Zum Inhalt springen

612 – Writing Child Heroes

01.11.2026

Shownotes

There are plenty of reasons to write stories about children, the most prominent being that children want to see themselves represented in fiction. However, child protagonists come with a unique set of challenges, especially when tasked with solving high-stakes problems that would normally fall to adults. This week, we talk about ways to set your child heroes up for success, as well as tips for maintaining believability and getting those pesky grown-ups out of the way.

Show Notes Transcript

Generously transcribed by Maddie. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.

Chris: Welcome to the Mythcreant Podcast. I’m Chris. 

Oren: And I’m Oren. 

Chris: You know, the world is a dangerous place with fascism and AI that poisons people’s minds and global criminals. You know who I think would be the best person to deal with all of this? 

Oren: I can only imagine. 

Chris: I think a child is the perfect person to take care of all of our problems for us.

Oren: Their childlike wonderment would see a path through these intractable problems that we all haven’t figured out how to deal with. That’s logic. That happens all the time. 

Chris: Maybe we just need somebody who will believe in a solution. 

Oren: Maybe the real solution was the friends we made along the way.

Chris: That’s it. We’ve cracked it. So this time we’re gonna talk about depicting child heroes and child protagonists, which comes with its own trickiness and liability that you have to work around to make your story feel believable. First of all, why child heroes? I guess we could take this from two directions. Why are they the hero in the story, which is pretty important. Also, we could talk about why we write about children. 

I think one thing that I find interesting is that it used to be that age brackets felt like they were a little more flexible in what the age of the protagonist was. So if we go back to The Enchanted Forest Chronicles, for instance, which most people read when they were preteens maybe, or pretty young, the protagonist is 16, but that is not a YA book, does not feel like it was written for an older teenage crowd.

It was basically one of the books that people read when they first start reading novels on their own at like, 10 or 12. But these days, generally, traditional publishers anyway, always want the protagonist to be the same age as the audience. So whenever we write for our kids, and I know lots of writers who want to write for their children, we usually end up with a child protagonist, which in many ways is good. Kids do like that. 

Oren: I’ve heard so many different claims about how publishers view age of protagonist in relation to age of reader, but at least in my own experience with YA being the one I know the best, it’s pretty rare for a YA character to be significantly older and even rarer to be significantly younger than the main demographic readership of the book. And I haven’t read a lot of middle grade recently, although the ones that I’ve edited have generally had protagonists about the same age as their target reader. 

Chris: I do think kids are more interested in protagonists that are slightly older than slightly younger. To a child, another kid who’s two years younger than them is like a baby.

Oren: At least that matches my experience where when you’re a kid, you desperately want to be older because then you’ll be more mature and you’ll be able to do more stuff, and the idea of being younger is an anathema. Why would you want that? You can do less things when you’re younger. 

Chris: Or they feel like if you suggest something for them that has a younger protagonist, that you are suggesting they are that young, feel like they’re being talked down to. Then we have our child heroes, and of course the first question is why is this person, why is this protagonist the one to be solving these problems?

Oren: Well, ’cause the author wanted them to. That’s actually what it says in the story. We’ve solved that problem already. That was pretty easy. 

Chris: [Chuckles] This isn’t a huge problem for every story. Some stories do have a scope that’s appropriately small, where it makes sense generally for a person to solve their own problems. And we can talk later about, how do we keep their parents from intervening to help them? But if it’s a survival story, for instance, with a kid, it’s not hard to understand, “Why is this kid doing this?” That’s the tactic that both Star Wars and Star Trek took recently with their shows. Prodigy had a group of kids that were in kind of, like, a slave mining camp.

Oren: It was great. Fun times. 

Chris: Right. And of course, they get free, and then they find their own ship and take off with it, and there’s just no adults. Star Wars, they were not in a slave mining camp, but they still randomly find a ship that takes them out, and then they have to figure out how to get back. And so, since we’re not trying to save the world, that certainly makes it easier to figure out why this kid is the one doing it.

Oren: Skeleton Crew was such a funny show conceptually. It was the closest we’re ever gonna get, probably, to Star Wars portal fantasy. The scenes in the kids’ starting planet look so much like a modern American suburb, or at least an idealized TV one, that you could be forgiven for thinking that this was set in the real world. It’s amazing how much they wanted this to be portal fantasy, and someone decided they couldn’t actually do portal fantasy, so they just had to make it look like that as much as possible. 

