376: The Problems with Punishment, with Bryan Post
Notas do episódio
Punishment feels like it's working. Compliance shows up fast, and for a minute it looks like the lesson landed. But according to child behavior expert Bryan Post, that quick compliance is often the opposite of learning, it's the brain shutting down under stress.
In this conversation, Bryan and I dig into the real difference between punishment and discipline. Punishment is force or coercion aimed at controlling, suppressing, or changing behavior. Discipline, by definition, is meant to teach. But most of us were raised to believe they're the same thing, so what we call discipline in our own homes is often punishment wearing a nicer name.
Bryan leans on neuroscience to explain why this matters so much for our kids. When the brain is stressed, thinking becomes confused, short-term memory shuts off, and the ability to learn goes offline. That means punishment doesn't just feel bad in the moment, it actively blocks the very mechanism a child needs to take in the lesson we're trying to teach. And the same is true for us as parents. A stressed out adult cannot calm a stressed out child. It's not possible.
We talk through Bryan's simple, three-part practice, breathe, slow down, soften, and why it's one of the most powerful tools available to us in the middle of a hard moment. We also get into why acting-out behavior is often a sign a child has regressed to a younger emotional age, how to trace our own reactivity back to its roots, and why relationship, not control, is the thing that actually changes behavior long term.
If you've ever wondered why the same old approaches keep producing the same frustrating results, this episode offers a different way to think about it.
Listen to the full episode now.
Take the free quiz to find out where to start with your neurodivergent child: parentingadhdandautism.com/quiz
Show notes and more resources at parentingadhdandautism.com/376
This Episode Is Sponsored by Stasis Kids
Stasis Kids is the first day-and-night nutritional supplement system built for children who take stimulants.
Stimulants are effective, and for many families they are essential. They also come with familiar daily realities: energy and focus tapering later in the day, evenings that can be harder to wind down from, and moods that shift as the day goes on. Until now, no supplement system had been built specifically for children navigating those realities: one designed to support a child's routine, rather than working against it. Stasis Kids was created to fill that gap.
Now available in both gummies and capsules. Third-party tested. Pediatric-formulated.
Click here to learn more and use discount code COMPLEX for 15% off.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/beautifully-complex--6137613/support.
You can find additional resources at parentingadhdandautism.com. It's not just about the struggles, it’s about progress, one step at a time.
In this conversation, Bryan and I dig into the real difference between punishment and discipline. Punishment is force or coercion aimed at controlling, suppressing, or changing behavior. Discipline, by definition, is meant to teach. But most of us were raised to believe they're the same thing, so what we call discipline in our own homes is often punishment wearing a nicer name.
Bryan leans on neuroscience to explain why this matters so much for our kids. When the brain is stressed, thinking becomes confused, short-term memory shuts off, and the ability to learn goes offline. That means punishment doesn't just feel bad in the moment, it actively blocks the very mechanism a child needs to take in the lesson we're trying to teach. And the same is true for us as parents. A stressed out adult cannot calm a stressed out child. It's not possible.
We talk through Bryan's simple, three-part practice, breathe, slow down, soften, and why it's one of the most powerful tools available to us in the middle of a hard moment. We also get into why acting-out behavior is often a sign a child has regressed to a younger emotional age, how to trace our own reactivity back to its roots, and why relationship, not control, is the thing that actually changes behavior long term.
If you've ever wondered why the same old approaches keep producing the same frustrating results, this episode offers a different way to think about it.
Listen to the full episode now.
Take the free quiz to find out where to start with your neurodivergent child: parentingadhdandautism.com/quiz
Show notes and more resources at parentingadhdandautism.com/376
This Episode Is Sponsored by Stasis Kids
Stasis Kids is the first day-and-night nutritional supplement system built for children who take stimulants.
Stimulants are effective, and for many families they are essential. They also come with familiar daily realities: energy and focus tapering later in the day, evenings that can be harder to wind down from, and moods that shift as the day goes on. Until now, no supplement system had been built specifically for children navigating those realities: one designed to support a child's routine, rather than working against it. Stasis Kids was created to fill that gap.
Now available in both gummies and capsules. Third-party tested. Pediatric-formulated.
Click here to learn more and use discount code COMPLEX for 15% off.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/beautifully-complex--6137613/support.
You can find additional resources at parentingadhdandautism.com. It's not just about the struggles, it’s about progress, one step at a time.