Zum Inhalt springen

600 – Crafting a Long Series

09.08.2026

Shownotes

Oh wow, that’s six entire hundreds. Honestly didn’t expect we’d ever make it this far, and now we’re lacking a plan. Fortunately, that doesn’t mean your long series also has to lack a plan, or lack a smooth transition for that matter. This week, we’re discussing how to lay the groundwork for a story that goes on and on, hopefully in a way that doesn’t leave you trapped four books into an epic work of dark fantasy with no idea how to continue.

Show Notes Transcript

Generously transcribed by Manasa. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.

Oren: And welcome everyone to another episode of the Mythcreants Podcast. I’m Oren.

Chris: And I’m Chris.

Oren: I was there, Chris. I was there 3,000 years ago when some nerds recorded the first Mythcreant Podcast episode.

Chris: Oh, we’re so old.

Oren: I told them to cast it into the fire, and they dramatically said no, and then 600 episodes later, here we are.

Chris: Well, since we have another opportunity, we can cast it into the fire again.

Oren: No. We don’t, we don’t do that. We don’t cast things into the fire around here. You think fire’s free? We can’t afford fire.

Chris: So yeah, maybe just cast the intro music into the fire.

Oren: I like that intro music, but we have had it for quite a while.

Chris: Yeah. A big thanks to Jonathan Coulton for, for giving us permission to use his song. It was great. It was just from a different time, having that long of intro music. It was time to modernize by just getting right to the episode. And I don’t know, maybe later we might add a more modern, shorter intro sometime if I get around to it. I, I might never.

Oren: We don’t say “100%” nearly enough to be a modern podcast. We have completely lost the lingo.

Chris: Well, maybe our retroness still has some charm.

Oren: People don’t realize….Before we get to the main topic, uh, if you have enjoyed the podcast, we could use your help. We are currently looking for more transcription volunteers to help us make sure every episode launches with a transcript. We are grateful to our existing volunteers, and we wanna make sure they don’t get burned out. We typically send an episode every six weeks or so at the most. If you’re interested, go to mythcreants.com/volunteer.

Chris: All right. So what is our topic today? Is it that we’re so old?

Oren: Yeah, it’s so old.

Chris: 3,000 years. It feels like 3,000 years. It does.

Oren: I was hoping that it would, it would work out to 3,000 days, but no, it’s more like 5,000 days. So it didn’t quite work out math-wise. Today we’re talking about how to craft a long series.

Chris: Long series, like this podcast. Which is totally the same.

Oren: Which we didn’t plan at all. So, you know, if you wanna end up like us, don’t plan, I guess, is the lesson here. Because, of course, the planning versus pantsing debate is eternal, and I’m not gonna try to solve it here. But if you are talking about a series, you do have to consider the extra wrinkle that unless you’re writing the whole thing all at once before publishing (which some writers do, but I don’t think most of us do), then there’s gonna be stuff that already exists in the world and that you would be very hard-pressed to change if you end up deciding you wanna take the story in a completely different direction.

So planning can be a little bit more important there because as long as it’s a single book, you can theoretically go back and change things if you decide, “To heck with this outline,” or, “I don’t do an outline.” But if you’re doing a five-book series, and the first two books are already published, well, you gotta kinda abide by what you set there, or you should. I suppose you don’t have to. No one has to do anything.

Chris: I mean, if you plan the first one and write it without planning the series, and again we could talk about the best case scenario versus the worst case scenario. In the best case scenario, if you do know what you’re doing, we will talk about how to leave things open so the story has some place to go even if you haven’t planned it out. If you leave things open instead of like writing yourself into a corner after the first installment, you can be okay. But you are gonna have more constraints after the first book because now you have to adhere to whatever you established in your first story. On the other hand, though, I have definitely seen people, you know, especially with their magnum opus, they jump into a series right away, and it’s almost like we have the same constraints but in reverse – which I think is worse – where now they’ve planned the end, and so the beginning can’t change.

Or I’ve even had people add scenes that feel really out of place in their first book because it’s intended to set up something for a later book. And the first book is hands down the most important. It doesn’t feel that way when you’re plotting because, of course, like any good plot, you wanna escalate and have the last book be like the most epic. But from the reader’s perspective, the first book absolutely has to succeed in order for anybody to read the later books. Again, depending on what kind of series we’re talking about. We can talk about anthologies later.

Oren: Yeah, that’s one of the most difficult things as an editor when you’re talking to the author and suggesting, “Well, this thing isn’t working. This plot element isn’t functioning well. We should revise it to strengthen it,” and they’re like, “No, that can’t be changed. We need that to set up for the twist in Book Four.” Well, you didn’t hire me to edit Book Four, so there’s only so much I can do about that. I ask for very broad details of what happens in the later books, but I can’t even read a full series outline. That would be a ton more work that no one paid for. So at some point, we do have to acknowledge that fixing the first book should probably be the priority.