Chris: [Chuckles] I think that goes back to the idea that the protagonist always has to be a perfect relatable stand-in for the target reader. And I’m not gonna say that doesn’t give it a boost often. I think that people are capable of empathizing with characters that are different from them too. But it felt like with that show, they really wanted that fact where the kids are like, “Oh, I get to go to Star Wars. I get to explore the Star Wars universe.” And so they felt they needed to make the “weird suburban Star Wars looks like middle America environment.”

Oren: Yeah the suburbia planet. Every planet in Star Wars has one environment, and this one was suburbs. 

Chris: That is funny. Obviously, we can have smaller scope yet with something that’s lower stakes if they’re dealing with personal relationships, for instance. Okay, that’s not too hard. But then, of course, the larger the scope of the story gets and the higher the stakes, if it has societal importance, if it’s like the world is ending, then we start needing to get more and more robust reasons for why the child protagonist is the one to do it instead of all of the other people.

Oren: At a certain point, you are going to have to hope that your readers like the story enough to ignore the logical issues. Once your story reaches a certain level of scale, there really is no explanation that will make kids solving this make sense in most cases. There might be some very niche scenarios where there is, but for the most part if you try at that point, you’re gonna end up with the Deadly Education problem, where your story requires ever more complicated world-building explanations to try to address an inherently illogical situation.

If you’re writing Animorphs, you basically have to hope people like Animorphs, and that their desire to watch the kids have cool animal morphing adventures will cancel out the fact that obviously these kids should tell somebody, and they have many options to do so. 

Chris: That definitely helps. Again, if people enjoy the premise, they’re much less likely to call it unrealistic. They’ll give it some grace. So that definitely can factor in. It’s big enough you basically need to have a child that is like a chosen one that has very special unique powers that no one else in the universe has, or in some cases strong societal importance. Like the child ruler, the king or queen or other monarch died, and there’s kind of a reason why this person is of very unique, special importance.

Oren: Animorphs does have reasons, it’s just that they are entirely inadequate if you are in the mood to question them. And the story just kind of hopes that you’re not in that mood. It’s like, “Well, these kids are the ones with the special powers, and they can’t trust anybody ’cause anyone could be a Yeerk, and they don’t want their parents to be in danger.”

They have these different explanations, and those all fall apart on even minimal examination. But if you like Animorphs and you’re having fun, why ask those questions? It has a fairly simple, straightforward explanation. We’re not spending 20 chapters trying to build a Rube Goldberg machine to explain why the kids can’t tell their parents, which would not be really useful and would be really boring to read anyway.

Chris: Let’s talk more about getting adults out of the way. I think that kids not telling parents is something that’s just gonna have to happen. I do think that we should probably watch out for situations that are a little too close to real life, ’cause we have to think about what are kids gonna take away from this, and I personally, one of my biggest pet peeves is the numerous scenes of bullying in stories where there is no thought or consideration taken to the fact that adults have a responsibility to create a safe environment for kids.

Oren: But Chris, if you tell on your bully, you’re a tattletale, and that’s actually worse than being a bully. 

Chris: [Chuckles] Noo. No. 

Oren: I’m going to law school now, so I know these things. 

Chris: Oh, no. 

Oren: [Chuckles]

Chris: Doesn’t going to law school come with some kind of disclaimer? Don’t you have to be like, “Just so you know, people, I’m not a lawyer. I’m a law student, and I’m legally required to tell you that.” Don’t you have to say that? 

Oren: If anything, I think lawyers are famous for not qualifying their statements. They just make really bold pronouncements and leave immediately without specifying. That’s what I’m learning at law school. 

Chris: I’ve met somebody who is relatively knowledgeable about law but not a lawyer. They always immediately spout disclaimers. [Chuckles]

Oren: Lawyers also do that. They just do it slightly differently. They’ll be like, “Yeah, maybe, but that’s not my area of law, so I can’t really comment.” Or if it is their area of law, they’ll be like, “Maybe, but I’m not familiar with the specifics of that case.” So they also do it. Turns out that it’s impossible to actually know anything. Socrates had it right the whole time. 

Chris: I’m gonna have to talk about Sophie’s World, actually. Getting into things like kids should be telling their parents, number one is bullying. If you’re gonna do bullying in a story, please use thought and consideration, and don’t use it as a quick, thoughtless plot device because that’s a real thing, and schools and parents and adults absolutely should be stopping it. It should not be the kid’s responsibility to stop it. And we don’t wanna teach our kids that they should not go and tell on their bullies, ’cause they should. They absolutely should. So I’m reading Sophie’s World, which is a philosophy textbook disguised as a novel, basically. 

