
Cutting Class
Shownotes
We picked the 1989 comedy slasher ‘Cutting Class’ because we needed something lighter, and it turned into a confusing-but-entertaining watch loaded with tonal whiplash, juvenile jokes, and some genuinely memorable kills.
We talk about the oddball cast—especially a very young Brad Pitt—plus Jill Schoelen, Martin Mull, and Roddy McDowell, and why so many scenes feel bizarrely staged or played too straight for the gags. From killer POV moments and death-by-kiln to the Xerox kill and that trampoline flag impalement, the movie delivers creative set pieces even when the plot and character motivations don’t track. It’s not a good movie, but we still had fun with it and think it plays best with friends.
Expand to read episode transcript Automatic Transcript Cutting Class (1989)Episode 476, 2 Guys and a Chainsaw Horror Movie Review Podacst
Todd: Hello and welcome to another episode of Two Guys and a Chainsaw. I’m Todd. And
Craig: I’m Craig.
Todd: Well, this week it was my turn to pick and I thought we needed to go with something kind of light. I don’t know about you, but I’ve been just feeling a little weird and down lately. I think mostly it’s the news. I wasn’t in the mood for a real bleak horror movie or anything like that.
I wanted something that we could kind of have fun with. And I had this thing on my list that had been on my list for a while, and I don’t know if it was, uh, one of our more recent episodes that. Subconsciously spurred me to go back to this, but I chose 1989’s Cutting Class, and the reason I had this on my list is number one, at the time I put it on there, I had never heard of it before.
I knew I had never seen it before, but it has quite a lineup of stars in it, including a very, very, very young Brad Pitt.
Craig: Mm-hmm.
Todd: In one of his first screen rolls out, you know, outside of television. I didn’t really know much about it. I, I purposely went into this really not reading anything about it. I knew it was billed as a comedy slasher film, and so I kind of was figuring it would be like a horror comedy and I thought it would be fun and light for, and I imagined you hadn’t seen it before.
So had you seen it before?
Craig: I don’t remember. It’s surprise, it would surprise me if I hadn’t just because. Of the fact that Brad Pitt is in it. Not like I’m a huge Brad Pitt fan or anything, but I like watching these old horror movies with people who then went on to have a lot of fame.
Todd: Yeah, there’s so many.
Craig: Yeah. And, and there are, and there are other good people in this too. Not necessarily a-listers, but people, you’re definitely gonna recognize some of them more than others, but still. But if I have seen it. I didn’t remember it, so maybe I haven’t, ’cause I literally remembered nothing about it.
Todd: Okay, cool.
Yeah, so when I proposed it, you were, you weren’t just like, oh yeah, that one you just really didn’t, didn’t know.
Craig: No, no. I mean, I, I’ve known about it. I’ve been curious because it’s always shown up on those before they were stars horror movie lists.
Todd: Mm-hmm.
Craig: With like, you know, Matthew McConaughey and Renee Zellweger and George Clooney and a bazillion other people who did horror before.
Hitting it big. So I knew it existed and I had seen like maybe short clips of him in it, but I don’t think I’d seen it.
Todd: Okay, cool. Well, I’m so glad we’re talking about it because I had so much fun watching this. I have housemates with me right now for this month or so, and I told them I we’re watching a movie for the podcast if you wanna watch it.
And we had a blast laughing at this film. One of the biggest things I’m not quite sure of, I know it’s. It’s labeled as a horror comedy. I wasn’t sure how seriously we were supposed to take it. It is that bizarre.
Craig: It was hard. Yeah. I, I couldn’t, I couldn’t figure, I couldn’t figure out the balance either, because it’s not goofy funny most of the time, but then they throw in really goofy jokes and they kind of don’t land like they, it doesn’t match up tonally.
Todd: Yeah.
Craig: Like there’s a bunch of like dick jokes and stuff that kind of come out of nowhere and I’m like. Are we in the same movie like this is? I
Todd: know,
Craig: it’s weird.
