Pretty Scary
- Episodes
- 243
- Released
- daily
- Latest episode
- Oct 27, 2026
About the podcast
True crime, conspiracy theories, ghosts, aliens, and things of that sort. Hosted by comedians Adam Tod Brown, Kari Martin, and Caitlin Cutt. Part of the You Don't Even Like Podcasts Network!
Current theme song courtesy of Sliceberg Slim: https://slicebergslim.bandcamp.com/ Theme song for episodes 1 - 210: "Under a Nightmare" by Pandacetamol - https://unpops.co/3NNigJO Creative Commons License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/
Episodes 243
The Lost Episodes - The Disappearance of Johnny Gosch
Adam and guest co-hosts Andy Sell and Jessica Singer discuss the awfully strange disappearance of an Iowa paperboy in the 1980s. The CNN Article: https://www.cnn.com/interactive/2023/12/us/johnny-gosch-missing-i …
Show notes
Adam and guest co-hosts Andy Sell and Jessica Singer discuss the awfully strange disappearance of an Iowa paperboy in the 1980s.
The CNN Article: https://www.cnn.com/interactive/2023/12/us/johnny-gosch-missing-iowa-boy-cec-cnnphotos/
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Crush
Adam and guest co-host Heather Marulli talk about the Itaewon Halloween crushing disaster by way of the Paramount+ documentary CrushGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here …
Show notes
Adam and guest co-host Heather Marulli talk about the Itaewon Halloween crushing disaster by way of the Paramount+ documentary Crush
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Operation Snow White
n the first of a two-part joint op with the Conspiracy! The Show podcast, Adam welcomes comedians Hana Michels and Kym Kral to discuss a Scientology scheme to infiltrate the American government that worked way …
Show notes
n the first of a two-part joint op with the Conspiracy! The Show podcast, Adam welcomes comedians Hana Michels and Kym Kral to discuss a Scientology scheme to infiltrate the American government that worked way better than you’d expect.
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Phantom Rider
Adam and guest co-host Olivia Haidar discuss the absolutely thrilling conclusion of the Sir No Face documentary trilogy, 2020's Phantom Rider.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here …
Show notes
Adam and guest co-host Olivia Haidar discuss the absolutely thrilling conclusion of the Sir No Face documentary trilogy, 2020's Phantom Rider.
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Do You Believe? Bigfoot, Ghosts, Atlantis, and More!
Adam welcomes special guest Hana Michels for an unscripted chat about Bigfoot, ghosts, Atlantis, the Mothman and so much more! Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here …
Show notes
Adam welcomes special guest Hana Michels for an unscripted chat about Bigfoot, ghosts, Atlantis, the Mothman and so much more!
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - The Blackout Experiments
Adam and guest co-host Andy Sell review the 2016 documentary The Blackout Experiment, which covers the notorious "immersive horror experience" known as Blackout.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks …
Show notes
Adam and guest co-host Andy Sell review the 2016 documentary The Blackout Experiment, which covers the notorious "immersive horror experience" known as Blackout.
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - The Legend of Boggy Creek
Adam and special guest co-host Olivia Haidar review the seminal 1972 "documentary" The Legend of Boggy Creek.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Possessed Pets Pt. 2: Vincent and Nitro
Adam and Kari recap the third and fourth episodes of Eli Roth Presents: My Possessed PetGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Roommate: Not In My House
Adam and special guest Kym Kral recap the season one finale of Investigation Discovery's Fear Thy RoommateGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Scream: The True Story
Adam and Cindy discuss a documentary about Danny Rolling, aka the Gainesville Ripper, the killer who (very loosely) inspired the horror movie ScreamGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here …
Show notes
Adam and Cindy discuss a documentary about Danny Rolling, aka the Gainesville Ripper, the killer who (very loosely) inspired the horror movie Scream
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Zak Bagans Wrote A Movie
Adam and Kari review the Travel Channel film "Haunted Museum: 3 Ring Inferno." It's a horror movie written by Ghost Adventures host Zak Bagans!Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here …
Show notes
Adam and Kari review the Travel Channel film "Haunted Museum: 3 Ring Inferno." It's a horror movie written by Ghost Adventures host Zak Bagans!
