Zum Inhalt springen

Australian Courts of Appeal (9 November 2026)

09.11.2026 · 19 Min.

Shownotes

Send us Fan Mail

Thirteen headnoted appellate decisions from four courts in the Court of Appeal edition of Monday 9 November 2026, with the New South Wales, Queensland, Western Australia and ACT editions of the same day folded in. Double counting in sentencing police officers; Fair Work costs that the conduct did not cause; hardship and reliance in setting aside a financial agreement; reasons that hide the path; a native title holder's right to be heard; an off-the-plan sunset rescission refused; and admissions, totality and youth sentencing. Violence against a woman in a mental health crisis, family violence, sexual offences against children and a child's terrorism offence are reported as legal doctrine only, as are the children's matters.

Criminal Law Desk (opening story; doctrine only).

  • Black v R; Trautsch v R [2026] NSWCCA 185 - a s 21A(2)(f) gratuitous cruelty finding for an assault risks double counting and is not engaged merely because violence exceeds the ordinary (result agreed; reasoning Dhanji J's, McNaughton J noting no zero baseline for police, Coleman J that it is not an absolute bar); available for the prohibited weapon offence; trust and authority under s 21A(2)(k) are distinct and a judge finding both must articulate what one adds. Leave granted, appeals allowed, both resentenced to full-time imprisonment (Dhanji, McNaughton and Coleman JJ; also Monday's New South Wales edition). JADE

Practice and Procedure Desk.

  • HealthX Group Pty Ltd v Palling [2026] FCAFC 141 - a s 570(2)(b) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) costs order needs a causal nexus between the unreasonable act or omission and the incurring of costs; withdrawing a contention is not of itself unreasonable; obiter, a late restraint claim may lack reasonable cause under s 570(2)(a); no error in a failure to make a finding not sought below. Appeal allowed in part (Snaden, Meagher and Bennett JJ; also today's Federal Courts brief). JADE

Family Law Desk (legal doctrine only; no party identified; all nine also in today's Federal Courts brief).

  • Bray & Poole [2026] FedCFamC1A 194 - s 90K(1)(d) hardship needs some comparison of positions with and without the agreement, not a net asset accounting; s 90K(1)(b) misrepresentation needs inducement; Browne v Dunn and affidavit evidence; Kennon: lay evidence suffices, litigation conduct is not family violence without more; unexplained equal contributions plainly wrong. Order 1 appeal dismissed; property orders set aside and remitted for rehearing before a different judge (Williams, Jarrett and Behrens JJ). JADE
  • Massen & Massen [2026] FedCFamC1A 200 - reasons that do not expose the path to a critical finding are an error of law. Appeal allowed; s 79 applications remitted for rehearing by a different judge (Williams, Kari and Parker JJ). JADE
  • Zenta & Zenta [2026] FedCFamC1A 203 - findings disturbed only if demonstrably wrong or glaringly improbable; best interests are values, not facts. Appeal dismissed (Schonell J). JADE
  • Wick & Hopper [2026] FedCFamC1A 198 - interim parenting orders: no statutory baseline; unilateral relocation does not alter s 61C responsibility; consequences of untested allegations may be weighed without findings. Appeal dismissed; the allegations remain for the final hearing (Christie J). JADE
  • Panza & Adriaansen [2026] FedCFamC1A 192 - a partial property distribution is neither notional property nor a s 90SM(4) contribution; reasons silent on its s 90SM(5) treatment vitiated the adjustment; discretion re-exercised. Ground 5(c) upheld, otherwise dismissed (McClelland DCJ). JADE
  • Sallings (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC1A 197 - dismissal of a leave application finally determines the controversy; relitigation is an abuse rightly rejected for filing. Application dismissed (Schonell J). JADE
  • Mikhailova & Parrino [2026] FedCFamC1A 202 - on an extension of time the substantial issue threshold comes first; s 79A(1)(a) looks to circumstances at or before the orders. Application dismissed (Schonell J). JADE
  • Rothman & Rothman [2026] FedCFamC1A 199 - transcript deadline extended on condition the appeal stands dismissed in default; no dispensation (Schonell J). JADE
  • Lunde & Lunde (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC1A 201 - time extended and the hearing vacated; liberty to apply should be used (Schonell J). JADE

Public Law Desk.

