Skip to content

71: Why Hasn’t God Healed Me Yet? Faith, Health + Letting Go of the Need to Control Healing ft. Dr. Tanya Paynter

November 12, 2026 · 38 min

Show notes

What do you do when you believe God heals, but your symptoms are still there?

What happens when you have prayed, tried to trust, taken care of your body, and still find yourself wondering:

Why hasn’t God healed me yet?

In this episode of Beyond Wellness Culture, Dr. Brook sits down with naturopathic physician and Christian apologetics graduate Dr. Tanya Paynter for a conversation about faith, physical health, doubt, control, and what healing can look like when it does not happen the way you expected.

Dr. Tanya shares her own season of deep spiritual doubt when she began questioning Christianity, Jesus, prayer, and beliefs she had carried for years. Her mental and physical health declined during that season until a prayer asking God to restore her faith became a turning point in both her relationship with Him and the work she does today.

Together, Dr. Brook and Dr. Tanya explore one of the hardest questions many Christian women carry:

Why hasn’t God healed me yet?

Dr. Tanya explains that sometimes we approach that question with one specific outcome in mind.

We may be praying for the pain to disappear.

For the insomnia to stop.

For the symptoms to resolve.

But what if God is working somewhere else at the same time?

What if healing is happening in a relationship, a belief, an old wound, your emotional life, or your relationship with Him?

As Dr. Tanya says, God may answer differently than we expected without being absent from the situation.

In this episode, you’ll hear:

  • Dr. Tanya’s journey from law enforcement to naturopathic medicine
  • The faith crisis that changed her relationship with God
  • Why knowing about God is different from actually knowing Him
  • What may be underneath the question, “Why hasn’t God healed me yet?”
  • Why healing may look different from the outcome you are praying for
  • How spiritual doubt can affect the way you experience your health
  • Why suffering does not automatically mean God is punishing you
  • The difference between your priorities and God’s priorities
  • How health struggles can deepen your relationship with God
  • Why wellness culture can turn healing into another performance
  • How conflicting diets, supplements, and protocols can create more health confusion
  • Why someone else’s health solution may not be your answer
  • What happened when Dr. Tanya stopped automatically reaching for supplements
  • How creating space before reacting to a symptom can change the questions you ask
  • Why caring for your health and trusting God do not have to compete
  • How to move from simply learning about God into a deeper relationship with Him


One part of this conversation gets especially practical when Dr. Tanya talks about her supplement cupboard.

For years, a symptom would show up and she would automatically reach for something to fix it.

Then she realized God was not part of that conversation.

She began pausing first and asking:

“Do I need this, Lord?”

Sometimes the answer was yes.

Sometimes the answer was rest.

And once, the answer was simply:

“What you need right now is a snack.”

That pause helped her stop reacting automatically and begin listening more closely to both her body and God.

This episode is not about refusing support or believing that every symptom should disappear through prayer.

It is about noticing when fear, control, perfection, and the constant search for the next answer begin taking over your relationship with your health.

And it is an invitation to ask a different question:

Instead of only asking, “Why hasn’t God healed this?”

What if you also asked:

“God, where are You working right now?”

CONNECT WITH DR. TANYA

✨ Your body has been trying to tell you something.

Find out what it's saying with the free 30-second Body Signal Decoder Assessment. Pick your signal, get your personalized guide straight to your inbox, and finally start making sense of what's going on inside.

Get it here: os.drbrooksheehan.com/decoder

🎧 And if you caught the mention of the Talk to Me, Body affirmation card deck during the episode, here's where to grab yours. 63 scripture-anchored cards to help you trust the body God designed for you.

Get yours here: drbrooksheehan.com/talk-to-me-body/

📱 Come say hi on Instagram: @drbrooksheehan

⭐ If this episode spoke to you, would you take a second to leave a five-star review on Apple or Spotify? It helps more women find this show. And more women learning to listen to their bodies is exactly why I do this.

All episodes of Beyond Wellness Culture, Women Over 40, Nervous System Regulation, Burnout, Listen to Your Body

Settings

Display

Language

Decides which stations you see first on the home page.

History

Recently played stations and episodes and your latest searches are only stored in this browser.

Notifications

A short notice when a podcast you follow has a new episode. Turn off single podcasts with the bell on their page.

Account

Save favorites – in the app and on the website.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Open search
Space
Play or pause
← →
In the player: back 15 s, forward 30 s (episodes) · in a row: next tile
↑ ↓
In a row: target within the tile
Home / End
In a row: first or last tile
Esc
Close window or menu
?
This overview
Now playing

Go to station page

Play next

    Add episodes with “Play next” – they play after the current episode.