
SHE CAUGHT HIM. THEN THEY LET HIM GO. | The Hillbrow Birthday R@pist
Shownotes
She caught him. The system released him. Then she caught him again.
Veteran SAPS detective Joyce Buthelezi joins Paul Llewellyn and Dr Gérard Labuschagne to recount the investigation into Mlungisi Mtshali, the notorious Hillbrow Birthday Rapist.
Joyce recognised a pattern in three rape dockets, helping uncover an offender who lured young women with an elaborate birthday story before attacking them in Johannesburg hotels.
Working alongside Gérard, Joyce helped lead an investigation that culminated in Mtshali's arrest in KwaZulu-Natal.
But while awaiting trial, Mtshali was mistakenly released following an unrelated driving conviction, forcing investigators to track him down a second time.
He was eventually sentenced to 39 life terms plus 212 years.
Beyond the investigation, Joyce shares her remarkable philosophy of policing: understanding victims, building relationships with suspects and their families, and treating people with dignity.
She also reveals why the victims cried at sentencing — and why attending their graduations and weddings meant more to her than securing a conviction.
An extraordinary firsthand account of investigative persistence, institutional failure and the humanity behind good policing.
PROFILER AFRICA — Understanding the minds behind South Africa's most disturbing crimes.