Zum Inhalt springen

Rebuilding trust in an unequal world with Kate Pickett

30.10.2026 · 40 Min.

Shownotes

Is today’s polarisation the logical consequence of rising inequality? And can we still turn it around? In this final episode of our third season, Kate Pickett, Professor for the Public Understanding of Social Science at the University of York, member of the Club of Rome and co-author of The Spirit Level joins Till Kellerhoff to explore what more than 15 years of evidence tells us about unequal societies.

Pickett explains how inequality gets under our skin through chronic stress, eroding health, trust and social cohesion for almost everyone, not just the poorest. Drawing on the Earth4All Rebuild Trust report, which she co-authored, the conversation looks at why 70% of people say inequality has gone too far and 65% believe the system is rigged, and only 31% trust their government to act in the long-term interest. They discuss why this shared diagnosis so rarely becomes a political majority, how economic and cultural explanations of populism interact, and how citizens’ assemblies and participatory budgeting can help rebuild trust. Pickett also shares her hopes for the new International Panel on Inequality.

Tune in for hopeful conversation about why the good society is a political choice, not a utopian dream.

Till: This year, for the first time, one person’s wealth passed $1 trillion, although only for a short time. But in the same year, seven in 10 people across the world’s largest economies told us inequality has gone too far, and only three in 10 trust their government to act in their long-term interest. More than 15 years ago, our today’s guest, Kate Pickett, warned in the best-selling book, “The Spirit Level,” that unequal societies are less trusting, less healthy, and more divided.

Is today’s polarization a consequence of this inequality already described by Kate over 15 years ago? And how do we turn this around and rebuild trust?

That’s what we’re talking about today on the Club of Rome Podcast, where we explore bold ideas for shaping sustainable futures. I am Till Kellerhoff, director of content and programs at the Club of Rome, and I’m delighted to be joined by Kate Pickett.

Kate is Professor for the Public Understanding of Social Science at the University of York. With Richard Wilkinson, she wrote “The Spirit Level,” one of the most influential books on inequality of the past decades, and this year she published “The Good Society and How We Make It.”

Kate is also a member of the Club of Rome and one of the co-authors of the Rebuild Trust report by Earth4All, published in September 2026. We talk about whether today’s polarization is the logical consequence of what “The Spirit Level” describes, what the new survey tells us about where we are now, and why Kate thinks the good society is a political choice rather than a utopian dream.

Hi Kate, welcome to the Club of Rome podcast.

Kate: Hi, Till. Thank you for having me

Till: So Kate, you already more than 15 years ago argued, uh, in the spirit level with, uh, Richard Wilkinson that inequality has a potential to pull societies apart, right? Lower trust levels, worse health, more violence. Um, and you argue that the underlying problem is the scale of material differences between people within society.

If that becomes too big, you see these negative consequences. Maybe you can lead us briefly through some of the mechanisms there. H- Why is an increasing amount of inequality problematic for societies?

Kate: Sure. So basic summary is that we found that income inequality, so the gap between rich and poor in different societies, and it’s important to say here that we were looking at the rich developed market societies. That inequality is related to a range of outcomes, and broadly those fall into, at the time, fell into sort of three different categories: health outcomes as, as you mentioned, so health is worse in more unequal societies. Social capital, so things like trust, levels of violence, but also, um, children and young people’s life chances also worse in more unequal societies. And the differences between different societies w- were pretty big. , For some outcomes like levels of imprisonment, there were eightfold differences between the most equal and the most unequal countries, for example.

So the differences were large, and that’s important ’cause it tells you that it isn’t just the poor that are being affected. There aren’t enough poor in, in all of those societies to explain those big differences. And then we also found that pretty much everybody is affected. So even if you are a relatively affluent, well-educated, high social class person, you would on average be more likely to have good outcomes in a more equal society than if you had the same level of income, education, et cetera, in a more unequal society.

So that- that’s sort of the basic finding. So of course, that raises the question of why? How? You know, how is the gap between rich and poor really doing that damage? Is it a causal relationship or is it just a correlation and, and how does that work? So we’ve spent a lot of time, and when I say we, that’s Richard Wilkinson and I, but also, you know, other researchers across the world trying to look at those different pathways.

