Pular para o conteúdo

Deep Dive: Farm Transparency (November 2026)

12 de novembro de 2026 · 21 min

Notas do episódio

Send us Fan Mail

A special episode of The Petal: Deep Dive, the judgments that change the law, given the time they deserve. One case, followed through three courts: hidden cameras in a goat abattoir, an animal welfare charity's footage, and the question of who owns a film made by trespassing, and what equity can make the maker do with it. Four chairs: an anchor, a specialist intellectual property academic, a specialist intellectual property practitioner, and a documentary producer.

The facts as found. On seven nights between January and April 2024, people acting for Farm Transparency International entered the fenced Eurobin abattoir of The Game Meats Company of Australia and installed hidden cameras. The charity sent a compilation film to the federal agriculture department and the then Minister, then to Channel Seven (which reported without broadcasting any footage), and posted it online until an ex parte order that evening. The charity admitted the trespasses. The trial judge made no finding that the footage disclosed cruelty or illegal conduct.

Case note

  1. Trial: The Game Meats Company of Australia v Farm Transparency International Ltd [2024] FCA 1455; (2024) 186 IPR 261 (Snaden J, 19 December 2024). Trespass admitted and established; injurious falsehood and Australian Consumer Law s 18 claims dismissed (no imputation of condoning cruelty; lawful political aims, no malice). $30,000 general and $100,000 exemplary damages. Constructive trust over the copyright refused as a "bold step" without authority; injunction refused because the trespass was complete and future damage was not shown to be "extreme, or at all events very serious". JADE
  2. Full Court: The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd v Farm Transparency International Ltd [2025] FCAFC 104; (2025) 312 FCR 272 (Burley, Jackman and Horan JJ, 13 August 2025). Appeal allowed: the charity held the copyright in the images on constructive trust for the abattoir, by analogy with thieves, fraudsters and knowing recipients, the creation of a new asset being no answer, and the Pallant v Morgan line showing no prior fiduciary relationship was needed. Consequential orders: assignment, permanent injunction except to the regulator, deletion, and an affidavit identifying all recipients. Cross-appeal on exemplary damages dismissed (no proportionality rule). JADE
  3. Full Court costs: The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd v Farm Transparency International Ltd (Costs) [2025] FCAFC 134 (Burley and Jackman JJ; Horan J dissenting in part, 25 September 2025). Rejection of an early Calderbank offer (dismissal with each side bearing its own costs, for a permanent non-publication undertaking) unreasonable; indemnity costs after the offer expired. JADE
  4. High Court: Farm Transparency International Limited v The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd [2026] HCA 42 (Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ, 11 November 2026). Appeal allowed in part. As summarised in the Petal's generated Judicial Ledger headnote: (1) all members accepted that where a trespass is complete but its consequences continue, equity's auxiliary jurisdiction extends to a restorative mandatory injunction, without a subsisting right, if damages are inadequate; the threshold was stated differently, with no single majority formulation, and Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ (Beech-Jones J agreeing subject to qualifications) held that exemplary damages must also be inadequate; (2) damages were inadequate here; (3) six Justices held a constructive trust over trespass-derived copyright available only as a discretionary auxiliary remedy, not where lesser orders do full justice or third parties would be injured (Muschinski v Dodds; Giumelli v Giumelli); only Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ positively rejected an institutional trust; (4) the Full Court erred in declaring the trust without first deciding adequacy and the minimum relief; (5) all Justices held the trust inappropriate, because it would arm the abattoir against strangers such as the Commonwealth and Channel Seven, and Gageler CJ and Gleeson J held that failing to recognise the public interest in free speech when fashioning an equitable remedy is an error of equitable principle; (6) the Lenah dicta were confined, on differing reasoning; (7) in place of the trust, a deletion injunction (forthwith, including future copies, an affidavit after each deletion, and a restraint pending compliance), not binding the regulator or the broadcaster; (8) the recipients affidavit was set aside; (9) each party bears its own costs in the High Court, and costs at trial and in the Full Court were remitted to the Full Court. JADE

Press freedom. The Human Rights Law Centre and the Alliance for Journalists' Freedom appeared as amici curiae, arguing that no constructive trust should issue where other orders do full justice, that non-monetary relief must be balanced against freedom of expression and of the media, and that copyright protects expression, not facts. The episode's documentary producer weighs the chill, the editorial safeguards and fairness to both the farmers and the activists.

Cases referenced at the table

  • Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Ltd (2001) 208 CLR 199 JADE
  • Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (1998) 195 CLR 1 JADE
  • Isenberg v East India House Estate Co Ltd (1863) 3 De G J & S 263 JADE
  • Smethurst v Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police (2020) 272 CLR 177 JADE
  • Muschinski v Dodds (1985) 160 CLR 583 JADE
  • Giumelli v Giumelli (1999) 196 CLR 101 JADE
  • Pallant v Morgan [1953] Ch 43 (no JADE link)

The Petal: Deep Dive is part of The Petal from JADE OpenLaw. The daily brief covers each day's decisions in eight minutes; this table takes the big ones slowly. The High Court summary above is drawn from the Petal's machine-generated headnote; check the reasons before relying on any pinpoint. This episode of The Petal: Deep Dive was produced by BarNet OpenLaw, the creators of JADE. The voices are AI-generated. Theme music by Michael Green SC. Nothing in this program is legal advice. The Petal is an experiment and your feedback is essential.

Todos os episódios de The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw

Configurações

Exibição

Idioma

Define quais estações você vê primeiro na página inicial.

Histórico

As rádios e episódios ouvidos recentemente e suas últimas buscas ficam só neste navegador.

Avisos

Um aviso rápido quando um podcast que você segue tem um episódio novo. Desative podcasts individuais pelo sino na página deles.

Conta

Salve favoritos – no app e no site.

Atalhos de teclado

/
Abrir busca
Espaço
Reproduzir ou pausar
← →
No player: voltar 15 s, avançar 30 s (episódios) · na fileira: próximo bloco
↑ ↓
Na fileira: alvo dentro do bloco
Home / End
Na fileira: primeiro ou último bloco
Esc
Fechar janela ou menu
?
Esta visão geral
Tocando agora

Ir para a estação

A seguir

    Adicione episódios com “A seguir” – eles tocam depois do episódio atual.