
Australian Courts of Appeal (Friday 6 November 2026)
Show notes
Twelve headnoted appellate decisions from four courts in the Court of Appeal edition of Friday 6 November 2026, with the New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia editions of the same roll-up folded in. A Kable challenge the court declined to decide; emails as information, not property, in self-defence; a State that submitted to jurisdiction; liability now and damages later at VCAT; and duress by caveat. An abuse claim, domestic violence offending and a sexual offence are reported as legal doctrine only.
Public Law Desk (opening story).
- Rapid Legal Solutions Pty Ltd v State of Queensland [2026] QCA 227 - a court ordinarily will not decide a constitutional challenge to provisions that do not bear on the party; the s 9 Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) severance presumption yields only to a positive all-or-nothing intention, not reduced effectiveness; severing ss 87ZM and 87ZQ(3)(b) Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 (Qld) leaves Pt 5B's purpose intact. Appeal dismissed with costs; the Kable question not decided (Bond and Doyle JJA, Cooper J; also Friday's Queensland edition). JADE
- Clarkson v Ray White Gladstone [2026] QCA 228 - "residents" in s 75(iv) of the Constitution means natural persons only (Howe binding); s 2C Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) cannot alter the Constitution. Appeal dismissed (Bond and Doyle JJA, Hindman J; also Friday's Queensland edition). JADE
- Parole Board Queensland v James [2026] QCA 226 - exceptional circumstances under s 194(1)(a) Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) must justify more favourable treatment on the release date; a non-retrospective concession is not of itself exceptional (Doyle JA and Hindman J; Bond JA no view). Appeal allowed, the primary judge's orders set aside (Bond and Doyle JJA, Hindman J; also Friday's Queensland edition). JADE
Criminal Law Desk (the self-defence matter is pending; no one identified).
- R v Xerri (a pseudonym) [2026] NSWCCA 183 - on a s 5B Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW) stated case, confined to the facts stated, emails shown only as text on a screen were information, not "property" under s 418(2)(c) Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), and reading them aloud was not "interference". Acquittal quashed and the conviction appeal remitted to the District Court to be determined according to law (N Adams CJ at CL, Cavanagh and Muston JJ; also Friday's New South Wales edition). Nothing is predicted. JADE
- Brooker v R [2026] NSWCCA 181 - where sentencing remarks admit competing interpretations, error is not inferred if the preferable one shows none; a quantity just into the commercial range remains serious. Leave granted, appeal dismissed (Ward ACJ, Dhanji and Yehia JJ; also Friday's New South Wales edition). JADE
- Gatt v R [2026] NSWCCA 182 - rejecting an unchallenged psychologist's opinion without forewarning was procedurally unfair and caused practical injustice under s 5(1)(c). Appeal allowed and resentenced (Roberts J, N Adams CJ at CL agreeing; Dhanji J would have imposed a lesser sentence; also Friday's New South Wales edition). Reported as legal doctrine only. JADE
- Penhaligon v Attorney-General for the State of Queensland [2026] QCA 225 - under the Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act 2003 (Qld) an offence "involving violence" need not have violence as an element; mere physical contact is not enough; violence found by two routes. Appeal dismissed with costs, at the preliminary hearing stage (Boddice and Doyle JJA, Morrison AJA; also Friday's Queensland edition). Reported as legal doctrine only; nothing is predicted. JADE
Practice and Procedure Desk (the Victorian claim is reported as legal doctrine only; its allegations are untested).
- Queensland v Statham (a pseudonym) [2026] VSCA 260 - complete diversity does not attach to the third limb of s 75(iv); s 58 Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) precludes another State's Supreme Court exercising jurisdiction in a contract or tort suit against a State unless it submits (Breavington followed); submission is objective and needs no knowledge of the right; a transfer application invokes jurisdiction. Leave granted, appeal dismissed (Orr P, Walker and Donaghue JJA). JADE
- Bahl Enterprises Pty Ltd v Sikandar [2026] VSCA 261 - under s 78(1) VCAT Act the question is whether it was open to the Tribunal to form the belief; failure to file a defence creates a present disadvantage; s 78(2)(b)(i) permits determining liability with damages to be assessed. Leave to appeal refused (Walker, Richards and Donaghue JJA). JADE
- He v N & G Superannuation Pty Ltd acting as trustee for N & G Superannuation Trust (No 2) [2026] NSWCA 236 - recusal procedure on a multi-member bench; bias must be raised distinctly and promptly; reopening after reserve only in exceptional circumstances (s 64 Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)). Applications refused, motion dismissed with costs (Leeming, Kirk and Ball JJA; also Friday's New South Wales edition). JADE
- Varmedja v Hodoba [2026] NSWSC 1404 - worked example from the synopsis: r 42.21 UCPR security for costs principles apply in probate; an unparticularised incapacity plea suggests a weak case; a heavy candour burden for stultification; stay until security is provided (Scruby J; Friday's New South Wales edition). JADE
Commercial Law Desk.
- He v N & G Superannuation Pty Ltd acting as trustee for N & G Superannuation Trust (No 3) [2026] NSWCA 237 - a caveat and a threat of specific performance in a genuine contractual dispute are not illegitimate pressure on either duress standard; no special disadvantage; no loss proved. Appeal dismissed with costs (Leeming, Kirk and Ball JJA; also Friday's New South Wales edition). JADE
- L & L International Investment Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Arundel Springs East CTS 53560 [2026] QCA 229 - applying Project Blue Sky, a caretaker remuneration review advice not complying with s 132(1) BCCM Act 1997 (Qld) is not a nullity, so QCAT had jurisdiction. Leave to appeal refused with costs (Mullins P, Doyle JA, Freeburn J; also Friday's Queensland edition). JADE
Also on the docket (list only, no outcome stated).
- In the matter of Norvista P4 Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1402 - winding up. JADE
- In the matter of Quasar Constructions (Commercial) Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2026] NSWSC 1408 - joinder. JADE
- The Capital Markets Company Limited v Sommerin (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 1411 - costs. JADE
- KenoGO Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2026] NSWSC 1412 - discovery. JADE
- Wright v The Estate of Hanger [2026] NSWSC 1403 - strike out. JADE
- Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited v The Residents Development Pty Ltd (mgrs and recs apptd) [2026] NSWSC 1410 - default judgment. JADE
- Robot X Limited v Placer Robotics Pty Ltd & Anor (No 3) [2026] NSWSC 1413 - costs. JADE
- State of New South Wales v Mustapha [2026] NSWSC 1406 - interim supervision order (listed only). JADE
- Appwam Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council [2026] NSWLEC 1744 - development consent. JADE
- Abuduhou v Blacktown City Council [2026] NSWLEC 1743 - development consent. JADE
- Golding v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2026] WASC 489 - company registration. JADE
Some matters are still to be decided: the Xerri conviction appeal returns to the District Court, the Statham claim continues in Victoria and its allegations are untested, Penhaligon was decided at a preliminary stage, and the interim supervision order matter is listed only. Anyone facing a charge is presumed innocent; nothing here predicts any outcome.
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.
Chapters (11)
All episodes of The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw