
596 – Annoying Portrayal of Writers in Fiction
Notas do episódio
Writers often have difficulty portraying other people’s jobs. There are so many little details to get right, tricks of the trade that are difficult to research, and perspective that can only be gained from years of experience. But you’d think if there was one profession writers could get right, it would be writing. Absolutely not the case.
Show Notes- Romanticism
- Deep Space Nine: The Muse
- Middlemen
- Lord Byron
- La La Land
- Stranger Than Fiction
- Proactive vs Reactive Fiction
- The Everlasting
- Death of the Author
- Middlegame
- Story Within a Story
- Ten Thousand Doors of January
- The Name of the Wind
- Interview With the Vampire
- The Princess Bride
- Pseudo Structures
- Hero With a Thousand Faces
- Voyager: Worst Case Scenario
Generously transcribed by Ace. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.
Chris: You’re listening to the Mythcreant Podcast with your hosts Oren Ashkenazi and Chris Winkle.
[Intro Music]
Oren: And welcome everyone to another episode of the Mythcreant Podcast. I’m Oren.
Chris: And I’m Chris.
Oren: Chris, I have a question. Have you ever researched a profession or job that you were going to write about?
Chris: Um, I plead the Fifth?
Oren: Oh, well, trick question. I know you have, ’cause I saw you researching farming, and your character’s not even a farmer, they’re just from a farm.
Chris: Okay, I guess I have. I always feel like my research is not enough, okay? I always feel like I could do more.
Oren: I mean, that’s technically true in that you always can do more. But I would say that in general, writers at least have an understanding that they should probably learn about a profession if they are trying to portray it, and do their best. They don’t always succeed. Certainly there is a lot of content out there about, you know, physicists or pilots or doctors or whatever, watching stuff about them and seeing all these mistakes. But you would figure that if there was one profession that writers could get right, it would be writing.
Chris: Yeah, you’d think maybe they should research it more.
Oren: And yet!
Chris: And yet!
Oren: And yet they’re often very annoying. Now, granted, a lot of this is probably just because I have a different opinion about writing than the people who are giving these portrayals. Nevertheless…
Chris: Yeah, it’s probably a combination of that and, like, if we see it in a story, somebody’s trying to make it fit what they think is a good story.
Oren: Yeah.
Chris: But to be perfectly honest, like, some of these things that I see that are obnoxious, they’re the same things that made me go “oh!” when I started giving writing advice and realizing how many aspects of writing culture make it hard for people to learn writing. And that’s why there isn’t better writing advice out there. It’s all connected, man.
Oren: Well, I mean, it is all connected, ’cause it’s all Romanticism.
Chris: Yeah. Okay, okay, yeah. It’s all Romanticism. It ruins everything.
Oren: Not 100% Romanticism, but so many problems about the way that writing is portrayed in fiction is about how you just need to disconnect from the world, stop looking at anything, just go deeper and deeper into your own mind. Just unblock your editor, stream of consciousness, hot alien lady, drain the life force from me to create the perfect book.
Chris: We’re, we’re definitely gonna have to talk about that one. But the weird thing about this is, so I was reading a book about agents recently, Laura McGrath’s Middleman. And one thing it mentions is how much the book industry purposely continues spreading Romanticism as a way of selling books.
Oren: Oh. Yeah, right.
Chris: Right? Now, is it really necessary to sell books? I don’t know, but there’s a big focus on genius, and certainly I think it might be easier to sell an author and books by a particular author if you’re like, “Oh, they’re just a genius.”
Oren: Yeah.
Chris: Which is sad.
Oren: Well, I mean, it’s, it’s hardly a surprise that if you are marketing a piece of art, the artist is often just as important as the art, right? And I think most people would understand that on some level.
Chris: And I would not call that exactly a bad thing in the age of AI.
Oren: Yeah. There’s that. But I also think that at least part of it is that a lot of writers wanna be Lord Byron. And, you know, Lord Byron is famous for, uh, being a huge weirdo, is the most generous way to describe him, and then dying young. So you know, we never had to deal with old, uncool Byron, just like normal, young, exciting, abusive Byron. He did a lot of abuse is all I’m saying.
Chris: Yeah.
Oren: And I think a lot of writers want to be that, and I think that’s where that one Deep Space Nine episode where, uh, Jake runs into a hot alien lady who drains his life force to write a better book, where that’s coming from.
Chris: Yeah, okay. We’re just gonna have to get into this episode.
