
A Closer Look At Target-Date Funds: You Won't Believe What We Found! | David Brown & Shaun Davies | 246
Shownotes
Finance professors Shaun Davies, PhD, CFA and David Brown, PhD join the show to give us a look under the hood of target-date funds (TDFs). What they found may surprise you! Their research reveals enormous differences in fees, risk, glide paths, active management, and performance; even among funds carrying the exact same retirement year. But this isn't a target-date-fund takedown. TDFs have helped millions of people get invested, stay invested, and avoid some bad behavioral decisions. The real question is whether yours is actually doing what you think it is. Bill also brings on Jesse Cramer of Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors to join this important conversation.
This episode covers:
- What a target-date fund actually owns and how its glide path changes over time
- Why two funds with the same target year can produce dramatically different results
- How fees and poor active management contributed to historical TDF underperformance
- Why a fund's risk level may matter more than matching its date to your expected retirement year
- What late starters and FIRE investors should consider when choosing a TDF vintage
- Why the target-date-fund industry still lacks a useful universal benchmark
- How Glidepath Financial's replicating-fund approach compares TDFs against low-cost passive alternatives
- The life-cycle investing idea that your future earnings effectively behave like a bond
- Why TDFs can still be powerful behavioral tools despite their imperfections
- Collective investment trusts, retirement decumulation, annuities, private assets, and where TDFs may go next
.
=== SUPPORT THE SHOW ===
🌐 Visit Catching Up to FI website
☕ Like what you hear on Catching Up to FI? Support the show at "Buy Me a Coffee"
🎙️We love hearing from you! Record a Voice Message with your feedback or question Record a Voice Message with your feedback or question
.
===DEALS & DISCOUNTS FROM OUR TRUSTED PARTNERS===
NEW! Mama Are We Poor?"Mama Are We Poor?" is a new childrens' book by co-host, Dr. Bill Yount and past guest, Monica Scudieri. They teamed up after the interview on episode #120 in 2025. Monica shared a sweet moment she had with her son and he asked here the question "Mama are we poor". Almost two years later, they collaborated to create a heartfelt, beautifully illustrated picture book that helps parents and caregivers open up conversations about money, financial stress, and family resilience with young readers. Through a child's eyes, kids learn that worth isn't measured in dollars-and that love, stability, and gratitude can carry a family through hard times.
.
F.I.R.E. For Dummies
Co-host Jackie Cummings Koski, CFP®, AFC® is author of "F.I.R.E. For Dummies". This is the perfect guide for anyone looking to move from the basics of their finances to reaching F.I.R.E. (Financial Independence, Retire Early) and enjoying the time freedom it creates. Even if you feel behind on your finances, the steps in this book will help you catch up sooner than you ever imagined.
📕 Get Your Copy (currently 40% off on Amazon)
.
For a full list of current deals and discounts from our partners, sponsors and affiliates, click here: catchinguptofi.com/our-partners
.
RESOURCES MENTIONED ON THE SHOW
Off Target: On the Underperformance of Target-Date Funds
Glidepath Financial (compare target-date funds)
.
⏰ Related Episodes
The Biggest Retirement Mistake: Over Saving and Under Living | Rachael Camp & Jesse Cramer | 198
Space Telescopes, Sunflowers, and Financial Gardening | Jesse Cramer | 105
How to Bake a Cake: An Asset Allocation Mashup | Rick Ferri & Paul Merriman | 134
.
CHAPTERS:
0:00 Intro
4:00 How target-date funds became America's default
7:00 What's really under the hood
10:00 The 1% problem
14:00 Risk differences
18:00 How to choose a TDF
27:00 Human capital as a bond
35:00 The ten building blocks
38:00 Do we even need bonds?
44:00 The behavioral case for TDFs
56:00 Glidepath ratings
.
📌Disclaimer: Our content is for general education and information purposes only. We are not providing financial, legal, or tax advice. Always do your own research or consult a professional before making important decisions.