
What All the President's Men Didn't Show You About Watergate
Shownotes
Do you think you know the Watergate story?
Most people know Watergate from All the President's Men: two reporters at The Washington Post and a president brought down. Far fewer know who the burglars were, why they went into the Democratic National Committee headquarters, or why some of the investigators still suspect the break-in was sabotaged from the inside. The Watergate Caper: Richard Nixon and the Death of the American Dream, the archival documentary from Shane O'Sullivan narrated by Harry Shearer, tells that story through the news footage, hearings, songs and movies of the Nixon era.
In Episode 289, Christian sits down with Shane O'Sullivan, an Irish filmmaker and author based in London who heads Film and Photography at Kingston School of Art. Shane explains why he thinks Woodward and Bernstein get too much credit for solving Watergate, and why, in his telling, the FBI case agent and the federal prosecutor did the real investigating. He built the film from the Nixon Library's off-air news recordings, working mostly from London.
Shane walks through how he wove movies like Medium Cool, The Conversation and The Ice Storm through the news footage and hearings, set the All the President's Men version of the burglary against real witness testimony, why Harry Shearer works as a bridge rather than a conventional narrator, and how fair use clearance counsel helped him justify long movie clips. He also lays out the questions that still hang over the break-in: the tape left on the doors, why James McCord, the Nixon campaign's own head of security, went in himself, and why anyone would take the risk when Richard Nixon was already ahead of George McGovern in the polls.
WATCH THE FILM: The Watergate Caper: Richard Nixon and the Death of the American Dream is available to rent or buy on Amazon, Apple TV, Fandango at Home and Google Play.
In this episode, you'll learn:
- What Howard Hunt told the Cuban burglars to get them on board
- How a four-hour first cut became a 105-minute film
- Shane's advice for filmmakers: find an archive no one has fully used
CHAPTERS
0:00 The Watergate Caper Trailer
2:49 From RFK to Nixon
7:46 All the President's Men Myth
13:49 Harry Shearer and Medium Cool
17:57 When Movies Mirrored Watergate
23:47 Archival Footage and Fair Use
30:05 Dick Cavett and Howard Baker
32:46 The 18½-Minute Gap
37:22 Was the Break-In Sabotaged?
43:56 Advice for Archival Filmmakers
48:43 Sherman's March and Remake
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
How was the Watergate break-in discovered?
A security guard found tape on the doors that kept the locks from latching. According to filmmaker Shane O'Sullivan, the guard thought little of it the first time, but when he came back later and found it again, he called the police, who went up and arrested the burglars. O'Sullivan says one of the key questions is whether the tape was left on purpose to sabotage the operation.
Was the Watergate break-in sabotaged?
Some of the investigators think it may have been. Shane O'Sullivan says FBI case agent Angelo Lano still believes James McCord or Howard Hunt made mistakes on purpose to expose Nixon. McCord, the Nixon campaign's head of security and a former head of physical security at the CIA, left tape on the doors and went in himself, knowing he would be identified if caught. O'Sullivan says the question is still open.
How accurate is All the President's Men?
Shane O'Sullivan calls All the President's Men one of his favorite films, but says people shouldn't take it as a literal primer on Watergate. In his view, Woodward and Bernstein get too much credit. He says the FBI case agent and the federal prosecutor did the investigating, and leaks to the press helped The Washington Post keep the story in the news.
DOCUVIEW DEJA VIEW PICKS
Shane's picks are a Ross McElwee double bill. Sherman's March (1986) follows McElwee through the South in the path of General Sherman's march, an odyssey that Shane says opened up his mind about what a film could be. Remake (2025) is McElwee's newest film, about trying to remake Sherman's March as a fiction film and about his relationship with his son. Every guest pick is in one place.
SPONSORED BY VIRGIL FILMS ENTERTAINMENT
This episode is brought to you by Virgil Films Entertainment, distributor of Super Size Me and the Oscar-nominated Restrepo, with over 25 years of distribution experience. https://virgilfilms.com
LISTEN AND FOLLOW
Listen and subscribe wherever you get podcasts
SUPPORT THE SHOW
CONNECT WITH DOCUMENTARY FIRST
ABOUT THE GUEST
Shane O'Sullivan
Shane O'Sullivan is an Irish filmmaker who has lived in London for 30 years. His films include RFK Must Die and Children of the Revolution. His book on the burglars, first published as Dirty Tricks: Nixon, Watergate and the CIA, is now The Watergate Burglars. He directed, produced and edited The Watergate Caper.
The film | The book | LinkedIn | Instagram | X
ABOUT DOCUMENTARY FIRST
Documentary First is a weekly podcast about the people behind documentaries and how the work changed them. Host Christian Taylor, director of the award-winning The Girl Who Wore Freedom, talks with filmmakers, distributors, entertainment lawyers, actors and more, from Ken Burns and PBS American Masters creator Susan Lacy to first-timers, across nearly 300 conversations. Each week brings one of two formats: a long-form conversation with the people behind films for HBO, Netflix, PBS and independent film, or The Deep Dive, where Christian takes one insight from a recent conversation and follows it wherever it leads. Listen Notes ranks the show in the top 5% of all podcasts worldwide. New episodes every week.
RESOURCES MENTIONED
Make Film History (BBC and BFI archive)
Nixon Library WHCA video collection
Photo of Fred Thompson and Howard Baker by a U.S. Senate photographer, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Photo of a Nixon White House tape recorder by Travis Wise, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Photo of Roscoe Lee Browne, Peter Bonerz and others reading the Watergate tape transcripts by Marianna Diamos, Los Angeles Times, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Kapitel (11)
Alle Folgen von Documentary First: Conversations on Documentary Filmmaking