
The Babysitter Who Killed the Girl She Wanted to Become
Shownotes
The Babysitter Who Killed the Girl She Wanted to Become
A sixteen-year-old was found buried in a pet cemetery with a telephone cord around her neck, on land owned by the family of the woman who had once babysat her younger siblings. The killer didn't hate her — she wanted to be her. How does admiration curdle into a plan to erase someone and step into their life?
In this episode, we analyze the murder of aspiring dancer Rachel Barber in Melbourne and the obsession behind it. We examine the three phone calls the day before she vanished, the police who dismissed her as a runaway, the burial among pets, and the chilling transformation the killer underwent in prison. What does it cost when a missing teenage girl is assumed to have simply left?
Victim: Rachel Barber
Age: 15 (16 when found)
Date: March 5, 1999
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Perpetrator: Caroline Robertson (former babysitter)
Outcome: Pleaded guilty to murder; sentenced to 20 years (minimum 14.5)
- Rachel Barber, a 15-year-old aspiring Broadway dancer, vanished after leaving her dance studio on March 5, 1999.
- Police initially treated her as a runaway and pointed at her boyfriend, despite a diary that showed no sign of trouble.
- Her body was found buried in a pet cemetery on a rural property owned by the father of Caroline Robertson, a former babysitter to the family.
- Psychiatric evaluation found Caroline had an identity-based obsession with Rachel and wanted to erase her and take over her life.
- Caroline pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 20 years; in prison she lost weight and dyed her hair blonde, coming to resemble Rachel, before her 2015 release.
Tired of ads? Listen to this podcast and 200+ more ad-free on OBOMEDIA.
Try it free for 7 days, cancel anytime: https://obomedia.com/en/gratis?ref=desc-7132489
OBOMEDIA presents true crime storiesa true crime podcast built on real cases.
Every true crime story in our crime files follows the crime investigation from the missing person report to the trial: investigators and police building a murder case, a police investigation gone cold, justice for the victim and those who survived.
We open the unsolved murder, the cold case reopened decades later, the mysterious death, the disappearance, the serial killer, the family murder, the murder mystery; the missing persons a missing woman, a missing girl, a missing man found dead and the missing and murdered.
From the infamous case to the unsolved case, from classic true crime to dark true crime and disturbing true crime: true crime reports, real crime stories, real murder cases, true murder stories and unsolved mysteries one true crime case at a time, from the OBOMEDIA true crime vault.
© 2026 Created by an independent creator of the OBOMEDIA Network, who owns and is solely responsible for this content. All rights reserved. Reproduction or commercial use without the creator's written permission is prohibited. Business: [email protected].
A sixteen-year-old was found buried in a pet cemetery with a telephone cord around her neck, on land owned by the family of the woman who had once babysat her younger siblings. The killer didn't hate her — she wanted to be her. How does admiration curdle into a plan to erase someone and step into their life?
In this episode, we analyze the murder of aspiring dancer Rachel Barber in Melbourne and the obsession behind it. We examine the three phone calls the day before she vanished, the police who dismissed her as a runaway, the burial among pets, and the chilling transformation the killer underwent in prison. What does it cost when a missing teenage girl is assumed to have simply left?
Victim: Rachel Barber
Age: 15 (16 when found)
Date: March 5, 1999
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Perpetrator: Caroline Robertson (former babysitter)
Outcome: Pleaded guilty to murder; sentenced to 20 years (minimum 14.5)
- Rachel Barber, a 15-year-old aspiring Broadway dancer, vanished after leaving her dance studio on March 5, 1999.
- Police initially treated her as a runaway and pointed at her boyfriend, despite a diary that showed no sign of trouble.
- Her body was found buried in a pet cemetery on a rural property owned by the father of Caroline Robertson, a former babysitter to the family.
- Psychiatric evaluation found Caroline had an identity-based obsession with Rachel and wanted to erase her and take over her life.
- Caroline pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 20 years; in prison she lost weight and dyed her hair blonde, coming to resemble Rachel, before her 2015 release.
Tired of ads? Listen to this podcast and 200+ more ad-free on OBOMEDIA.
Try it free for 7 days, cancel anytime: https://obomedia.com/en/gratis?ref=desc-7132489
OBOMEDIA presents true crime storiesa true crime podcast built on real cases.
Every true crime story in our crime files follows the crime investigation from the missing person report to the trial: investigators and police building a murder case, a police investigation gone cold, justice for the victim and those who survived.
We open the unsolved murder, the cold case reopened decades later, the mysterious death, the disappearance, the serial killer, the family murder, the murder mystery; the missing persons a missing woman, a missing girl, a missing man found dead and the missing and murdered.
From the infamous case to the unsolved case, from classic true crime to dark true crime and disturbing true crime: true crime reports, real crime stories, real murder cases, true murder stories and unsolved mysteries one true crime case at a time, from the OBOMEDIA true crime vault.
© 2026 Created by an independent creator of the OBOMEDIA Network, who owns and is solely responsible for this content. All rights reserved. Reproduction or commercial use without the creator's written permission is prohibited. Business: [email protected].