Oren: Yeah.
Chris: And it’s, uh… Oh, it was supposed to be the B plot, but it became the A plot, right?
Oren: Mm, something like that. Yeah.
Chris: Yeah, yeah. So you know, Jake starts writing a book. It’s not very good. Hot alien lady shows up. She recognizes his natural genius, of course.
Oren: Mm-hmm, which he has.
Chris: And she’s gonna teach him to write better, but of course, she does it not by, like, actually teaching him how storytelling works or how writing works at all, but by just starting to feed off his brain juices to keep him from censoring himself.
Oren: Uh-huh. Mm-hmm.
Chris: Yeah, ’cause that’s, that’s all it takes, folks, is you just stop censoring yourself. Just write the most unhinged stuff imaginable on the page and it’s gonna be brilliant. That’s all it takes.
Oren: Right. Also, use a pen that famous authors use. She gives him, like, a famous author’s pen.
Chris: Yeah, make sure to use a traditional inkwell pen on physical paper.
Oren: Yeah. That’ll work great. That will definitely help.
Chris: Mm-hmm, yeah. And make sure you have a study with a big fancy wood desk and shelves full of books, you know?
Oren: Yeah. I mean, don’t get me wrong. I can totally see how being in the proper atmosphere might help you relax and get in the mood for writing. Uh, but the way that it’s presented in the s- in the TV episode is very… almost like this pen has magical powers, right?
Chris: Yeah.
Oren: And of course, you know, that feeds into the whole, you know, we hate editors. We don’t like the idea of studying this because that would make it less magical. It’s gotta be just pure soul. And this is a thing that continues with Jake’s character for a while, right? The show continually emphasizes this idea that he is a good writer because of his natural genius that he just has to figure out how to get out of the way of, right?
Chris: Mm-hmm. Yeah. And again, it goes to hiding… You know, most of the time editors, agents do not talk about what changes or suggestions they’ve made to a book. They pretend, “Oh, no, it’s all the author,” right? So we can build this aura of genius around them, which is… Again, I’ve said it before, it’s very toxic to writers because how is a new writer supposed to live up to this idea of being an automatic effortless genius, right? So is it worth doing this for selling books? I think readers would still buy books without Romanticism.
Oren: I mean, I don’t know. They barely buy books now, so who can say? This also ties into another one that I’ve just increasingly found annoying, which is the instant mega hit overnight success. And it’s not that this never happens, but it’s quite rare and it doesn’t usually happen the way that it is portrayed in books, right? Like, usually even if your book is very successful by book standards, you’re still not usually going to be a millionaire immediately, right? You know, if you get a six-figure advance, that’s a lot of money- And it’s potentially life-changing money, but it’s not like 1% money.
Chris: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Oren: Which is what I think people think that’s what a successful book looks like. You know, a successful book means that you are a bazillionaire now, and I can’t prove this, but I also suspect that part of this is why book piracy is as common as it is, is that people think that authors are rich. They think, “Oh, well, it’s okay to pirate this guy’s books because, like, they were on the New York Times bestseller, and the only way that that could happen is if they are rich.” And I mean, I know that at least some people think this, ’cause yes, they say it on social media. They argue with the author that it’s okay to pirate their books, which I’m just… How are… How did you not die from shame doing that, is the part I don’t understand.
Chris: Oh my gosh.
Oren: Like, the idea of telling an author that I’m pirating their books and it’s okay, how did you not just combust instantly from doing that? I have no idea.
Chris: Meanwhile, many bestselling authors have day jobs. So you know, not great. Not a great look.
Oren: And of course, even the authors who do reach great success, it is almost never like, “And then I opened the inner floodgates and let my story out,” right? There’s almost always, when you dig into it, multiple drafts, and there’s editing. Even if they are discovery writers, which some of them are, they almost always have to make changes. They usually have books that they released first that didn’t do very well, or books that they maybe trunked because they weren’t marketable. Not necessarily worse, just not what the market wanted at that time, right?
