
That Wasn't Kevin: The Key, The Cat, The Other Thing
Shownotes
That Wasn't Kevin: The Key, The Cat, The Other Thing
A newspaper about break-ins, a missing toothbrush, and a key that shouldn't exist. These ordinary objects appear in a man's apartment, each one a chilling sign that something is terribly wrong. What happened to his neighbors, the Marshalls, and why do these everyday items hold such a sinister secret?
In this episode, we delve into a man's unsettling account from January 11, 2016, as he recounts the strange events leading up to the disappearance of his neighbors. We explore the inexplicable occurrences that defied rational explanation and left him questioning everything he knew about his home and the people around him.
Person: Kevin Marshall
Person: Sarah Marshall
Date: December 10, 2015
Date: January 11, 2016
Location: Two-story rental complex
- On Tuesday, December 10, a newspaper about neighborhood break-ins appeared on his kitchen counter.
- On Wednesday, December 11, his toothbrush, always in the same spot, vanished from his bathroom.
- Kevin Marshall had not been to work for several days by Wednesday evening.
- On Thursday, December 12, at 6:43 AM, he found an unfamiliar key in his gym bag.
- The key fit the Marshalls' front door with a smooth, effortless click.
Tired of ads? Listen to this podcast and 200+ more ad-free on OBOMEDIA.
Try it free for 7 days, cancel anytime: https://obomedia.com/en/gratis?ref=desc-7141101
OBOMEDIA presents real horror stories a scary story podcast for the late night hours.
Every episode is horror narration done right: true scary stories and horror stories based on true events, told from the first chilling minute. Expect disturbing true stories, disturbing horror stories and dark true horror stories drawn from real testimonies.
Some nights bring camping horror stories, forest horror stories and road horror stories; others bring home alone horror stories, haunted stories, eerie stories, strange stories and unsettling tales true creepy stories and creepy encounters that never made the news.
Press play on our late night horror stories and late night scary stories, from storytime horror to a full horror stories compilation or scary stories compilation real scary stories, scary stories based on true events, and dark stories to keep the lights on.
© 2026 Created by an independent creator of the OBOMEDIA Network, who owns and is solely responsible for this content. All rights reserved. Reproduction or commercial use without the creator's written permission is prohibited. Business: [email protected].
A newspaper about break-ins, a missing toothbrush, and a key that shouldn't exist. These ordinary objects appear in a man's apartment, each one a chilling sign that something is terribly wrong. What happened to his neighbors, the Marshalls, and why do these everyday items hold such a sinister secret?
In this episode, we delve into a man's unsettling account from January 11, 2016, as he recounts the strange events leading up to the disappearance of his neighbors. We explore the inexplicable occurrences that defied rational explanation and left him questioning everything he knew about his home and the people around him.
Person: Kevin Marshall
Person: Sarah Marshall
Date: December 10, 2015
Date: January 11, 2016
Location: Two-story rental complex
- On Tuesday, December 10, a newspaper about neighborhood break-ins appeared on his kitchen counter.
- On Wednesday, December 11, his toothbrush, always in the same spot, vanished from his bathroom.
- Kevin Marshall had not been to work for several days by Wednesday evening.
- On Thursday, December 12, at 6:43 AM, he found an unfamiliar key in his gym bag.
- The key fit the Marshalls' front door with a smooth, effortless click.
Tired of ads? Listen to this podcast and 200+ more ad-free on OBOMEDIA.
Try it free for 7 days, cancel anytime: https://obomedia.com/en/gratis?ref=desc-7141101
OBOMEDIA presents real horror stories a scary story podcast for the late night hours.
Every episode is horror narration done right: true scary stories and horror stories based on true events, told from the first chilling minute. Expect disturbing true stories, disturbing horror stories and dark true horror stories drawn from real testimonies.
Some nights bring camping horror stories, forest horror stories and road horror stories; others bring home alone horror stories, haunted stories, eerie stories, strange stories and unsettling tales true creepy stories and creepy encounters that never made the news.
Press play on our late night horror stories and late night scary stories, from storytime horror to a full horror stories compilation or scary stories compilation real scary stories, scary stories based on true events, and dark stories to keep the lights on.
© 2026 Created by an independent creator of the OBOMEDIA Network, who owns and is solely responsible for this content. All rights reserved. Reproduction or commercial use without the creator's written permission is prohibited. Business: [email protected].