Chris: Yeah. I think ideally people would, as they practice writing and plotting, slowly scale up the size of their stories so that they don’t commit to a long series before they kind of know how plotting goes a little bit. Not that there isn’t… I think most writers still- they try something different and then they have surprises and things don’t go how they expect, right? So it’s not for a lot of people, it doesn’t necessarily become super regular. But I think the issue that happens in the very beginning is: if you start a long series like right away, but you’re still learning some like really important story fundamentals, you end up with something that is really complex and puts tons of constraints on the first book. And it’s just really hard to make that first book a success, which it absolutely needs to be. So that’s a situation where I might say, “You know what? Maybe you should just not plan. Maybe you should just write the first book and make sure that works.” Again, ideally planning can, can do worlds of good, but…

Oren: Right, and even if you are at the stage where starting to plan makes sense, I’m not suggesting that you need to plan every single detail and have like a super rigid plan to hold yourself to because as you write, things are gonna change. Things are gonna be different, and you will have to probably make adjustments. That’s just the nature of it. And if you get too rigid in your planning, that’s going to be a problem, and every writer is gonna have to find that sweet spot for themselves. I can’t tell you what it is for you. But I would generally recommend, if you’re serious about this series and you have like some experience with what that means, I would usually recommend at least some basic plotting of what you think the later books are gonna be, so that you’re setting yourself up for them early instead of trying to scrounge a plot out of the ether later on.

Chris: So maybe it’s worth talking about: how do you leave yourself with somewhere to go? Let’s say you are just plotting the first book, but you wanna make it a series. You’re not gonna plot out the entire series because you’re gonna see how well the first book does before you commit to working on book two.

Oren: Right, like what I did. Admittedly, I was surprised at how many people saw the ending hook that I put in “Abbess Rebellion” and thought that it was a – even described it as – a cliffhanger ending. I was like, “Is that a cliffhanger?”

Chris: Oh, I mean, I certainly didn’t think it was a cliffhanger.

Oren: But there were definitely some people who read that and were like- even that hook was-…You know, they were like, “Well, where’s the next part?” And I’m like, “Well, the next part will be there if any significant number of people read this,” which, you know, they didn’t, as expected.

Chris: I mean, unless you have a huge marketing budget, that’s to be expected. And from what I’ve heard, if you’re gonna be indie publishing, it makes sense to finish three books before you start spending money if you wanna advertise yourself, because then there’s three things for people to read if they do start reading your work. So who knows? You know, we’ll see. I think there are a lot of people who did like “Abbess Rebellion” and wanted to see a sequel. So if things pick up, it’s possible. Um, you know, it’d be nice if you still return to that.

Oren: You know, with all this free time I’m gonna have in law school.

Chris: Yeah, could be a long time coming. Okay, so let’s talk about it. The main thing that really screws writers over and makes it hard to do another installment is: when we tie up everything in the plot, and everybody gets a happy ending, and there’s just no problems left. Because at that point, if you want to create problems for the next book, it feels like we have to take the happy endings away from people, and that doesn’t feel great. We’ve seen a lot of…like the “Willow” show … A lot of these were, don’t get me wrong, fairly unforced errors. At the end of the “Willow” movie, the classic movie, you know, Willow now is like learning magic and he’s happy and doing great. And in the beginning of the show, he’s miserable, and it drags out the question of whether he can actually do magic for a surprisingly long time. When the whole movie was about him getting to the point where he felt confident in himself, and then he was ready to actually do real magic. So that was just so unsatisfying, the idea that he couldn’t do magic anymore. And, again, we can have new threats appear and that works, especially if you want relationships to grow, but everybody is like getting along perfectly and they’re like really close to each other, it may not feel…and you can create new problems, it’s just definitely easier if there’s some room for growth. The enemies become friends, but they’re not yet lovers, or what have you.

Oren: Yeah. Well, “Willow” is weird because “Willow” has basically zero world building. Like, there is so little effort devoted to what this place is like beyond that there’s an evil witch and we gotta stop her. Like, what we’re even stopping her from doing is very vague. So it’s not like they don’t have anything left to explore because they basically explored nothing, which is one of the reasons why the sequel series is so weird to me. But ideally if they had wanted to set themselves up for a sequel, there would’ve been a little bit more of an attempt to demonstrate that this world has things going on other than this one evil witch.

Chris: Yeah. Which, again, the world building, brings me to this also really matters for allowing sequels because if you have just like a single world threat that kind of defines the plot and it doesn’t feel like this is a world that has that same level of problems regularly, then it can be really hard to come up with “What’s the next problem?” Whereas if you have a world where stuff is happening all the time…So like for instance, in “Lockwood & Co.”, we have a ghost apocalypse kind of, so there’s ghosts everywhere.

