Zum Inhalt springen

Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, Inc.: Date Argued: 03/24/26

04.04.2026 · 1 Std. 9 Min.

Shownotes

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Case Summary:

In the case of Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, Inc. (Docket No. 25-6), argued before the Supreme Court of the United States on March 24, 2026, the relevant facts are as follows:

Fact Summary

The case centers on Thomas Keathley, who filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy in late 2019. While his bankruptcy repayment plan was active, he was involved in a severe motor vehicle collision in August 2021 with a truck driven by an employee of Buddy Ayers Construction (BAC).

Keathley promptly hired a personal injury attorney and filed a lawsuit against BAC in December 2021. However, he failed to disclose this new legal claim—which bankruptcy law views as a potential asset for creditors—to the bankruptcy court in several subsequent amended filings.

The core factual and legal dispute involves the doctrine of judicial estoppel, which prevents a party from taking a position in a legal proceeding that contradicts a position taken in a previous proceeding. BAC argued that because Keathley "hid" the asset from the bankruptcy court, he should be barred from pursuing the personal injury claim entirely.

Lower courts, including the Fifth Circuit, agreed with BAC, applying a harsh standard that presumes bad faith whenever a debtor has a "motive to conceal" an asset, regardless of whether the omission was a genuine mistake or oversight by counsel.

The factual record includes Keathley’s eventual disclosure of the lawsuit to the bankruptcy court, but only after BAC moved to dismiss his personal injury case. BAC maintains this "catch-me-if-you-can" approach undermines the integrity of the judicial system.

During the oral arguments on March 24, 2026, the Supreme Court justices appeared skeptical of the Fifth Circuit's rigid rule. Justice Gorsuch and Justice Jackson questioned why the "windfall" should go to the construction company (the alleged wrongdoer) rather than the bankruptcy creditors who would actually benefit from the lawsuit's proceeds.

The Court examined whether judicial estoppel should require a finding of subjective bad faith or if a mere "hypothetical motive" to conceal is sufficient to strip a plaintiff of their day in court.

Alle Folgen von Oral Arguments – The Supreme Court of the United States

Einstellungen

Darstellung

Sprache

Bestimmt, welche Sender dir auf der Startseite zuerst gezeigt werden.

Verlauf

Zuletzt gehörte Sender und Folgen und deine letzten Suchen liegen nur in diesem Browser.

Hinweise

Ein kurzer Hinweis, wenn ein Podcast, dem du folgst, eine neue Folge hat. Einzelne Podcasts stellst du über die Glocke auf ihrer Seite ab.

Konto

Favoriten speichern – in der App und auf der Website.

Tastenkürzel

/
Suche öffnen
Leertaste
Abspielen oder anhalten
← →
Im Player: 15 s zurück, 30 s vor (Folgen) · im Regal: nächste Kachel
↑ ↓
Im Regal: Ziel innerhalb der Kachel
Pos1 / Ende
Im Regal: erste bzw. letzte Kachel
Esc
Fenster oder Menü schließen
?
Diese Übersicht
Läuft gerade

Zur Senderseite

Als Nächstes

    Folgen mit „Als Nächstes“ vormerken – sie laufen nach der aktuellen Folge.