
Ep 16 - Beyond CRM: Designing Safer Health Systems with Dr. Ken Catchpole - Part I
Shownotes
- Pit stops have evolved extensively over the years. See here
- Pit stops need to be done reliably and quickly
- Analyzed the F1 pit-stop process and applied to a patient handover process for moving pediatric cardiac surgery patients to the intensive care unit
- Emphasized clearly defined roles, sequencing, leadership and structuring communication.
- Recent work on radio-frequency identification (RFID) surgical sponges highlights the importance of research in patient safety interventions. His recent study found that RFID sponges had only a marginally acceptable benefit.
Current barriers to developing aviation-structured CRM in medicine: lack of training from healthcare workers, a focus on individuals versus teams, and cultural resistance to system change.
- Healthcare workers don’t have to demonstrate their ability to effectively communicate before being licensed
- Failure to properly train healthcare professionals on new protocols, checklists, procedures, etc.
Using of ideas from other industries takes research, adaptation, and training
CRM works to improve the performance of frontline workers. Moving beyond CRM focuses on human factors in the design of systems.
- Human factors in system design emphasizes how human behaviour and the limitations of human performance can be understood to enhance system performance.
- Human factors research initially started in the 1940’s in aviation, when focusing on pilot confusion between flaps and landing gear (two similar levers) in a basic airplane. The initial solution was to change the shape of the levers.
Employment of a human factors scientist in healthcare institutions may improve patient safety.
- Human factors scientists can improve healthcare design through:
- Incident analysis
- Developing standards of practice
- Architecture and design of actual spaces
- Observation and understanding of different clinical environments
- Disseminating information to healthcare workers
- Dr. Catchpole’s current suggestions for improving safety in hospitals:
- Procurement of devices (effort spent to determine functionality before it is purchased)
- Clinical incident analysis (how harm comes from financial and staffing-related decisions, not just clinicians)
- Human factors scientists spending time in clinical environments to find where the real pain points are.
Safety intervention worth mentioning
- Human factors or user-centred design, particularly when implementing new equipment or processes.
- A great example of a forcing function is to change epidural catheters to no longer accept Luer lock syringes.
Other resources
- The Design of Every Day Things by Don Norman
- The Field Guide Human Error by Sidney Dekker
- Still Not Safe by Robert Wears
- Institute for Healthcare Improvement: Certified Professional in Human Factors in Healthcare
Random recommendations
- Ken: Go and do some art. It doesn’t need to be good. Whether it’s sculpture, gardening, cooking etc.
- Amir: The Podcast Hard fork. The newest episode (their penultimate episode is very important: The AI mob that attacked hugging face
- Adam: The Rescue streaming on Disney+ in Canada, which is about the rescue of a Thai Boys Soccer Team that got trapped deep in a cave that flooded.
Thanks to Carter Ponce at VoV Media for his work in producing and promoting the show, and our intern, Dr. Sam Seshadri, a rural family medicine resident in Canada, for his research and help with post-production.
Kapitel (6)