Zum Inhalt springen

586 – Depicting Travel and Transport

03.05.2026

Shownotes

Your characters start in one place. You would like them to be in another place, and the magic system doesn’t include teleportation. That means it’s time to depict some travel, which can range from the best moments of a story to the equivalent of needing to eat your veggies before dessert. Which end your story falls on depends on both understanding how travel works and properly setting expectations. Also, having more than one horse per person. That’s very important.

Show Notes Transcript

Generously transcribed by Michael Frank. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.

Chris: You’re listening to the Mythcreants Podcast with your hosts Oren Ashkenazi and Chris Winkle.

[Opening Theme]

Chris: Welcome to the Mythcreants Podcast. I’m Chris …

Oren: And I’m Oren.

Chris: So Oren, I want my protagonist to go on a dangerous journey to the center of this dark, enchanted wood. But then I realized I also want a friend from their hometown to just to be there when the protagonist arrives. And to be clear, this is somebody that the protagonist left behind at their hometown.

Oren: Mm-hmm.

Chris: So they needed to get there ahead. And I was just thinking, well, I suppose the town could just invent a transporter while they are traveling. You know? Problem solved.

Oren: Is that you the later seasons of Game of Thrones?

Chris: [Laughter]

Oren: Which is funny because I never watched later seasons of Game of Thrones. That’s just a thing people say about it. To me, reading the books, it was the opposite. Suddenly in the books it takes forever to get anywhere.

Chris: Yeah, that’s sort of hard. The catch-22 of travel where you want something to take a long time, but you also want it to be super fast whenever it’s plot convenient.

Oren: Right. We made the mistake of being into fantasy, and usually in fantasy stories you don’t have super fast transit. You know? Usually a hallmark of fantasy is that you’re limited in how quickly you can move around. Which, you know, is cool and flavorful until you need to be somewhere. Then it’s a pain.

Chris: I do suspect that in space it’s easier to make everything just move at the speed of plot. ‘Cause you know, space is big and amorphous and it’s not that you couldn’t establish, like, Earth to Alpha Centauri-whatever takes this such and such time, and then later have it be a different time. But …

Oren: I mean, that is something that has been increasingly noticeable to me in every iteration of Star Wars and Star Trek, which is that travel times seem to shrink. And I don’t know for sure. It’s not like I’ve measured them. But I’ve just noticed that, especially in the newer versions of Star Wars and Star Trek, it kind of feels like when they want to go somewhere they’re just immediately there.

And maybe it was just more about the pacing of the actual scenes than real travel time, but it certainly felt like it took a little longer to get places in older iterations of both franchises.

Chris: I mean, I can believe that because usually the pace of stories is also continuously kind of sped up as times pass. But in this case, it’s partly about the believability of how fast. Does it feel real? Does it really feel like they’re traveling if they go there instantly? But like, once the audience gets used to, “okay, we could get there, but it felt like a day passed.” And that becomes realistic, you can kind of keep pushing the boundary if you want characters just to show up instantly.

Not that there isn’t reason to want some delays in travel. We can talk about fantasy. That’s one thing that’s interesting is just by being in different settings fantasy tends to have a very different relationship to travel than science fiction often does.

Oren: Although, I mean with certain magic systems, if you want, you can just start introducing teleportation magic and say, “I don’t wanna deal with that anymore.” It’s not my favorite.

Chris: Yeah. You better put some restrictions on the teleportation magic.

Oren: Yeah, it’s a huge ability. It has a lot of ways that it can potentially interfere with the plot. It’s not something I typically like to introduce.

Chris: Yeah I mean, I think if you wanna use teleportation magic, again, it’s a lot easier if you make it more an analogous to modern day travel or you travel to a portal zone and then you can go from one portal to the other as opposed to spot to spot teleportation.

Oren: Yeah, just being able to teleport wherever you want is gonna ’cause you some problems.

Chris: I mean, it helps if you have to have been there before or if you need an accurate picture of it. I mean, in modern day an accurate picture would be nothing. In some fantasy settings an accurate picture would still something, but I think even those will wear down.

Oren: Oh man! This is a great new plot idea. So you need an accurate picture of something, right? And in modern day, that’s not a problem, except because the internet is now flooded with slop. You look up a picture; is that really what it looks like? Is this a real picture? Who knows?

Chris: [Laughing] I just love the idea of like—so what happens to you if you tried to teleport into something that’s been like slop-ified. So it has something weird in the picture. Like a crab turning into a cabbage, you know?

Oren: Not good things happen to you. Let me tell you.

Chris: Do you go to the alternate slop dimension? Ah man.

Oren: you come out really convinced that you can replace forty percent of your workforce with an LLM.

Chris: [Burst of laughter] Oh no. Let’s get back to the speculative fiction. Let’s escape again, please.

Oren: Yeah. The optimistic fantasy world.

Chris: [Chuckling] Let’s go back to the optimistic fantasy world.