  • Ut-Alkar Aboriginal Corporation v Chief Executive Department of Environment [2026] QSC 263 - a s 527 Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld) appeal is a rehearing that cannot be resolved by consent; a directly affected non-party native title holder was entitled to a reasonable opportunity to be heard; a submission on the file is not a hearing. Consent orders set aside and the appeals remitted to the Land Court (Henry J; Queensland edition). JADE

Commercial Law Desk.

  • Casula Estate Pty Ltd ACN 643 475 414 as trustee for Casula Estate Unit Trust v Singhal and; Casula Estate Pty Ltd ACN 643 475 414 as trustee for Casula Estate Unit Trust v Lenka [2026] NSWSC 1409 - s 66ZS Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) does not qualify the vendor's contractual preconditions; unreasonable conduct includes communications with purchasers; self-representation does not lower the standard of proof. Claims dismissed; deposits repaid with interest (Pike J; New South Wales edition). JADE

Criminal Law Desk (doctrine only; no complainant identified).

  • Singh v The King [2026] VSCA 262 - admissions to contextual conduct are admissible; incident-specific admissions may be directed to that charge; no unrequested ambiguity direction under s 16(1) Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic). Extension refused (Boyce, Donaghue and Kaye JJA). JADE
  • Ollis v The King [2026] VSCA 254 - absence of common aggravating features is not mitigating; comparables a yardstick; totality judged against all sentences and cumulation orders. Extension refused (Walker JA). JADE
  • R v RK [2026] NSWSC 1414 - diminished relevance of youth is not an overriding principle in terrorism sentencing; no principle mandates full-time imprisonment for every young offender. Community correction order (Campbell J; New South Wales edition). JADE

Docket and registry (Lu v Tasman from a synopsis; the rest listed without a headnote; no outcome stated).

  • Lu v Tasman 61 Bh Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1419 - capitulation costs; offer of compromise checklist; indemnity costs (synopsis only). JADE
  • Kchevetskaia v Korlevic [2026] NSWSC 1243 - pleadings. JADE
  • Michales v CharterLaw Legal Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1416 - strike out. JADE
  • In the matter of Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 1420 - scheme of arrangement. JADE
  • Toohey v Mapp [2026] NSWSC 1417 - probate. JADE
  • Wong v Mooney [2026] NSWLEC 1745 - tree dispute. JADE
  • Manly Property Group No. 2 Pty Ltd v Northern Beaches Council [2026] NSWLEC 1747 - development consent appeal. JADE
  • Sutton Property Pty Ltd v AAKK Investments Pty Ltd [2026] QSC 266 - costs. JADE
  • Rotella v Meschberger [2026] WASC 486 - estate administration. JADE
  • Westpac Banking Corporation v Farrant [No 7] [2026] WASC 488 - interlocutory orders. JADE
  • DPP v Chan (No 4) [2026] ACTSC 426 - criminal trial procedure. JADE
  • DPP v Chan (No 3) [2026] ACTSC 424 - sentencing. JADE

Two family property cases are remitted for rehearing, the interim parenting allegations are untested and remain for the final hearing, two family appeals are still to be heard, and the Queensland appeals return to the Land Court; nothing is predicted. Anyone facing a charge in the registry's criminal listings is presumed innocent.

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Alle Folgen von The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw

Einstellungen

Darstellung

Sprache

Bestimmt, welche Sender dir auf der Startseite zuerst gezeigt werden.

Verlauf

Zuletzt gehörte Sender und Folgen und deine letzten Suchen liegen nur in diesem Browser.

Hinweise

Ein kurzer Hinweis, wenn ein Podcast, dem du folgst, eine neue Folge hat. Einzelne Podcasts stellst du über die Glocke auf ihrer Seite ab.

Konto

Favoriten speichern – in der App und auf der Website.

Tastenkürzel

/
Suche öffnen
Leertaste
Abspielen oder anhalten
← →
Im Player: 15 s zurück, 30 s vor (Folgen) · im Regal: nächste Kachel
↑ ↓
Im Regal: Ziel innerhalb der Kachel
Pos1 / Ende
Im Regal: erste bzw. letzte Kachel
Esc
Fenster oder Menü schließen
?
Diese Übersicht
Läuft gerade

Zur Senderseite

Als Nächstes

    Folgen mit „Als Nächstes“ vormerken – sie laufen nach der aktuellen Folge.