Chris: Yeah, this reminds me of all of the, like, TV episodes where as soon as the protagonist puts something online, it goes viral. And rarely do they write anything that I think in real life had any chance of going viral. It’s like, well, it’s really hard to make viral content, because it has to stand out, and it’s a moving target. But everything goes viral in a story. But yeah, no, related to that, I was very annoyed with the ending of La La Land. This is a movie about two artists, an actor and a musician in Hollywood, who are trying to, you know, get their breakout. And one thing that really struck me about this is we’re clearly going with the idea where we don’t want a super happy ending, ’cause it would be too pat. And these two people are having a romance with each other. So to me, it made sense that, because again, most people who go to Hollywood don’t make it big. Right? More people who go into acting end up just… It’s so hard to get roles. It’s amazingly difficult to get a role as an actor, just amazingly difficult to break in. And ’cause, you know, people only look at you if you already have acting credits, so how do you get your first acting credit? It’s very similar to trying to break in and get an agent, for instance. So, well, I was expecting them to end up together, but not actually break out. But instead, they both become, like, huge successes.
Oren: Oh, good.
Chris: And one of them, by putting on a one-person play that literally almost nobody goes to, like the theater is totally empty, but apparently one of the few people in the audience is a casting director who happened to love her. And it’s like, really? Casting directors are super busy, and they have tons of people. They create acting workshops and charge people money to give them acting coaching, similar to agents charging money for pitches, to give them pitches in person at conferences.
Oren: Oof, I don’t like that. Yeah. That’s not my favorite.
Chris: No, it’s not my favorite either. So, like, the idea of a casting director just going to some unknown person’s one-woman play and then like, “I’ve discovered you,” and then that person becoming super successful, it just… Man, it feels like it undermines the experiences of most people who go to Hollywood and never break out. But see, the ending’s not pat because they don’t end up together as a couple. And it’s just like, what?
Oren: Look, man, most of us end up dating somebody eventually. Very few of us are gonna get breakout Hollywood roles.
Chris: And, ah, man, I would like, at this point, more stories about somebody trying to become successful as an artist and then realizing they’re never going to get paid a living for their art and then having to deal with that, right? And decide what they’re gonna do. And appreciate the art for the art’s sake, for instance, keep doing their day job or whatever it is.
Oren: Yeah. Somewhat related to the Romanticism thing is… and I know this one is touchy, ’cause this, like, affects authors in real life too, is this thing that I’ve noticed in a number of books where the narrative acts as though the author has zero responsibility to finish a series they’ve started. And I know why they do that. It’s because people were huge entitled dicks to George R. R. Martin and, you know, obviously went way over the line, and it’s probably why we’re never gonna get Game of Thrones over, ’cause at this point, if I was Martin, I would never finish the series, right? But at the same time, it’s weird to act as though there’s no responsibility because you’re effectively selling someone an incomplete product with an implied completion at some point. And if you go full caveat emptor and say, “Well, it’s on them for buying it,” is that really the attitude we want readers to take? That they should not buy a series until it’s finished ’cause they have no assurance at all that it will ever be finished? ‘Cause that’s a problem authors have is that people don’t wanna buy their series until the series is finished.
Chris: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Oren: So I just think maybe there’s a little more to this than some of these portrayals would have you believe.
Chris: Yeah, I mean, I think the problem is that you can’t have it both ways, right? If authors are under no obligation… I mean, again, authors are a single human being. Stuff can always happen, right? So it’s not like anybody’s a bad person for not finishing their series. Stuff happens. At the same time, I do think, you know, when we make certain promises to readers, we have some level of obligation to meet those promises if we can. And we can’t really have it both ways, right? Either we’re not gonna worry about doing it, and that means readers are reading a series at their own risk, and oftentimes they’re just not gonna wanna do that until it’s complete, or we have a serious obligation and we can ask them to trust us if the series isn’t finished yet. And we just kind of have to choose which way we wanna have it.
Oren: I just think that stories that do decide to go into this territory should acknowledge that this is a little bit of a both sides situation. Not like both sides as in “it’s okay to yell at George R. R. Martin,” obviously that’s wrong. But I just think that they should acknowledge that you’re not causing zero problems by not finishing a series you started, right? Like, that is a choice that- assuming it is a choice, maybe it’s not, depends on what’s happening, right? But if you’re making that choice, that does have some consequences.
Chris: Yep, it’s one of many obligations. Again, there are other things that could be more important. But… and certainly we shouldn’t do that and then, you know, tell readers they should start series that are not finished yet.
Oren: Yeah, I mean, you could go that direction and be like, “All right, well, you know, just don’t buy a series until it’s done.” Just, oh boy, that’s probably not a great message.
Chris: I wanna talk about Stranger Than Fiction.
Oren: Oh yeah?
Chris: Another one of those weird movies that depicts the writing process and is, and maybe it’s not as bad as the Deep Space Nine episode with