Oren: [Laughter]

Chris: So yeah, science fiction, it’s not that there’s no considerations. I do think that the trope of aliens leaving behind warp gates is particularly interesting.

Oren: Yeah, sci-fi authors love alien warp gates because they both give an explanation for where this technology came from and why the rest of your setting doesn’t seem that advanced. And they help create a reason why people don’t just blow them up if there’s a problem because you can say that they’re made of, like, special alien stuff or like, we can’t rebuild them or they’re invincible. Because that’s a problem with if you have some kind of warp gate system, it makes any kind of interstellar fighting very hard.

And you see this in Babylon 5, where in Babylon 5, after a while they just kind of gave up and every ship could open its own warp gates now. So the actual warp gate next to the station really didn’t seem like it mattered that much. Whereas in like, The Expanse or in Mass Effect their teleportation gates are made outta weird alien stuff. And so they either are afraid to mess with it or it’s too difficult to destroy, so you just have to accept that ships are gonna be coming through that.

Chris: I did notice in Star Flight Academy how they did have to come up with a reason why Discovery—the Discovery ship couldn’t just use its special drive to come to their rescue.

Oren: Yeah. They had to give a reason for that. It’s funny. The spore drive would’ve caused less of a problem if it hadn’t been a prequel, but it’s still kind of a problem. It’s like, your ship can teleport anywhere? Like, alright.

Chris: Again, it’s that point to point teleportation. Because at some point in time just having every single ship, every single force on the enemy or on the good guys be able to go anywhere instantly—that’s just a very different kind of conflict with very different logistics.

Oren: Yeah. I’m not gonna say you can’t do it. I am gonna say that most writers don’t know how to write that. I certainly don’t. 

Chris: I mean, for the purpose of storytelling, we usually need stories where our protagonists are isolated. ‘Cause usually, you know, we have our little scrappy hero who is supposed to be the person who saves the day. And we have to come up with reasons why more powerful people can’t help them. And being physically isolated is a pretty important component of that. So if people are doing teleporting anywhere that certainly makes that harder. Which is why Starfleet Academy of course decided, oh! You know, Discovery’s just busy right now. Can’t come.

Oren: Yeah, they had a techno battle thing about it. Don’t worry. It’s fine.

Chris: The other thing that’s interesting is the fact that technically the speed of travel should usually affect the speed of communication.

Oren: Yeah. That’s another thing that is hard to wrap your head around as a modern person. The idea that messages in a lot of fantasy settings can’t go that much faster than a person can travel. There are some options. Fantasy settings can have limited communication over distances. You can set up smoke relays. If you’re a little more advanced, you can do something like the clacks towers from Discworld, which are based on a real thing. The Discworld versions are a lot more capable than the real version, but you know, they exist. And the more advanced you get the more options. But generally speaking, there isn’t a lot of information that’s going faster than a human can travel. And that’s also the same in some sci-fi settings actually. In some sci-fi settings there’s no intergalactic wireless. Messages move at how quickly a messenger ship can get there.

Chris: Although I do think in a lot of Star Trek episodes don’t they have some very long distance video calls?

Oren: Oh yeah, yeah. No, Star Trek doesn’t work like that. In Star Trek you can Zoom with anybody at any. And they have an explanation for that. They call it “subspace buoys,” which is how they explain how you can call Earth to anywhere in the Federation. But Voyager can’t call Earth ’cause there aren’t any buoys in the way.

Chris: But Voyager does eventually. Is it when they reach the buoys?

Oren: No, they access an ancient alien communication network. So sort of, but not Starfleet’s. I think it’s the Hirogen who used to be real big on building interstellar communication networks, and then they decided to be “diet Klingons” instead. Interesting cultural evolution.

Chris: I guess the useful thing of having all of your protagonists doing a long journey—traveling from one place to another—is if you have like one spot where people have the ability to communicate across the galaxy, then they’re only gonna be there for a temporary time, and then you can just take it away again.

Oren: I mean like, if you’re having it based on infrastructure you have a lot of flexibility. Because if you want your characters to be able to get messages and not have to go across the universe to get them, you can say, oh well, we stopped at a planet that had a big subspace antenna and so we were able to get some mail. But now we’re going out into the less developed area, so we’re not gonna be getting those.

Chris: But I will say that if you do want—kind of regardless of what you do, this is one of those things where if you’re doing it consistently it’s probably gonna constrain you at some point. There is no perfect solution that means that everything is plot convenient for you when you’re plotting as possible, but still is gonna seem perfectly consistent to the reader.

Oren: And you have to decide how much do you wanna lean into this? Because if you look at, for example, just a relatively recent example in real history in the run up to the American Revolution a lot of what happened had to do with the speed of travel. There were several attempts to cool down tension between the colony leaders and Parliament in the UK, but these messages take weeks to get across the Atlantic. And very often something happens while you’re waiting for a message.