And during the story they have to tackle different ghosts haunting houses, and then we climax with a big mansion that has tons of ghosts in it. It’s super creepy. We don’t get rid of all of the ghosts in the setting, right? We don’t fix whatever caused the ghost apocalypse and send all of the ghosts to rest at the end of the first book. If we did that, then it’s like, well, “the entire concept of this book is fighting ghosts, but now we took care of all of the ghosts. Where do we have to go?” Whereas if we’re just fighting, okay, “this is one mansion that’s particularly dangerous, this is gonna be our climax, the post-apocalypse is still here”, then we can just pull up more spooks and ghosts for future books, and we have plenty of room to keep writing sequels.

Oren: And I suspect that you wouldn’t have a Willow type situation in novels very often because Willow kind of gets away with the fact that it does zero world building because it’s a relatively short cult classic movie that doesn’t really need world building. It’s just got quirky, fun characters that people like, and it’s funny. Whereas with a novel, I think you would have a hard time getting people to buy a fantasy novel that had that flimsy of a world. Like even fantasy novels that aren’t known for their world building do more than that.

Chris: I mean, a fairy tale fantasy can be very flimsy in its world building, right? Because it’s really light and kind of low in realism.

Oren: Yeah, that’s true.

Chris: So there’s just like kingdoms everywhere, but, you know, we don’t necessarily have a map and it’s like “how many kingdoms can fit in such a small space? We have like princes and princesses running around everywhere.” So it may depend on the type of story. Willow is pretty campy. So I don’t know. But again, because it’s left open, right, there’s plenty of room to be like, “Oh yeah, did you know there’s another big empire next door that is headed by an evil wizard and the wizard wants to kidnap Elora or something?” You know, so there’s just … There is actually plenty of room to build on that because it’s not thoroughly explored and the premise of the original Willow is just magical people and armies running around on the map.

Oren: Yeah. Although Willow does highlight another potential issue which is that if you want to leave room for sequels, it’s usually best to be modest with your initial scale. Because they’ve saved the kingdom from a super evil powerful sorceress, and it’s not that you can’t escalate past that, it’s just what do you escalate to? It feels like that witch is about as powerful as a bad guy could get before the power levels start to become meaningless.

Chris: So generally the rule is, because you do want the series to be a non-anthology series that is closely tied together, you do want it to escalate. But you have other options. Instead of escalating the tension, which usually in many cases requires increasing the scope of the story…so it’s a town, now we’re focusing on the kingdom or what have you. You could also change things up more so that you’re adding more novelty to make up for the fact that the tension is not going up because something is new and refreshing in the new story. But then the question is: what is it gonna be? I mean, again, Willow is open-ended, right? Maybe we could add some unicorns or something. The unicorn lord. Something that’s different enough to make a sequel work. Again, that might be harder with something like Lockwood & Co., that is very specifically about fighting ghosts as opposed to a general magical epic fantasy setting like Willow. Not that you couldn’t create, add variety to Lockwood & Co., but like that would definitely be harder.

Oren: I want to talk about two very broad methods for series plotting. You got what I will shorthand refer to as the Lockwood method and then the Temeraire method. Because in Lockwood, there is a series plot about figuring out, like, what the heck happened with this ghost apocalypse, what’s going on, and we start to get towards solving that by the end. But that’s not apparent from the first book. In the first book, they don’t receive, like, the riddle of the ghost apocalypse, which is what I would probably recommend to newer writers. It’s something that is implied, but you don’t come right out and say it, and then that gives you the option to either continue it or to say, “All right, I’m done with this series,” before you actually get there. As opposed to in Temeraire, it’s very clear that the throughline is the defeat of Napoleon from the first book. And Naomi Novik does it. Nine books later, they get him, but that’s a nine-book series. That’s pretty ambitious for most of us teeny baby writers. And if she had started that and then decided that she was done with that serie

Alle Folgen von The Mythcreant Podcast

Einstellungen

Darstellung

Sprache

Bestimmt, welche Sender dir auf der Startseite zuerst gezeigt werden.

Verlauf

Zuletzt gehörte Sender und Folgen und deine letzten Suchen liegen nur in diesem Browser.

Hinweise

Ein kurzer Hinweis, wenn ein Podcast, dem du folgst, eine neue Folge hat. Einzelne Podcasts stellst du über die Glocke auf ihrer Seite ab.

Konto

Favoriten speichern – in der App und auf der Website.

Tastenkürzel

/
Suche öffnen
Leertaste
Abspielen oder anhalten
← →
Im Player: 15 s zurück, 30 s vor (Folgen) · im Regal: nächste Kachel
↑ ↓
Im Regal: Ziel innerhalb der Kachel
Pos1 / Ende
Im Regal: erste bzw. letzte Kachel
Esc
Fenster oder Menü schließen
?
Diese Übersicht
Läuft gerade

Zur Senderseite

Als Nächstes

    Folgen mit „Als Nächstes“ vormerken – sie laufen nach der aktuellen Folge.