
587 – Revenge and Forgiveness in Fiction
Notas do episódio
Your hero has sworn to kill their archenemy in a bloody revenge quest. But when the moment comes, should they pull the trigger? We dunno, do you want them to? Revenge stories are often debated as moral issues, but the reality is that how you craft them generally determines whether readers find the results just or not. In a shocking twist, we have some advice.
Show Notes TranscriptGenerously transcribed by Sofia. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.
Chris: You’re listening to the Mythcreant podcast with your hosts Oren Ashkenazi and Chris Winkle.
[intro music]
Oren: And welcome everyone to another episode of the Mythcreants podcast. I’m Oren.
Chris: And I’m Chris.
Oren: So, Chris, do you remember back in 2014, 12 years ago, we had a debate about multiple points of view?
Chris: Mm, yeah. I couldn’t forget that because I won.
Oren: Yeah. See, I pretended to change my opinion and I’ve been planning my revenge for all that time, which is why now you need to beta read my new novel with 500 different POV characters each in their own universe and time period.
Chris: [laughs]
Oren: Or maybe not. Maybe I’ve decided that you’ve suffered enough and that I forgive you.
Chris: I feel like that’s a self-own. I feel like that’s self-revenge right there.
Oren: [laughs] So today we are talking about the concepts of revenge and forgiveness in fiction, specifically in fiction. I’m not making any claims to real life, mind you. That’s a little more complicated.
Chris: Yeah. I could describe what causes a large group of people in general to forgive a person that they do not know personally. Like a character or a public figure. In general trends, I cannot predict what any individual person needs to forgive somebody in their life. Those two things are very different.
Oren: So first, there’s a concept that I see storytellers talk about sometimes with a lot of concern, and it’s this idea of a character being forced to forgive someone.
Chris: I can definitely sympathize that. I think that’s what happens when the GM creates an antagonist that you just love to hate. But then instead of letting you fight them and beat them, he decides to make them sympathetic and then so pathetic and compliant that you’re not really allowed to beat them up anymore. So, you grudgingly start working with them and then the other players think your PC is unreasonable for not forgiving them. Does this sound familiar, Oren? Does it sound like a familiar scenario?
Oren: [laughs] Yeah, well. I mean, this is a whole different ballgame when it comes to role-playing games because those characters have free will and you can’t edit the story, but—
Chris: You couldn’t force me to forgive. But some of the other players were like, really? You can’t forgive this person? No, never. Not doing it.
Oren: There is a prose fiction analogy to that, which is that the reader might disagree with the character. That can happen.
But when it comes to fiction, the way that I would advise people to look at this is you are not trying to force your character to do anything. You are trying to create proper circumstances so that this character, given what you have established about them before, will do the thing you want them to do.
So, if that means you want your character to forgive someone, you have to create the circumstances under which it makes sense for them to do that.
Chris: Yeah. I wanna be fair because I do think some narratives create this impression of forcing forgiveness.
For one, there’s the obvious thing of the other side characters who are clearly supposed to be the storyteller’s mouthpiece insisting that somebody has to forgive.
Oren: If you have direct badgering of your protagonist or some other character by another character in the story, that is definitely gonna change the dynamic of it.
Chris: Right. And again, we’re talking about situations where somebody has seriously wronged another person. Just to be clear: what we’re going off of is the idea that nobody is entitled to forgiveness by somebody they hurt.
So there can be obviously situations where the side characters act like the storyteller’s mouthpiece and insist on it, which is clearly a sign of that pressure. But I do think that sometimes there’s almost nothing that is necessary for a character to forgive in order to do. Because character functionally can take all the same actions, usually to succeed without technically forgiving. Forgiving is different than, for instance, cooperating.
Oren: That gets into the next part of the question, which, what is forgiveness exactly. Like what does that mean? Because that can mean a lot of different things and it matters in this case, this isn’t just a silly semantics question.
Because I think some writers tend to imagine it as we’re friends now and we’re on the same team, and I’ve decided that I am no longer upset by whatever it was that you did.
And that can happen but that’s not the only thing that I think we would think of that way. Right? It’s not the only way this kind of story can play out.
Chris: Yeah, I would think of a lot of different things as alternatives to forgiveness. I think if I were to pick one thing that is forgiveness, it’s that you are no longer holding whatever they did against that person. And that’s, in a lot of situations, still not reasonable. It’s an emotional thing.
Oren: This sort of thing can happen when you have your bad guy do something really bad. They did a real nasty thing, but then you kind of end up liking them. You decide, oh, but they’re kind of cool and they have a sympathetic backstory. And now I want them to be on team good. And I want my main character to hang out with them and for it to not be constantly unpleasant.
