
Atheist Tries on Christianity – Stuart Tettemer’s Story | Ep. 157
Shownotes
What happens when the worldview you embraced no longer seems capable of explaining the world you experience?
For Stuart Tettemer, atheism wasn't a rebellion against God. It was simply the conclusion that seemed most reasonable. Raised in a Christian home, Stuart gradually drifted away from faith and eventually embraced atheism, finding intellectual confidence in the arguments of the New Atheists and a materialistic understanding of reality.
But over time, unanswered questions began to emerge.
Could consciousness be explained by matter alone? If free will is an illusion, what becomes of morality and responsibility? And why did a life centered on success and achievement leave him increasingly unsatisfied?
🎙️ Love the show? Support the mission and explore eX-skeptic merch here: https://ex-skeptic-shop.fourthwall.com/
Guest Bio:Stuart Tettemer is the Mayor of Panama City Beach, Florida. A graduate of Cornell University with degrees in Information Science and Computer Science, Stuart spent years working as a software engineer in Silicon Valley and with technology startups before returning to Florida.
Today, he is passionate about community, discipleship, and helping others discover the truth and beauty of the Christian faith.
Resources Mentioned:eX-skeptic Guides: https://exskeptic.org/bookstore/
Chapters00:00 Intro 02:00 - Meet Former Atheist Stuart Tettemer 04:20 - Growing Up Christian and Drifting Away 08:46 - Why He Accepted Atheism Without Question 12:59 - How Science Shaped His Worldview 15:14 - Can Atheism Explain Life's Meaning? 18:54 - The Mind-Body Problem and Consciousness 21:06 - Can Free Will Exist Without God? 23:16 - Exploring Buddhism and Meditation 25:09 - Why Success and Wealth Weren't Enough 27:45 - The Sam Harris Argument That Changed Everything 30:06 - Discovering Eastern Orthodox Christianity 34:09 - Practicing Christianity Before Believing 41:02 - Finding Community Through Bible Study 43:18 - How Serving Others Transformed His Faith 46:49 - Are We Both Physical and Spiritual? 49:48 - Recognizing God's Pursuit of Him 51:11 - Why Evidence Still Requires a Step of Faith 54:04 - How to Help Skeptics Discover Christianity 01:00:57 - The Transformative Reality of Faith 01:49:59 - Closing
Connect with eX-skeptic:Website: https://exskeptic.org/
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/exskeptic
Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/exskeptic
Twitter: http://x.com/exskeptic
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@exskeptic
Email info: [email protected]
eX-skeptic TranscriptEp. 157
November 6, 2026