
Right to Work Checks: The Compliance You Can't Ignore | With Ian Hamilton
Shownotes
When Sarah and her team audit a new client, right to work checks are non-compliant somewhere between 80 and 90% of the time. In this episode, business immigration advisor Ian Hamilton joins the podcast to walk through exactly what employer right to work compliance actually requires — for British and Irish nationals, EU nationals, and everyone on a visa in between.
You'll learn the difference a share code does and doesn't prove, the working-hours traps that catch out employers with student or skilled worker visa requirements on their books, and why sponsor licence compliance has become a far higher-stakes game under the current government. You'll also get Ian's honest, practical view on what genuinely protects a business when the Home Office comes calling.
Key Takeaways
- A right to work check must be completed before someone starts work, not after. Ian flags this as the single most common non-compliance issue he finds when auditing sponsors — if in doubt, delay the start date until the check is properly done and filed.
- A share code is not proof of a right to work check on its own. It only lets an employer view part of an individual's e-visa, so the actual check — and reading the full detail on any restrictions or conditions — still has to be done and recorded properly.
- EU nationals do not automatically have the right to work in the UK. Without settled or pre-settled status, they need a skilled worker visa or another eligible route, and this is one of the areas Ian sees businesses get caught out on most often.
- Working-hour limits are easy to miss and carry real risk. Students can typically work up to 20 hours a week during term time; skilled workers can do up to 20 hours a week of supplementary work for a different employer — going beyond either is a right to work compliance failure.
- Fines for non-compliance run up to £60,000 per employee (reduced to £45,000 for a first offence), alongside reputational risk and, for sponsors, the possibility of losing a sponsor licence entirely — which immediately affects every skilled worker that business sponsors.
- The Home Office increasingly cross-checks sponsor data against HMRC records. A mismatch between a certificate of sponsorship's stated salary and actual tax records is one of the most common triggers for a compliance investigation.
Timestamps
[00:41] What a right to work check actually is[01:24] Checks for British, Irish, and other nationals[04:10] Why EU nationals are often assumed wrongly[05:28] Working-hour limits for students and skilled workers[09:46] The real financial penalties for non-compliance[19:27] How the Home Office finds non-compliance[25:06] Section 3C leave and the two-limb test[34:00] Key takeaways for staying compliant
Resources Mentioned
- OTB Legal — Ian Hamilton's firm, specialising in sponsor licences, skilled worker visas, and Home Office compliance
- Immigration Act, Section 3C — referenced regarding the extension of existing leave while a valid, in-time visa application is under consideration
- Home Office sponsor guidance — referenced as spanning four separate documents, described as complex and containing inconsistencies
Ian Hamilton is a Business Immigration Advisor at OTB Legal, where he specialises in sponsor licences, skilled worker visas, and helping businesses stay compliant with the Home Office's sponsor management system. Drawing on his experience auditing sponsors of all sizes, he's worth listening to for a genuinely practical, on-the-ground view of where employers most often go wrong with right to work compliance — and what a strong audit trail actually looks like in practice.
Follow Ian on LinkedIn
right to work checks UK, employer right to work compliance, skilled worker visa requirements, sponsor licence compliance, Home Office immigration checks, UK immigration law for employers, HR compliance for small business, hiring overseas workers UK, small business HR advice, UK employment law compliance