And I think it’s perhaps helpful if we start with health, and we are both, Rich and I are both epidemiologists, so we come from a public health perspective. The link, the causal pathway between higher levels of inequality and those worse health outcomes is to do with chronic stress. So it is to do with living in a more unequal society, how that makes you feel about your relative social position, how it makes you feel that other people are judging you.

It, it increases the salience of the socioeconomic differences between people. It increases the gap between people, and that’s a chronic stressor. And we understand really well the biological and, um, psychological impact of chronic stress. Chronic stress is it undermines sort of all health systems.

So it’s, it’s like you age more rapidly. Your immune system is compromised. Your reproductive system is compromised. Your neurological system is compromised. Your endocrine system is compromised. So chronic stress we understand really, really well And inequality just increases those levels of chronic stress for the vast majority of the population.

I mean, I have to say that in recent years that we’ve started to see some much more, um, explicit focus on, on details of those causal pathways. So I’ve worked with a group that’s looked at the impact of inequality on brain function and brain structure in adolescence, and you can see that in more unequal societies, brain function and, and structures are different.

And so inequality is having an, an observable impact on people’s biology, on their physiology, and that’s because of chronic stress and how, how inequality makes people feel and behave. So I think we, we understand that really well, and I think it’s quite easy as well to think about the pathways through which greater inequality, bigger social distances between us, leads to an undermining of trust and social cohesion.

So I think those pathways are quite, quite well understood as well. So I think the science and the social science has, has really moved beyond just describing those relationships to, to really understanding those causal pathways

Till: and it is, I mean, if you look at the numbers, right, it is, um, uh, clear, clear that, um, according to the latest World Inequality Report, the 10% richest in terms of income, um, earn more than the, than the bottom 90%, um, but it even gets more concentrated if you look at wealth, right? The richest 10%, uh, have three-fourth of the wealth globally.

The bottom 50% have, like, 2%, so basically, uh, nothing. But those are, um, global distributions. And, and I was wondering, your studies look particularly at within-country inequality, right? But if you look, uh, at what happened since and, and in the last decades in general, um, there is also an interesting global dimension because, let’s say, 40 years ago, if you were at the bottom income scale in Spain, you were still at the top income scale, uh, globally, right?

Now we see that there is catching up, and all of a sudden you ca- you, you, you compete to a certain extent with, um, a, a, a richer middle class from India or China. Is that an element in, uh, that, that can cause additional stress, you think, that this global dimension of inequality comes in there as well? Or would you differentiate stronger between the within-country and between-country inequality?

Kate: I think it’s really important to look at both, and I think it’s really important to understand the trends in, um, within country as well as between country inequality. And I think our world is more global than it used to be as well. You know, so we are all perhaps more aware of, um, global inequalities where we stand in relation to, to, um, the global economic system.

And so I think inequalities in that can be a source of stress for us in ways that perhaps they, they were less so in the past. Um, but it’s all salient. So if we think about the global concentration of wealth, for example, which, um, Oxfam report on every year in their reports to the World Economic Forum, and which produced those astonishing statistics that you just said.

Um, I heard one in, in New York the other day. The, um, head of Oxfam International said that there are two, um, high net worth individuals in Latin America who own the same wealth as the bottom half of the population of Latin America and the Caribbean. So these astonishing statistics of, of wealth concentration do affect all of us because they affect levels of democracy, who has power, who has agency, um, who can exploit the system, and who can hoard wealth and, and all of those things do affect all of us.

Um, those super rich individuals on that global scale are controlling our media, they’re controlling who has access to political power, so we are all affected by those sorts of inequalities. But I think probably for most of us, it is the within country, our own societal inequalities that perhaps have the most salience for most of us.

