
216. How to Get Buy-In From Skeptics at Work
Shownotes
How do you get buy-in for a change you believe in when the people around you doubt it? In this episode of Communicate to Lead, Kele Belton explains how to earn support from skeptics by asking for their objections first, and shares four steps for bringing them along.
In This Episode
Skeptics are often more useful than they seem: the person pushing back may be thinking about their workload, expertise, or future. Kele walks the four steps through two examples — one on your team, one with a peer — and one of them ends in a way you might not expect. Listen for the everyday comparison that changes how you see the skeptic in the room.
What you will learn
- Why the person pushing back on a change may be pointing to something your plan needs
- How asking for objections first changes the conversation
- Four steps for getting buy-in from skeptics at work
- How to respond when someone challenges your plan in a meeting
- How to close the loop so people can see their input mattered
- How to get buy-in from a peer when you can’t rely on your authority
- How to raise concerns about a change without being labeled negative
- How to move forward when not everyone agrees
Your Action Step
Think of one change you’re leading. Before the next meeting, talk with the person you expect to push back hardest, using the first two steps.
Common Questions About Getting Buy-In at Work
How do you get buy-in from a peer you have no authority over?
Involve the peer in designing the change instead of presenting a finished plan. Ask how it would affect their team, adjust to reduce their workload, and propose a limited trial you agree on together.
Do you need everyone’s agreement before moving forward?
No, but two questions need separate answers: does this person support the change, and have the risks they raised been addressed? Address what matters, explain your decision, and pause if a serious risk remains.
AI Prompt: Prepare for a Conversation With a Skeptic
Use this after listening. Remove names and confidential details before pasting it into an AI tool.
You are my executive communication coach. Help me prepare for a one-on-one conversation with someone who has doubts about a change I’m leading. Ask me these questions one at a time: (1) What is the change, and what is still open to their input? (2) Who is this person, and how does their role relate to mine? (3) What have they said about the change so far?
Then help me with three things. First, list the concerns they might have, about the plan itself and about what it could mean for them. Treat these as possibilities to explore in the conversation, not conclusions about what they think. Second, draft three or four open questions I can ask to understand their concern. Third, suggest how I could open the conversation in two or three sentences, and what a small trial of the change could test.
Constraints: Keep the tone warm, direct, and professional. Do not write lines that try to persuade or reassure them before I’ve listened. After the draft, ask me which words don’t sound like me, and help me revise until it sounds like I wrote it myself.
Example (output style): “I’m working on a change to how we handle our monthly reporting, and I’d value your input before it’s set. What am I missing?”
Mentioned in This Episode
- Episode 146: Communicating Change: How to Lead a Strategy You Did Not Choose
- Episode 175: How to Stop Defending Your Decisions at Work
Ready to Go Deeper?
If you’re leading change where trust is thin, that is the work Kele does with her clients.
Book your free Leadership Strategy Call
About Your Host
Kele Belton is a communication and leadership facilitator, coach, and consultant, and the host of Communicate to Lead. Through her company, The Tailored Approach, she helps high-performing women in middle and senior management move from essential but invisible to seen, sponsored, and promoted.
Connect With Kele
- LinkedIn: Kele Belton
- Instagram: @thetailoredapproach
- Website: The Tailored Approach