
Ep 24 – “Putin Will Not Stop Until He Is Stopped”: H.R. McMaster on the Future of War
Shownotes
Ukraine is not fighting Russia. It is fighting an axis: Russian soldiers, Chinese electronics, Iranian drones, and North Korean troops on European soil, at least 6,000 of them by his count, with something like 10 million North Korean artillery rounds behind them. Four governments, different objectives, one shared aim: tear down the rules of international order and replace them with rules that suit authoritarians.
Lieutenant General H.R. McMaster was National Security Advisor of the United States under President Trump and is now at the Hoover Institution. He gave this talk in London on 8 September 2025, at the Ukraine Freedom Summit, to a room of Ukrainian veterans, defense industry leaders and serving soldiers, weeks after Anchorage and days after the dictators met in Tianjin and Beijing. The news in the questions has moved on. The argument has not.
His case starts at the strategic level. The West, he argues, talked itself out of confronting this axis and still imagines it can be split, China from Russia, when every one of them overextended because it perceived weakness. Then it goes back a century: Ukraine today looks to him like the Western Front, where the machine gun and massed artillery killed the offensive, the Germans answered with the elastic defense and small infiltrating teams, and only the tank gave mobility back. This time, he says, the technology will be different: one operator controlling many drones, computing at the edge, and a loop between the people who fight and the people who design that Ukraine has made shorter than anyone thought possible.
He closes on four things that do not change. War is an extension of politics. War is human: Thucydides named fear, honor and interest two and a half thousand years ago and nothing has replaced them. War is uncertain. And war is a contest of wills, which is where he says Afghanistan was lost: "we talked ourselves into defeat."
In the questions he lays out the four moves Putin uses on every Western leader, the two arguments that actually work with Americans, what Putin wanted at Anchorage and did not get, and why no negotiation succeeds without power behind it.
Recorded in London, 8 September 2025.
KEY MOMENTS
4:21 - An axis of aggressors: Russia, China, North Korea, Iran
6:13 - Provoked by weakness: from the Syria red line to Kabul
11:28 - The Western Front mirror: Materialschlacht to Hutier tactics
15:06 - One operator, many drones: autonomy at the edge
20:33 - Four continuities: war is an extension of politics
25:38 - "We talked ourselves into defeat"
28:40 - Putin's four-step playbook for Western leaders
34:44 - Shultz, the shadow of power and a Finland-style loan
37:07 - Seized assets, secondary sanctions and the shadow fleet
Produced by the Borderlands Foundation.
Support our work: https://theborderlandsfoundation.org
Why War Matters — Sam's San Francisco talk. Part I is free:
https://ukraineforfounders.com/talk/
All episodes: https://ukrainemilitaryhistory.org/
Guest — Lt. Gen. H.R. McMaster:
Hoover Institution: https://www.hoover.org/profiles/h-r-mcmaster
Built & Promoted with https://storyfunnels.ai