You know, our position in relation to other people in our neighborhood, in our region, in our nation, that probably are doing, um, the most damage

Till: And I think this, what you mentioned in terms of the super rich is something that is, uh, currently particularly being discussed, right? The year, world has, uh, seen the first trillionaire, uh, although only for a short time, but the numbers are staggering. Um, the richest 0.001% of the world have three times more wealth than the bottom 50%, um, that’s unimaginable.

and we, we did speak a little bit about the super rich here, but if you look at the, um, if the-- of the development of inequality in different countries, the picture is, of course, complex, right? It is not as easy to say inequality is always everywhere increasing. There are nuances, there are differences.

You need to look. Do you look at wealth? Do you look at inequality? At which country do you look at? There are varieties of capitalism with different redistribution. Um, so it is a complex picture. And what I was wondering, um, because also we come to that then in the context of the report, um, the latest Earth for All report, is it about objective inequality that persists within countries, or is there also an element of the narrative about inequality and the perception of inequality, how people perceive it subjectively, even if that might not actually match the, uh, right data or trend?

Kate: Yeah. I mean, I think both are important. So it is through our perceptions of, of inequality that, um, we experience that chronic stress that, that I was talking about. Um, so it has to get into our minds somehow. There has to be some perception of the level of inequality to, to do the damage once you get beyond, say, the impact of inequality on levels of absolute poverty in different societies.

Um, but objective measures of inequality matter as well, and there’s been a lot of work in my own field in public health looking at objective income, you know, so measures of income, how much money do you have, and then your relative position. Um, you know, where does, where does that level of income put you?

And both of those things can be important, and it turns out it’s the relative income often, often trumps the absolute level. So I think when we’re thinking about absolute levels of things and perceptions of things, again, it’s, it’s a complex picture. Inequality has to find a way to get under your skin, into your mind, shaping your behavior, shaping your emotions, shaping your, um, physiology, and so that is coming about through your perception of what is going on.

But people’s perceptions of inequality are often, um, not brilliant, right? They’re not great. They often underestimate the level of inequality in their society or, or they think it’s, it’s, um, it’s got worse in the last two years or something when it hasn’t. You know, so people’s perceptions of inequality are not always matching up with, with the absolute level of inequality that we can measure.

Till: Yeah. And in that context, it is interesting as well with people, if you ask people where they position themselves in the income ladder, um, they, they, they, they come up with, with different results than the actual status they are in. And also if you then ask them, uh, if they-- if you think they would be affected by the inheritance tax or wealth tax, uh, they would consider themselves being part of that group much, much too early, right?

Because usually they are for much higher income and wealth groups. ,

Kate: if you talk to members of the public and ask them what they think of an inheritance tax, they are often fearful that that would affect them. Um, not understanding the, the, the threshold for, for paying an inheritance tax, for example, is quite high. Um, and so, so there’s the perception of, of what it might mean for them is very, very different to, to the reality.

Um, and that idea of asking people where do you place yourself within a society, within a structure of a society, there’s a, there’s a rubric for doing that, that a, a ladder, a measure of relative social standing, social class that, that people use in health-related research and others. And it, it just asks people to imagine society as a ladder with rungs, you know, 10, 10 rungs of a ladder from the bottom to the top, and at the bottom are the people who have sort of nothing, and at the top are the people who have everything and, and people are asked to place themselves on that ladder.

Um, and the most typical response is those people put themselves in the middle. They just like to think of themselves as average, even if they’re coming from quite a deprived community or, or they’re particularly affluent. So everybody sort of tends to stick themselves in the middle. Um, and so that measure of perceived relative social position often doesn’t match up with the reality of people’s lives

Till: We even had, uh, one case in Germany where the current chancellor, uh, Friedrich Merz, a few years ago in an interview described himself as a middle class, um, having worked as BlackRock before, um, and, uh, uh, having a private plane. But, uh, the, the perception of, of something is unequal, and, uh, there’s too much inequality is shared across societies.

That’s one of the results we have seen in the latest Earth4All reports, uh, Rebuild Trust, which was published in September this year, where 70% of, uh, the people across the globe say that there is too much inequality. Um, 65% say the system is rigged, and that is interestingly shared across incomes. So, uh, it is in different income groups, people, people share this diagnosis.

