Skip to content

Hunter v. United States: Argued on March 3, 2026

March 11, 2026 · 1 h 35 min

Show notes

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Case Summary:

On March 3, 2026, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Hunter v. United States, a case that examines the limits of plea agreements and whether a defendant can truly waive their right to appeal a sentence that may be unconstitutional.

The case involves Munson P. Hunter III, who pleaded guilty to wire fraud. As part of his plea, he signed a standard "appellate waiver," giving up his right to challenge his sentence. However, at sentencing, the judge imposed a condition requiring Hunter to take any mental health medications prescribed by his doctors—a requirement Hunter argues violates his Fifth Amendment liberty interests. Crucially, after imposing the sentence, the judge explicitly told Hunter, "You have a right to appeal," and the government prosecutor did not object to that statement.

Core Legal Issues

The justices are deciding two major points that affect nearly 95% of federal criminal cases settled by pleas:

  1. The Scope of Waivers: Are the only exceptions to an appeal waiver claims of "ineffective assistance of counsel" or a "sentence exceeding the statutory maximum," or are there broader exceptions for "miscarriages of justice" or unconstitutional sentencing conditions?
  2. The "Waiver of the Waiver": Does a judge’s oral statement at sentencing—telling a defendant they have a right to appeal—override a previously signed written waiver, especially if the government remains silent?

Highlights from Oral Argument

  • Skepticism Toward the Government: Several justices, including Justice Elena Kagan and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, appeared troubled by the government’s "hard line" position. They questioned whether a waiver should really block a defendant from appealing a sentence if, for example, a judge was explicitly racist or imposed a "shocking" and unconstitutional condition.
  • The Contract Law Debate: Hunter’s counsel, Lisa Blatt, argued that plea deals are essentially contracts and should be subject to traditional contract defenses like "unconscionability" or "public policy." However, Justice Samuel Alito and others expressed concern that importing complex contract doctrines into criminal law might make plea deals too unpredictable.
  • Coercion and Power Imbalance: Justice Jackson highlighted the inherent power imbalance in plea negotiations, questioning whether a defendant can "voluntarily" waive a right to challenge a sentence that hasn't even been determined yet.
  • The "Silent Prosecutor" Problem: Much of the bench focused on the fact that the prosecutor did not correct the judge when Hunter was told he could appeal. Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh explored whether the government "forfeited" its right to enforce the waiver by failing to speak up in the courtroom.

All episodes of Oral Arguments – The Supreme Court of the United States

Settings

Display

Language

Decides which stations you see first on the home page.

History

Recently played stations and episodes and your latest searches are only stored in this browser.

Notifications

A short notice when a podcast you follow has a new episode. Turn off single podcasts with the bell on their page.

Account

Save favorites – in the app and on the website.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Open search
Space
Play or pause
← →
In the player: back 15 s, forward 30 s (episodes) · in a row: next tile
↑ ↓
In a row: target within the tile
Home / End
In a row: first or last tile
Esc
Close window or menu
?
This overview
Now playing

Go to station page

Play next

    Add episodes with “Play next” – they play after the current episode.