And if your reader is reading this and they’re like, well, hang on. That horrible thing happened; I felt that. You did a good job making me feel that I don’t like this.
And of course there’s the two questions. There’s the question of does it feel like it makes sense that the main character did this? And people will argue about that because that often gets tied into the question of is it satisfying that the main character did this?
And if someone doesn’t feel that it’s satisfying, they will often express that by arguing that it does not make sense. Regardless of whether that part is true or not, right? You might actually have made a character who is super forgiving. Maybe your character is Tohru from Fruits Basket who forgives everything immediately. But that might not be satisfying to your reader and you could still find them arguing with you that it doesn’t make sense cause that’s often how readers express themselves.
Chris: I do think that in situations where the readers are still upset after a character like Tohru forgive somebody, there’s probably something else going on. Because people do resent a character who does terrible things and then is successful. People wanna see that karma balanced out.
And I would say that the issue there probably isn’t completely just the forgiveness itself, but that that character hasn’t gotten their karma balanced, hasn’t suffered in accordance with the wrongdoing.
Oren: In Fruits Basket I had a problem with that the matriarch of the family—who is just the worst—I felt like she got off completely scot-free for all the horrible things she did, and is now having a great time. And I did not like that. No, that person sucks. I don’t want any of you to be associated with her anymore.
Chris: Right. I mean, this is the issue with a lot of abuse narratives, right? Because that was an abuse narrative, she was very clearly an abuser.
Often when people are writing these narratives, maybe they feel like it’s too black and white to just say, Hey. That person is bad and we’re just gonna, for at the very least, not have them in my life anymore. For the protagonist part.
And I think it’s an effort to try to make it nuanced. They try to absolve them or make excuses for them and be like, they’re a person too.
That’s very common and it’s not great because unfortunately, in real life, abusers will absolutely use any shred of sympathy you give them. They will apologize and pretend they’ll never do it again, only to do it again cause they’re manipulative people. That’s how abuse is done. That’s definitely a problem there.
And that might be part of the fact that people don’t like Tohru doing it. But I do think that there are some storylines where if the author equates working with somebody with forgiving them and there doesn’t seem like we’re presented with an option of, no, you can cooperate, but you still don’t have to forgive. Or it doesn’t feel natural for the character. There can be other reasons where it just feels a little too contrived.
I think some storytellers do equate forgiveness with this is just how the arc should end. Because the arc hasn’t ended unless there’s forgiveness. For instance.
Oren: Yeah, and of course we were talking about this in terms of revenge, which adds another wrinkle to it.
Because for example, you could have a story where the protagonist chooses not to take revenge, and that doesn’t necessarily mean they have forgiven whoever wronged them. It could mean that they have decided that this is more harmful to me than it is satisfying to get whatever this revenge is. So I’m going to stop, but that doesn’t mean that we’re friends. That doesn’t mean that I’ve stopped holding that against them.
Chris: Yeah. There are a lot of different things that can happen besides just forgiveness and revenge. And I think talking more about what the alternatives are is a good thing.
Personally, I think self-forgiveness is underrated. If we have one person who’s being redeemed, for instance, in another person who wants revenge on them or just is angry at them, have the person forgive themself even if they’re never gonna get forgiveness from the person they hurt. Eventually, once they’ve groveled enough. Of course.
Oren: Once they’ve had kind of a rough time.
This also, of course, raises the question that comes up in a lot of these revenge stories: Is revenge a compelling motivation? The answer is maybe.
Chris: If you get one of those characters that you make it so the audience really hates them that much and wants them to take them down a notch, it can be compelling. I personally wouldn’t try to rely on that.
Oren: For revenge to be the stakes, you have to really make the audience want that to happen, and so usually for that, you’re depending on them really liking your main character. Which is always a gamble because sometimes that’s not gonna work right away. And you are gambling on that they will really care about whatever the thing is. So that means you often have to make it pretty intense. And some people just go for that. Some people really like revenge stories, but others will kind of be like, well, the thing that they we’re trying to get revenge for already happened. Getting revenge isn’t gonna undo it. So is it that important?
Chris: Yeah. Isn’t that why in John Wick, the bad guy kills a dog? Because people get really upset watching a dog die, and so that’s a way of getting them upset enough that they really want to see the antagonist die. A bit harsh. I wouldn’t wanna do that, but it’s clearly worked for the franchise.
