and, I have to be honest, I don’t really know where the book thinks I should be drawing the moral lines here. The government is evil by any objective measure, but in the book, their biggest sin is that they are hiding the existence of an even worse enemy. Why are they doing that? I have no idea. So, at this point, anything’s possible if I was to read further into the series.

Chris: Again, usually an evil empire would want all of its citizens to know about another evil, because that’s an easy way to control them, being like, “Hey, you have to do what we want or the other evil will get you. But we can protect you. But you have to do what we want.”

Oren: It’s like imagining the Nazis pretending the Soviets didn’t exist. I’m not saying the Soviets are worse than the Nazis. I am saying that the Soviets are a genuine enemy that the Nazis had that they could use. It’d be so weird if they were propagandizing their people to be like, “There’s no such thing as communists. Don’t look for communists.” It would be so weird.

Chris, chuckling: Well, right-wingers today definitely want there to be as many communists as possible.

Oren: Right, they have to invent one, because there isn’t a real enemy for them to rally around, right? Imagine if there actually was one.

Chris: That would be quite the boon for them. Yeah, so [in Fourth Wing] this is really weird. And also, it’s just very difficult to cover up things like that. Like, in the Venin we have these mages that are super powerful. They’re not exactly subtle. And supposedly the dragon riders have been… well, maybe the idea is that they’re not fighting them, I think… and are just leaving the griffin riders to fight them and then making an enemy out of the griffin riders. It’s very strange.

Oren: At the end of Book One it could be anything, right? We just know it could be anything…. We just find out that there’s a super evil double enemy that’s been hidden this whole time, and how or why is a big set of question marks.

Chris: So, in any case, Violet is raised to believe Empire is good, the rebellion against the Empire was bad, and it’s reasonable that she believes that. And, controlling access to information of course, depending on what your bad group is. That could definitely happen, where people just have been deeply misinformed. In this case, it’s just a little strange because, again, it would be very difficult to cover up the presence of this particularly powerful enemy, and they wouldn’t even want to and that kind of ruins the effect. But otherwise, even the death that happened at the dragon academy is something that she could potentially be taught is justified in some way. And she doesn’t have to actively cause those deaths. She just has to stand by and not protest that they’re happening.

Oren:. A really interesting example is The Light Brigade by Cameron Hurley. To my mind this is like the gold standard of realizing “we are the baddies” type stories because it’s a main character. We’re not doing a dodge that a lot of stories do where the character who goes through this arc is a minor side villain, like Zuko, right? And Zuko of course is the main villain at the start, but he becomes less and less the most prominent villain as the show goes on. But he doesn’t have to be a main character for a long time, right? Whereas Dietz has to be a main character from the start and is deeply propagandized about how “the corporations are good, Martian separatists evil, do your bit for king and country–or money, dollar and country, I guess.”

And so the way that this works is that it takes an entire book to de-propagandize Dietz. And the way that Hurley manages it is by having Dietz be affected by this weird time-jumping thing that happens to her any time they use the teleporter to get into combat. This allows for Dietz to not ever do anything too bad. We never have to watch Dietz mow down a bunch of civilians, which I bet her squad mates absolutely did. Because any time that might happen, whoops, the time thing acted up again. Oh, oh, well. And it just works so well, and also the big selling point of the book is the time shifts. And it’s just a masterpiece. It is so good.

Chris: The other thing that I think is important to this story is the fact that we have our retelling-character-narrator. So we have future-Dietz telling what happened to past-Dietz. And that’s important because then when Dietz is like a fascist at the beginning of the story future-Dietz can be like, “Yeah, that, obviously I was wrong there.” I mean, it’s not said like that, but we can see the perspective is different, and so we have the narrator to assure us that no, of course what the protagonist currently thinks is bad, and the protagonist is gonna change their mind later. And then kind of some acknowledgement that this is bad. That really helps that kind of character go over better.

Oren: Now, let’s say that you, you don’t have a whole novel, right? You’re not as committed to the bit as Hurley is. A somewhat easy solution is to

Tous les épisodes de The Mythcreant Podcast

Paramètres

Affichage

Langue

Détermine les stations affichées en premier sur la page d’accueil.

Historique

Les stations et épisodes écoutés récemment et tes dernières recherches sont seulement enregistrés dans ce navigateur.

Notifications

Un court message quand un podcast que tu suis publie un nouvel épisode. Désactive un podcast précis avec la cloche sur sa page.

Compte

Enregistrez vos favoris – dans l’app et sur le site.

Raccourcis clavier

/
Ouvrir la recherche
Espace
Lecture ou pause
← →
Dans le lecteur : 15 s en arrière, 30 s en avant (épisodes) · dans une rangée : tuile suivante
↑ ↓
Dans une rangée : cible dans la tuile
Début / Fin
Dans une rangée : première ou dernière tuile
Esc
Fermer la fenêtre ou le menu
?
Cet aperçu
En cours de lecture

Voir la station

À suivre

    Ajoutez des épisodes avec « À suivre » – ils seront lus après l'épisode en cours.