
The Supreme Court Closed the Loophole That Protected Flock's Cameras
Shownotes
Over four months in 2025, cameras photographed Lee Schmidt's car 475 times around Norfolk, Virginia. He was not a suspect or under investigation.
A network of 176 automated license plate readers recorded him anyway. Schmidt sued. In January, the chief judge of the Eastern District of Virginia wrote that the system "ensnares an immense array of law-abiding citizens guilty of nothing more than driving their cars in Norfolk," then ruled for the city.
Five months later, the Supreme Court decided Chatrie v. United States, a geofence-warrant case involving Google after a Virginia credit union robbery. It may have knocked the legs out from under the reasoning that let Schmidt lose.
This episode traces how the Fourth Amendment got here. Knotts said there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in movements on public roads. Jones cracked that rule, with Justice Sotomayor warning that location data can expose familial, political, professional, religious and sexual associations. Carpenter made seven days of cell-site data a search, but left open whether shorter surveillance counts.
That opening helped produce more than 30 decisions, by Flock Safety's own count, finding fixed license plate readers are not searches.
Chatrie seems to have closed that gap. Justice Kagan held that duration alone does not determine whether surveillance is a search and warned that even a short window can reveal visits to a psychiatrist, abortion clinic, gun show or political rally. Justice Alito predicted seismic waves through Fourth Amendment doctrine.
Schmidt is fully briefed in the Fourth Circuit, with no argument date. Whether Chatrie changes his case is the question.
Another gap remains. Chatrie involved government compelling a company to produce data. Flock stores images and sells access, including to cameras owned by HOAs, businesses, schools and hospitals. Nothing in Chatrie says whether government may buy data it would otherwise need a warrant to compel. Courts have barely touched this: is any of this state action?
Then there is Aaron Rodgers, who called this a sick society on the Pat McAfee Show and reportedly used an LLC to quietly fund his New Jersey town's police purchase of license plate cameras.
Also covered: Davis and good-faith reliance; the standing trap; Laird v. Tatum; Commonwealth v. McCarthy; Virginia's 2025 restrictions; 80-plus localities dropping Flock; and a San Francisco class action alleging 1.6 million queries in seven months.
CHAPTERS
(00:00) 475 photos in Norfolk
(01:42) Driving in public
(03:43) Jones and the mosaic theory
(05:23) Carpenter and the seven-day line
(06:50) Footnote three
(07:26) Chatrie changes the question
(08:25) Duration isn't the test
(09:30) The third-party doctrine wobbles
(10:20) Back to Schmidt
(12:47) Massachusetts drew a line, sort of
(13:44) The gap that could save Flock
(14:36) Is a private camera state action?
(15:43) Aaron Rodgers funds police cameras
(18:41) Why winning might change nothing
(20:12) The First Amendment will not help
(20:46) Where this gets decided
(22:41) The line nobody has drawn
(23:28) EagleTeam
LEGAL-ISH DISCLAIMER
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Sorry, occupational hazard: This is not legal advice, nor can I give you legal advice. I AM NOT YOUR LAWYER. Sorry! Everything here is for informational purposes only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. You should contact your attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular issue or problem. Nothing here should be construed to form an attorney-client relationship. Also, some of the links in this post may be affiliate links, meaning, at no cost to you, I will earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase. But if you click, it really helps me make more of these videos! All non-licensed clips used for fair use commentary, criticism, and educational purposes. See Hosseinzadeh v. Klein, 276 F.Supp.3d 34 (S.D.N.Y. 2017); Equals Three, LLC v. Jukin Media, Inc., 139 F. Supp. 3d 1094 (C.D. Cal. 2015).