
Ep 434: Why index investing is so hard to beat
Shownotes
A handful of stocks deliver most of the market’s return, and no one can pick them in advance. That’s why owning the whole market wins. The evidence that index funds beat active managers is well established. In this episode, I explain why, through three observations about how markets behave:
- In developed markets, what you don’t own hurts you. Just 2% of 64,000 shares studied created all the wealth over three decades.
- Volatility is normal. The average intra-year fall is 14% in Australia and 16% in the US, even though most years end positive.
- Most of the return comes on a few days, and those days often arrive shortly after the worst ones.
I also cover the gap between fund returns and what investors actually earn, when I’d invest monthly vs as a lump sum, and why emerging markets and smaller companies need a more selective approach.
00:00 Introduction: why indexing works and why it’s hard to beat
01:02 The SPIVA reports
02:00 Why investors still hold a few direct shares
03:10 Eating my own cooking
04:00 Three observations about how markets behave
04:52 What you don’t own hurts you: 2% of stocks created all the wealth
06:08 Australia: eight companies, almost half the wealth
07:05 FY24: five stocks, two-thirds of the return
07:59 Could you have picked them in advance?
08:39 The Magnificent Seven
09:25 What happens once a stock reaches the top 10
10:35 Buy the whole haystack
11:15 Timing and turnover costs
11:47 Volatility is normal: intra-year declines
12:59 2025: down 19% by April, up 18% by year end
13:39 Using falls to your advantage with regular investing
14:26 Why the first three to four years can mislead
15:09 Why a 20% fall wouldn’t surprise me
16:19 Most returns come in a few days
17:35 Missing the 10 best days in the S&P 500
18:09 The best days often follow the worst
19:31 Reframing falls as an opportunity
20:42 The behaviour gap: 9.9% vs 8.7%
21:36 Why “this time is different” is always the headline
23:10 Monthly investing vs lump sums
24:04 The value of optionality
24:33 Emerging markets and small companies: what you do own can hurt
25:46 Factor-based investing in those markets
26:37 Summing up: three reasons indexing wins
27:55 How many active managers fail to beat the index
28:10 Coming up: does indexing distort markets, and does factor investing pay?
Related episodes:
Ep 403: Lump sum share market investing: risky or rational
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/18951456-ep-403-lump-sum-share-market-investing-risky-or-rational
Ep 433: ASX 200 or global shares: Where to put new money
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/20053844-ep-433-asx-200-or-global-shares-where-to-put-new-money
Ep 430: Is financial advice worth it? What rules can’t fix.
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19923707-ep-430-is-financial-advice-worth-it-what-rules-can-t-fix
Q&A - ETF portfolio construction at 28: is 8.4% too low?
https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19978320-q-a-etf-portfolio-construction-at-28-is-8-4-too-low
Read Stuart's latest book? He's only got 19 reviews on Amazon so far, if Wealth by Design helped you, leaving one would mean a lot: https://www.amazon.com.au/review/create-review?asin=192318654X
Run your own business?
Check out Business by Design, Stuart and Mena's show on starting, growing and exiting a business, at https://www.businessbydesignpodcast.com/
Our most popular free guides:
Over the years we've written hundreds of articles. These three bring our best thinking together on the topics that matter most right now: choosing a super fund, debt recycling, and navigating the new tax changes.
Got a question for the podcast?
Email us at [email protected]
Subscribe to my weekly blog:
Important
This podcast provides general information about finance, tax and credit. It doesn't take into account your specific objectives, financial situation or needs, so you need to assess whether it's relevant to your circumstances before acting on it. If you're not sure, speak to a licensed, trustworthy professional.