
Ep. 137 - Do Texas School Takeovers Help Kids? | Dr. Rachel White (Univ. of Texas)
Notas do episódio
When Texas public schools repeatedly receive failing accountability ratings, the state can intervene, replace locally elected school boards, or even close campuses. But do these interventions actually improve student achievement, and is Texas measuring school performance fairly?
On this episode of Texas Talks, host Brad Swail welcomes Dr. Rachel White, Associate Professor in the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy at the University of Texas at Austin. White is also the founder and principal investigator of the Superintendent Lab, home of the National Longitudinal Superintendent Database, which tracks leadership across more than 12,500 public school districts nationwide. A former school board member, she brings experience in education policy, school governance, and superintendent leadership.
Brad and Dr. White examine Texas's A–F school accountability system and the state laws governing intervention in struggling school districts. Under Texas law, five consecutive unacceptable ratings at a single campus can require the education commissioner to appoint a board of managers for the entire district or close the campus. White explains the differences between state monitors, conservators, and full district takeovers, while questioning whether these interventions consistently produce better long-term outcomes for students.
The conversation explores the challenges of holding schools accountable when the state's grading methodology changes over time. White argues that school ratings should consider more than standardized test performance, including student growth, attendance, community conditions, teacher retention, and the broader educational experience.
Brad challenges White on whether schools that repeatedly fail to meet state standards should face stronger consequences, and whether a more comprehensive accountability system would be practical for Texas to administer.
They also discuss the state takeover of Houston Independent School District, where academic ratings have improved but questions remain about teacher turnover, declining enrollment, district spending, and the long-term effects of state management. White explains why evaluating the takeover requires looking beyond improved letter grades and considering what happens when local governance is eventually restored.
Looking toward the 90th Texas Legislature, White outlines potential reforms to school accountability, teacher compensation, school finance, and state-district relations. She argues for a greater emphasis on state support rather than state intervention, with local communities playing a larger role in determining how schools improve.
The episode concludes with a discussion of superintendent turnover and why stable district leadership matters for students, families, and communities.
Can Texas maintain rigorous academic standards while preserving local control and developing a more complete picture of student success? Join Brad Swail and Dr. Rachel White for a detailed examination of the future of public education in Texas.
00:00 - Opening: Do State School Takeovers Actually Work?
00:14 - Introducing Dr. Rachel White
00:58 - Rachel White's Background in School Governance
03:20 - The Superintendent Lab and Education Leadership Research
08:23 - How Texas State Intervention Works
11:34 - Does Research Support State School Takeovers?
13:00 - Problems With Texas's A–F Accountability System
16:25 - What Should Schools Be Held Accountable For?
18:25 - Can State Officials Fix Struggling Schools?
22:09 - Student Mobility, Poverty and Academic Performance
24:34 - Measuring Student Growth Beyond Standardized Tests
27:06 - How Takeover Threats Affect School Leadership
31:24 - Alternative Measures of School Performance
35:24 - Houston ISD: Academic Gains and Unanswered Questions
39:36 - Restoring Local Control After a State Takeover
43:03 - Parent Petitions and Campus Closures
44:56 - When Can a State Takeover End?
46:05 - What Texas Needs From Its Next Education Commissioner
50:21 - School Accountability and Legislative Reform
52:22 - Teacher Pay, School Finance and Funding Equity
54:25 - Special Education Funding and Teacher Support
55:25 - Superintendent Turnover and Student Success
Watch Full-Length Interviews: https://www.youtube.com/@TexasTalks
Follow us on social media
X: @Texas_Dispatch
Instagram: thetexasdispatch
LinkedIn: The Texas Dispatch
TikTok: texas_talks_podcast
Find more at The Texas Dispatch
Your source for state news, policy, and investigative journalism.
https://thetexasdispatch.com