Oren: Oh, that sounds great. I wanna do that. I want people to read my philosophy and think it’s a novel. 

Chris: I feel like it’s made way too many people think that this is gonna work out for them, and I don’t think it’s gonna work out for most people. But this author is pretty good at explaining philosophy in understandable ways, although… Let’s not go into my criticisms, other than the story ones.

14-year-old Sophie in this book has a secret philosophy teacher who sends her messages and doesn’t want her to see him or really know who he is. And then Sophie decides not to tell her mother about this. Pretty sure her father signed her up for this philosophy correspondence course, so it’s not like it doesn’t come with any parental approval, but her father is away at his job. He’s not with her right now, and she’s hiding this course from her mother. 

I feel like this is a nightmare parental scenario because this philosophy teacher is absolutely leading her astray when it comes to many things, teaching her to hate people who aren’t interested in philosophy and that they’re lesser and their minds are small. Teaches her to hate teachers. There was no self-awareness that this is in fact a philosophy teacher. And I don’t know, maybe the author’s strategy is whatever philosopher that he’s covering, he just goes with whatever their ideas are without questioning them and just presents them as the right answer. Maybe that’s just how he teaches. 

Oren: At least his idea of what their ideas are. Lot of debates about what exactly these ancient philosophers meant. 

Chris: But this poor mom, her daughter comes up and insults her for not liking philosophy and for being small-minded, and it’s like, this teacher is not having good influence on your kid. And she’s like, “You’ve been weird lately. What’s happening?” And Sophie pretends that this teacher is her boyfriend. 

Oren: Oh. [Laughs] 

Chris: Her boyfriend, she says, is her age, but it’s to explain why she’s really into philosophy now, instead of just telling her mother that she’s taking a philosophy course, which I don’t see why her mom would normally object to. She’s like, “My boyfriend’s really into philosophy and so I’m really into philosophy now, too.”

Oren: What a great scenario for a parent to find out, to have their kid come and tell them, “Yeah, so I’m dating someone, and they’ve been telling me all these things that have completely changed my personality and also made our relationship more hostile.” That’s great. That’s so much better than knowing it’s a weird adult guy in a correspondence course.

Chris: [Laughs] And her mother’s starting to wonder if she’s on drugs. 

Oren: I don’t know, man. That seems like a bad situation. 

Chris: I think with something like Animorphs where it’s like, “Well, there’s aliens taking over the Earth.” I’m a little bit less worried actually about us teaching lids not to tell their parents about that.

Oren: No, that’s too fantastical. It doesn’t really seem like it’s gonna map onto anything that kids will actually encounter. 

Chris: But in some cases you can just tell the parents. In this case, there’s just no reason. I think Sophie’s World doesn’t have much in the way of conflict, so maybe the author’s trying to create more conflict with her mother by not having her tell the mother. But that comes off as very forced. Conflicts generally shouldn’t require characters to not communicate for no reason. That’s something we want to avoid. 

Oren: Maybe the mom is supposed to be conservative or small-minded and anti-intellectual or whatever. That could happen. That’s not impossible. You’d wanna communicate that more clearly.

Chris: Right now she doesn’t seem to be anything wrong with this mother. [Laughs] Other than Sophie’s at home by herself a lot, which is a problem for kids for sure. 

Oren: I’m just throwing darts at wall here, but it could be that in the author’s mind, this mom is a parallel for small-minded conservative parents, but the author doesn’t wanna actually put that in the book ’cause it wou

Alle Folgen von The Mythcreant Podcast

Einstellungen

Darstellung

Sprache

Bestimmt, welche Sender dir auf der Startseite zuerst gezeigt werden.

Verlauf

Zuletzt gehörte Sender und Folgen und deine letzten Suchen liegen nur in diesem Browser.

Hinweise

Ein kurzer Hinweis, wenn ein Podcast, dem du folgst, eine neue Folge hat. Einzelne Podcasts stellst du über die Glocke auf ihrer Seite ab.

Konto

Favoriten speichern – in der App und auf der Website.

Tastenkürzel

/
Suche öffnen
Leertaste
Abspielen oder anhalten
← →
Im Player: 15 s zurück, 30 s vor (Folgen) · im Regal: nächste Kachel
↑ ↓
Im Regal: Ziel innerhalb der Kachel
Pos1 / Ende
Im Regal: erste bzw. letzte Kachel
Esc
Fenster oder Menü schließen
?
Diese Übersicht
Läuft gerade

Zur Senderseite

Als Nächstes

    Folgen mit „Als Nächstes“ vormerken – sie laufen nach der aktuellen Folge.