Skip to content

Why Presidents Can Pick Supreme Court Justices — But Can’t Control Them (Episode 19)

October 10, 2026 · 32 min

Show notes

A president gets to nominate a Supreme Court justice. The Senate confirms them. And then something remarkable happens: the justice never has to answer to that president again.

Donald Trump has publicly expressed frustration with Supreme Court justices he appointed after they ruled against positions he supported. But presidential disappointment with “their” justices is hardly new.

More than a century ago, Theodore Roosevelt was furious when his own appointee, Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., went against him in one of the great trust-busting battles of the Progressive Era. Dwight Eisenhower would later regret two of the most consequential appointments of his presidency. Richard Nixon discovered that even a Court reshaped by Republican presidents could ultimately help bring down a Republican president.

In this episode of The Roger Retrospective, we travel from Teddy Roosevelt to Eisenhower, Nixon and Trump to explore one of the ingenious—and occasionally infuriating—features of the American constitutional system: presidents choose Supreme Court justices, but once those justices put on the robe, the president loses control.

And that may be exactly what the Founders intended.

Today’s world, through the lens of history.

All episodes of Roger Retrospective

Settings

Display

Language

Decides which stations you see first on the home page.

History

Recently played stations and episodes and your latest searches are only stored in this browser.

Notifications

A short notice when a podcast you follow has a new episode. Turn off single podcasts with the bell on their page.

Account

Save favorites – in the app and on the website.

Keyboard shortcuts

/
Open search
Space
Play or pause
← →
In the player: back 15 s, forward 30 s (episodes) · in a row: next tile
↑ ↓
In a row: target within the tile
Home / End
In a row: first or last tile
Esc
Close window or menu
?
This overview
Now playing

Go to station page

Play next

    Add episodes with “Play next” – they play after the current episode.