Kate: I, I think that’s really important, don’t you, Till? I mean, I think that’s a really strong finding. Um, and I think in the report we describe it as a, a near universal diagnosis that the system is, is wrong, that the system is rigged. I mean, to have 70% saying there’s too much economic inequality, I mean, that fits with, with what I’ve seen in UK social surveys over, over decades.

You know, really widely shared understanding that there is too much inequality. Um, and 65% in, in this most recent survey thinking that the system is rigged to benefit the rich and powerful. That’s a strong mandate for system change. Um, and I think, I think that’s a really important finding that we need to share widely because it does suggest that there is a mandate for change.

It, it does suggest that we, we could, um, take that evidence to leaders and expect them to act on it because a very large majority of their population is going to back them do- doing things

You’re listening to the Club of Rome Podcast.

This is the final episode of our third season, but you can go back and listen to all the season’s episodes with thinkers like Jayati Ghosh and Chandran Nair. Our archive has episodes on universal basic dividend, wellbeing economics, planetary peace, climate resilience, and societal collapse and renewal.

You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Now back to the discussion

Till: But why is it so hard then to turn it into political majorities? Because we do see the shared diagnosis, right? But then again, um, many of the, um, uh, right-wing populists across the world do not only have policies in many areas probably many, uh, of the progressive listeners wouldn’t agree with. Uh, but even in economic policy, um, they’re often amongst the ones that say no to a wealth tax, no to higher taxation for the rich, no to inheritance tax, and in a way reproduce a certain neoliberal paradigm, um, that, that also leads to the fact that those with a, um, kind of less money, uh, would not benefit economically from those parties, right?

So why is it so difficult to turn this diagnosis into a political majority?

Kate: I mean, if I knew the answer to that question in a nutshell, w- would be- we’d go out and do something, wouldn’t we? So I mean, I think it is, it is a hard thing, and it is a longstanding, um, finding that, as you say, quite often people vote against their best interests for, for policy. Um, I think there’s two things going on there.

One is there is, um, a vested interest in those on the right of keeping things as they are, keeping the neoliberal agenda going, um, preventing this majority opinion of, of inequality being too great and things being done, preventing that. And so they are, they are blockers to, to that change, and they will use their money and their power to try and tell different stories and try and, and make sure that progressive change doesn’t happen.

And I think alongside that, that influence from, from the powerful is that feeling of, of people at the bottom of having been left behind, often by progressive politics, and for quite some time, feeling that the change that, that perhaps they were promised has not come, um, that they have been abandoned, that things are no better for their children than, than they are, um, than they might have expected.

And so they’re open, they’re vulnerable to those messages of, “We will, we will offer you an, an alternative. We will make things better for you. You’ve not been able to trust that political-- progressive political agenda, and we will come in and offer something, something different for you.” And I suppose also it speaks to, to, to people’s hope.

If you live in a very unequal society, there is always this sort of little hope

Alle Folgen von The Club of Rome Podcast

Einstellungen

Darstellung

Sprache

Bestimmt, welche Sender dir auf der Startseite zuerst gezeigt werden.

Verlauf

Zuletzt gehörte Sender und Folgen und deine letzten Suchen liegen nur in diesem Browser.

Hinweise

Ein kurzer Hinweis, wenn ein Podcast, dem du folgst, eine neue Folge hat. Einzelne Podcasts stellst du über die Glocke auf ihrer Seite ab.

Konto

Favoriten speichern – in der App und auf der Website.

Tastenkürzel

/
Suche öffnen
Leertaste
Abspielen oder anhalten
← →
Im Player: 15 s zurück, 30 s vor (Folgen) · im Regal: nächste Kachel
↑ ↓
Im Regal: Ziel innerhalb der Kachel
Pos1 / Ende
Im Regal: erste bzw. letzte Kachel
Esc
Fenster oder Menü schließen
?
Diese Übersicht
Läuft gerade

Zur Senderseite

Als Nächstes

    Folgen mit „Als Nächstes“ vormerken – sie laufen nach der aktuellen Folge.