Like the British general is waiting for a message from Parliament and the message says, “Don’t do any fighting stuff.” But before he gets that message he sees the colonials are up to something shady and he decides, “Well, I don’t have a message saying I’m not supposed to fight them yet, so I’m gonna go fight ’em.” And you have that kind of dynamic, and that can be fun, right? It helps. It makes your world more immersive. It helps you feel like you’re not just modern people wearing costumes.

But it also gets confusing and difficult. The further you get into a long story the harder it is to keep that up, because the more times you’re gonna risk your character, like missing the crucial information they need to be at a certain place for the story to work properly.

Chris: Yeah. And today everybody’s so used to having their cell phones that the default mindset is like, oh, this is really inconvenient. That character’s over there, but I just want them to know the things.

Oren: Right. Oh man, in role-playing games that’s especially bad because all the players are sitting around the table and they can just talk to each other.

Chris: Yeah, at this point I swear when I’m role playing, it’s like whatever. The team just has a hive mind.

Oren: Yeah! The party hive mind. Recently, we did a little mini Delta Green game and it was set in the ‘60s and I gave you guys walkie talkies. The idea was supposed to be that these were not as effective as regular cell phones. They were supposed to have limited range, and they were supposed to be kind of dangerous to use because they operate on a frequency that other people can listen in on. But after a while it just became clear that that was not what you guys were thinking of them as, and I hadn’t really made that clear in the game. So I just let them function effectively as cell phones, because that was clearly the direction we were going and I didn’t feel like fighting that.

Chris: Yeah. I mean, unless you really are in the mindset to leverage those communication gaps for drama, it just becomes too cumbersome to like, okay, you know? The other players just watched us play this out, but now I gotta repeat it over the walkie-talkie in character. But again, if you want actual travel adventures, which is what fantasy tends to lean into, because by nature it kind of is usually in a setting where traveling is a lot more cumbersome. And we were talking about Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief, which is a travel story where clearly Percy is supposed to be having travel adventures, but it’s awkward because it’s in modern day. So we have to start with an excuse for why he can’t fly.

Oren: ‘Cause Zeus is mad at him.

Chris: Zeus is mad at him, so he better not get in a plane.

Oren: Fortunately, he can’t take a high speed train because this is the United States, so he can’t do that. And for reasons only he and two other twelve-year-olds are allowed to go on the trip, so they can’t drive either. So you know, that worked itself out. [Sarcasticly] Don’t pay too much attention to the explanation for why only him and two twelve-year-olds can go. Just don’t worry about it.

Chris: But yeah, the same thing goes for, again, that balance between do you wanna have a venture while traveling or do you want people to get somewhere instantly? In a lot of fantasy settings one of the tricky things is anytime there’s water people will travel by water. But boats are just kind of—oh! Oh no! I was about to say boats are boring and Oren is— [Laughter]

Oren: [Indignant] How dare—I do beg your pardon, madam!

Chris: Look, there’s just less things for characters to do when they’re on a boat than there is when they’re land traveling.

Oren: Look, they got so many different kinds of knots that need to be tied and there’s a lot of cleaning. You gotta clean boats all the time.

Chris: [Noncommittal] Yes. Uh, it’s very exciting.

Oren: [Chuckling] That is actually an example of the difference between what I was in my notes referring to as active travel versus sedentary travel. Whereas in active travel, you’re either walking or riding a horse maybe. Like, the idea is that it requires constant effort on your part as opposed to sedentary travel where you are just sitting down waiting. If you’re a passenger on a boat or if you’re on a train or in a car that’s mostly sedentary travel.

It’s easier to skip over all that. People don’t expect you to cover it as much because it’s just sort of assumed, yeah, the boat will get where it’s going eventually. Whereas if you’re traveling on foot, it’s like that’s a little bit more of an effort. Readers may expect a little more from you there. 

Chris: Yeah. Let’s talk about that, because that is an issue with fantasy. Do you have to show the traveling? Just because there are many stories where that’s not really what the writer has in mind as far as what they want to depict. No

Alle Folgen von The Mythcreant Podcast

Einstellungen

Darstellung

Sprache

Bestimmt, welche Sender dir auf der Startseite zuerst gezeigt werden.

Verlauf

Zuletzt gehörte Sender und Folgen und deine letzten Suchen liegen nur in diesem Browser.

Hinweise

Ein kurzer Hinweis, wenn ein Podcast, dem du folgst, eine neue Folge hat. Einzelne Podcasts stellst du über die Glocke auf ihrer Seite ab.

Konto

Favoriten speichern – in der App und auf der Website.

Tastenkürzel

/
Suche öffnen
Leertaste
Abspielen oder anhalten
← →
Im Player: 15 s zurück, 30 s vor (Folgen) · im Regal: nächste Kachel
↑ ↓
Im Regal: Ziel innerhalb der Kachel
Pos1 / Ende
Im Regal: erste bzw. letzte Kachel
Esc
Fenster oder Menü schließen
?
Diese Übersicht
Läuft gerade

Zur Senderseite

Als Nächstes

    Folgen mit „Als Nächstes“ vormerken – sie laufen nach der aktuellen Folge.