Todd: It really is weird. You know, that’s the weird thing. You know, we’ve done movies before that we suspected were only labeled comedies after. They were received as comedies, movies that were meant to be serious, but they were so inept that they are quite silly.
And then later on it’s like, oh, we meant for it to be silly all along. Ha ha, we’ve done horror comedies that just weren’t very funny. Or like you said, like didn’t quite land. And of course a lot of the horror that we’ve covered is low budget and ineptly done, and it’s unintentionally funny, and that is its own.
You know, genre. I, I’m really not sure where this fits in, like you said it just because it’s just so tonally inconsistent throughout.
Craig: Yeah. Well this is the director’s first and only I think, directing credit, but he had done some serious stuff. Like didn’t he do like some writing on deliverance? I think maybe.
Todd: Yeah. He did some writing on, well, you’re talking about the right, yeah. The director was a additional crew on deliverance.
Craig: Okay. Okay.
Todd: The writer.
Craig: The writer. Well, what I was going to say, we’re talking, you’re talking about like the, the humor and the jokes and stuff the writer went on to do salute your shorts.
Yeah. And I think that that tells you everything that you need to know. Maybe about the humor here.
Todd: Yeah.
Craig: It’s kind of juvenile humor and I don’t know why it’s, doesn’t land. I think some of it, I don’t know. I think it’s a combination of a lot of things. The direction, the acting. It’s just like they, they’re, they’re not sure of what tone they’re going for.
Todd: Yeah. Oddly enough, the director, this is only his. Second movie. He’s uncredited as a director on Exorcist two.
Craig: Okay.
Todd: Both a writer and a director. I’m not sure what that means. You know, you never, you, you wonder what his involvement was if he was uncredited Right,
Craig: right.
Todd: Of his second unit director. He did little things like who knows what he did, but this was his only movie that he’s ever directed since then.
Although he did write screenplay for Excalibur and the Emerald Forest. Two movies I’m, I’m familiar with, but. That’s about it. So yeah, the, these two guys who wrote it and directed it didn’t really go on to do anything else we can judge this against necessarily, except, like you said, salute your shorts.
Craig: And I liked salute your shorts, but it was really, I mean, the whole point of it was it was juvenile, it’s
Todd: dumb,
Craig: right?
Todd: But this isn’t that either, so,
Craig: but it is in places. Okay, so this is also like the third Jill Solan movie. We’ve done an. In a row, like, I don’t know.
Todd: Yeah, I swear. Total coincidence.
Craig: It’s crazy.
She’s the lead in this movie, also Uhhuh, and her name is Paula, and she was reluctant to do the movie because she didn’t like the script, but I guess she was. Uh, brought in because she heard that Martin Mull and who’s the other big guy? Roddy McDowell.
Todd: Roddy McDowell. Yeah.
Craig: We’re both going to be in it.
Todd: We probably know him best from Fright Night.
He was the, like the washed up actor, a horror host in that one. And, but I mean, he’s a veteran.
Craig: Yeah. And he’s done a million things.
Todd: Yeah. He is a veteran of the, of the stage and screen. Like he’s,
Craig: and, and Martin Muell is a veteran comedic actor. Right? You know? Uh
Todd: oh. Yeah.
Craig: He’s done all of the like, oh, I can’t think of the guy’s name, but the Guffman Best in show type movies and mm-hmm.
He was on Roseanne and stuff. Hilarious. And these guys, like I said, not necessarily a-list, but reputable actors that people would definitely know. So I could understand why. She’d be like, okay, I’ll do, if they’re gonna do it, I’ll do it. Yeah.
Todd: Yeah.
Craig: I wish that she. Had a crystal ball and could have seen into the future what these guys were going to do in this movie, because I think she would’ve reconsidered it.
Todd: Yeah,
Craig: there’s, there’s one point in the movie where Roddy McDowell is in a, like a Chiquita banana wig looking into a mirror and he says, what are you doing? And I’m like, that is exactly right. What are you doing Roddy Mcow doing in this movie? Wow. That must’ve been a good check. Oh, it must’ve been a good check for a day’s work for each of them.
