
What Makes a Bass Player Sound Professional?
Shownotes
Disclosure: These show notes were created from a transcript of the episode using chatgpt to a) give me an extra hour to practice today, b) give you as much detailed information about my conversation with IMA, and c) keep me motivated to keep coming back to the creative side of making videos and having interesting conversations with guests while not dreading the post-production minutiae that I’m simply no good at.
Ian Martin Allison and I sat down with our basses for a conversation that began with making mistakes and ended with both of us admitting we sometimes need to get out of our own way.
In between, we talked about a question that comes up constantly in lessons, rehearsals, recording sessions, and gigs: what actually makes a bass player sound professional?
There are obvious answers involving time, sound, preparation, and technique. But the more we talked, the more we found ourselves discussing the decisions underneath all of that. Where does a note end? How much energy should you give a verse? Are you leaving another musician somewhere to go? And what happens to your playing when you become preoccupied with proving you’re good?
Ian is wonderfully open throughout this conversation. There’s plenty of playing, some excellent sounds, and a lot to take into your own practice this week.
Making a mistake, and carrying it around afterward
Early in the episode, Ian tells a story about an exposed melody on an upright bass gig that went badly enough to affect the performances that followed.
The advice he received gets to the heart of something many of us struggle with: when your identity is wrapped up in your instrument, a small musical mistake can start to feel like a verdict on you as a person.
We talk about recovering in the moment, the mental recovery afterward, and shifting your attention toward the people you’re playing for. We also consider how music education can make an exposed passage feel unnecessarily intimidating—and what we might do differently as educators.
Sound is part of the job
If you know Ian’s playing, you’ll know how much character he gets from his sounds.
He walks me through an HX Stomp setup, demonstrating the progression from a relatively clean amp sound through breakup, overdrive, fuzz, and octave. You can hear how much changes with his touch and how differently the effects respond to a pick or fingers.
We also discuss his work with Cory Wong and the distinction between switching on a distortion pedal and making a distorted bass sound sit where it belongs in the music.
It’s a useful section for anyone thinking about their pedalboard, but also for anyone trying to understand what a particular sound contributes to an arrangement.
Note length, space, and making the song feel right
Some of the most revealing playing in the episode is also the simplest.
Ian demonstrates how note length changes the energy of a bass line, why giving too much away in a verse can leave a chorus with nowhere to go, and how your accompaniment can invite another musician into the conversation.
These are details you can work on with almost any bass line you already know. The pitches might stay exactly the same while the feeling changes completely.
Being someone else’s bass player—and finding your own voice
Ian talks about how much he enjoys being a supporting musician, and how that identity has shaped his approach to making music of his own.
We explore the different instincts involved in supporting an artist, leading a band, and committing to your own creative decisions. That leads us into people pleasing, competition, ambition, and the point where trying to impress starts getting in the way of communicating something.
We also talk about the value of hearing musicians in a room, beyond the parts of their playing you might encounter online.
Giving yourself permission
Toward the end, I ask Ian about the last time he felt he’d made a significant step forward musically.
His answer involves giving himself permission to make music with the vocabulary he already had, while continuing to work on the things he wanted to improve.
My answer turns out to be closer to his than either of us expected. Looking back at my trio recording with Peter Erskine and Nir Felder, I can hear moments where dropping into a supporting role opened up the entire sound of the band. I wish I’d trusted that possibility more often.
It gave us a lot to think about: allowing the music to develop without feeling obliged to fill every available space.
Something to try in your next practice session
Take a bass line you already know and keep the notes the same.
Experiment with where each note ends. Try a shorter, more restrained version, then a more sustained one. Listen for how that changes the energy and how much room it leaves around you.
Then ask yourself which version makes the song feel better.
I’d love to hear what you take from this conversation—and whether your idea of a “professional” bass player has changed over time.
Links and resources
* My bass instruction books and learning resources
More soon, Janek.
Get full access to Janek's Newsletter at janekgwizdala.substack.com/subscribe