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Last Seen Walking
Adam and Cindy discuss an episode of ABC's 20/20 about a cold case that proves our justice system is irreparably broken.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Who Do You Believe? What The Sisters Saw
Adam and Cindy recap an episode of the ABC show Who Do You Believe? This episode covers the murder of a man named Steven Beard, allegedly at the hands of his wife, Celeste. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True …
Show notes
Adam and Cindy recap an episode of the ABC show Who Do You Believe? This episode covers the murder of a man named Steven Beard, allegedly at the hands of his wife, Celeste.
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Neighbor: Feud On the Frontier
Adam and Kari recap what IMDB claims is the highest rated episode ever of the Investigation Discovery series Fear Thy Neighbor.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here …
Show notes
Adam and Kari recap what IMDB claims is the highest rated episode ever of the Investigation Discovery series Fear Thy Neighbor.
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Joyce Carol Vincent
Adam and Cindy review the documentary "Dreams of a Life", which tells the story of Joyce Carol Vincent, a 30-something British woman who went missing for three years inside her own apartment.The documentary …
Show notes
Adam and Cindy review the documentary "Dreams of a Life", which tells the story of Joyce Carol Vincent, a 30-something British woman who went missing for three years inside her own apartment.
The documentary: https://www.amazon.com/Dreams-Life-Zawe-Ashton/dp/B00B0I5TYS
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - Ghost Adventures: Pasadena Ritual House
Adam and Caitlin recap an episode of television that happened right in their own backyard sorta! Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Ghost Adventures: The Comedy Store
Adam and Kari recap an unexpectedly touching episode the Travel Channel series Ghost AdventuresGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Neighbor: Red Picket Fences
Adam and Kari recap the second episode of the Investigation Discovery series Fear Thy NeighborGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Fresh (Movie Review)
Adam and Caitlin review the cannibalism-centric horror movie FreshGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Neighbor S1E1
Adam and Kari recap the premiere episode of the Investigation Discovery series Fear Thy Neighbor!Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - The Curse of Robert
Adam and Caitlin review the second movie in the Robert the Doll horror franchise.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Ghost Adventures: Vulture City Pt. 2
Adam and Caitlin visit Zak and company's revisit to Vulture City, Arizona!Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Robert
Adam and Caitlin review the bonkers first installment of the Robert movie franchise.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - The Ghost Train of Ely
Adam and Caitlin recap the first ever episode of Ghost Adventures to take place on a moving train! Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Ghost Adventures: The Curse of Ranch Island
Adam and Caitlin recap an episode of Ghost Adventures that is considered to be one of the best ever!Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Ghost Hunters: Ghosts of Christmas Past
Adam and Caitlin switch gears and recap an episode of that other ghost hunting show because it was the only one that had a Christmas episode they could find. Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks …
Show notes
Adam and Caitlin switch gears and recap an episode of that other ghost hunting show because it was the only one that had a Christmas episode they could find.
Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucksThe Lost Episodes - A Ghost Ruined My Life: Asylum
Adam and Caitlin recap the third episode of Eli Roth Presents: A Ghost Ruined My Life.Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Roommate: Down the Rabbit Hole
Adam and Caitlin recap a highly suspicious episode of the Investigation Discovery series Fear Thy RoommateGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - A Ghost Ruined My Life: Dark Entity
Adam and Caitlin recap the highly awkward and concerning second episode of Eli Roth Presents: A Ghost Ruined My Life"Get Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
The Lost Episodes - Fear Thy Roommate S1E1
Adam and guest co-host Kym Kral recap the debut episode of an Investigation Discovery series about terrible roommatesGet Adam and Kari's new podcast True Crime Sucks here: https://youdontevenlike.com/truecrimesucks
These are the latest 40 of 243 episodes. You’ll find older episodes in the podcast’s feed.
Similar podcasts
More Comedy podcasts
Is this your podcast?
Confirm it with an entry in your feed: you get a code here, add it as podcast:txt to the channel of your feed, and we check it. Your podcast is then shown as “verified” on SoundNode.