Todd: Oh my God. I was so embarrassed for Roddy McDowell in this. Not that he performed poorly. No, but what he was given to do was just like, I can’t even begin to describe it. We will eventually, but yeah. Very strange. Uh, and, and I wanted to even think, is this supposed to be parod? Slasher. Is this supposed to be like a, a comedy in that it’s a parodying slasher films?
I don’t know. It’s just so weird. The dialogue is strange too. You know, the opening credits are just like five minutes of this guy, of this paper boy throwing papers and eventually we get in on Paula and her dad. As you said,
Clip: Martin Mul Bill,
Todd: one of the, one of the first lines of the whole movie is he comes out and she’s like.
Daddy, he asked her to go. If she wants to come hunting with him or something, he’s gonna go hunting for like a week.
Clip: Honey, this is the first time I’ve left you alone,
Bernie. I should be worried. Daddy, you are a great district attorney, but you’re a lousy hunter,
Todd: Jesus Christ, and he ends up going on his little hunting trip by himself and some unknown person shoots him with an arrow in the chest and he falls down in the swamp.
Craig: Yeah, this is, these are the first minutes of the movie and I. Thought, wow. Martin Mole was smart. Like, yeah, sign on for that. Get the check. I thought, I can’t believe they’re killing off the dad in the first scene. But it’s, and and just describing it doesn’t do it in any justice ’cause it’s all goofy. Like, yeah, he’s dressed ridiculously in, you know, all this hunting gear and like he wants to bag a mallard and he goes to like the bait shop and they.
Rub dirt on him, so he’ll smell like, like, it’s just all very silly.
Todd: Yeah. There’s a character there who we never see again, who, it seems like they’re setting him up for something. Right. He takes him outside and he smears dirt on him and whatnot, and, and then we don’t, I don’t think we ever see that guy again.
It, yeah, it’s very silly.
Craig: I, but I’m reading it in my notes and I’m thinking the way that it’s reading on the page, it sounds. Like a spoof, but it’s not shot like one, like it’s shot. Seriously. Like. Then we’re introduced to Dwight, played by a very young Brad Pitt, and he’s just the pretty douche bag from all of these movies and he drives his fast car around and he almost runs over a little kid and then like jokes about it.
Todd: Yeah. That was a strangely set up scene. Ugh. I mean, it was, it was just kind of dumb, right? The little kid on his Hot Wheels, who comes right out into the middle of the road, like you can see where this is going a mile away, and then he’s at school and his friend Brian is there and they exchanged some looks and I thought, okay, this is this guy.
They don’t like each other. Like Brad Pitts the nice guy Brian is.
Craig: The broody.
Todd: Brad Pitts the douche bag. Yeah. Brian’s the moody dude. And they both kind of are interested in Paula because Brian keeps giving her these looks, which are actually kind of creepy.
Craig: Yeah, super creepy.
Todd: And Brian is climbing the rope and Dwight comes over and as he starts yanking the rope around to mess with Brian and Brian falls off the rope and the dick coach comes over and yells at Brian.
For falling off the rope, I guess.
Craig: Yeah.
Todd: And then later there at a hotdog place, one of those places where you could park and eat. This whole seed was ridiculous.
Craig: I know, that’s what I’m saying. Like the right, like it seems like, I don’t know. Okay. So imagine this. Imagine you take Jill Solan out of this role and you put a young Anna Ferris in it.
I think that if they had played the comedy up more. It wouldn’t have been a lot more funny, but they’re just playing it straight. So when, when, I don’t know. Brad Pitt shows up and there’s some banter about her wanting his ring. Yeah. But he can, he’ll never give up his family ring or something. And he’s like, I’m gonna go get some food.
Do you want anything? And she’s like, yeah, I’m really in the mood for a hot dog. What?
Todd: The way she says it, right?
Craig: She says it kind of suggestively, but not really funny.
Todd: Not suggestively enough. Yeah.
Craig: To be funny and right. And then she
Kapitel
Kapitel werden geladen …
Alle Folgen von 2 Guys And A Chainsaw – A Horror Movie Review Podcast