Oren: Yeah. Well, it’s so well-known with John Wick now at this point. I feel like if you did it, it would be hard pressed to not look like you were copying John Wick.
Chris: But I certainly wouldn’t want wanting to see a villain suffer, getting that schadenfreude be the only thing driving the story forward.
Oren: Which is usually why authors will add some additional stakes. Like this villain is still doing bad things and so a part of getting revenge will be stopping them. Or sometimes they’ll make it more of a broader justice issue, like this person has wronged a lot of people and so we have to get justice for them.
Chris: I also think when it comes to stakes, if you have something, some level of support, you can do a lot with just putting your protagonist in danger in order to get revenge. If we have a John Wick situation where we think that the audience is very likely to sympathize with this revenge quest and sympathize with our protagonist and we don’t have larger stakes, but we can make it feel like the protagonist is in danger when they are going to get revenge, that is stakes in itself.
It’s just, you need to tide the audience over before your protagonist gets in danger. And of course, you need a strong enough motivation for your protagonist to head into danger. But with revenge, I think that’s not too hard. If we’re going with John Wick as a power fantasy, that maybe doesn’t work as well because then John Wick is probably less likely to feel like he’s in serious danger, and so the stakes then become a little bit less compelling.
But in a lot of works, that would be just fine if you don’t have some evil plan that the antagonist is about to do.
Oren: Yeah. The other—of course—issue is if you do decide to add supplementary stakes, and then you end up wanting the protagonist to decide that actually they’re not going to take revenge—It’s like, all right, but what about all the bad stuff the bad guy is still doing right now? It feels like you’re shirking your responsibility.
I see this happen sometimes in stories that are inspired by superhero comics. Where it’s like, no, I won’t get revenge on the villain. It’s like, all right, but the villain is holding the city hostage, so maybe you still gotta stop him.
Chris: Yeah. I think the problem with a lot of the superhero stuff is, the assumption is you can’t really put them in jail ’cause they’ll just get out again for the next installment.
Oren: It’s weird because that’s almost never a thing in the story. It’s just a thing that infects fan discourse because it’s a meta problem.
Chris: But it’s hard to unsee once you know that’s always gonna happen.
Oren: It’s like, oh, this is kind of predictable that they’re gonna break out again.
Chris: I swear it’s gonna be very permanent. Prison has become very permanent this time.
Oren: That’s one of those things that superhero comics can get away with, that if any of us tried it, it would immediately get us left outta town. I mean, first of all, writing on a series long enough for this to be an issue is unlikely for most of us anyway.
But if you had a series that was several books long and the villain kept breaking out of jail to go do more mayhem and cause more destruction by like the second or third time this happened, your readers would just not continue if your main character was like, yep. Back to jail with you, Mr. Jail Escaper!
Chris: [laughs] Well, I think in most cases the villain would just get very old. People just like, well, you already beat that person. That’s not scary.
Oren: Which is fortunately not a problem most books have. In my experience, that problem is much more common in visual media…
Chris: Yeah, because you have an actor and the villain is more charismatic.
Oren: Or in the case of comics, because the villain is a brand.
Chris: Yeah
Oren: The only time I can think of off the top of my head that this happened in a book series is the first three Wheel of Time books where we fight the same guy and beat him three times.
Chris: That is too much.
Oren: It’s like the rule of three, I guess.
Chris: Yeah. The other thing to point out if your character is gonna reconsider is: have they been murdering any minions? Because if you wanna do the big action sequence where they have to get through all of the goons before they work their way up to the big bad, it’s a really bad luck to then agonize over whether you’re gonna kill somebody after you’ve been throwing people off of roofs.
Those people died and you didn’t agonize over whether you should kill them, even though they’re just earning a paycheck. They could have been strong armed into taking this job. They could be desperate, not have any other options and killed them without a thought. But no, the big bads gotta go to jail and that’s just very tiresome.
Oren: They shouldn’t have been wearing helmets, Chris. If they wanted me to think of them as human beings, I should have been able to see their faces.
Chris: I do think one of the more interesting parts of the Jessica Jones show was the fact that because the minions were just blatantly being mind controlled, she had to avoid hurting them too much when she was fighting. And that did make things harder for her.
Oren: That was very good.
Chris: So that could be interesting, intense. I think a lot of people don’t wanna do it cause they just want their power fantasy, or it takes more thought to avoid killing anybody.
Oren: I will say that also, if you want your character to take revenge, you can just do that. Most of the time. There are some things I see writers do that make that a little weird, but you just go for it, man. We’re not here to have to write our stories to say that revenge is always bad and you should