To All The Rom Coms We’ve Loved Before
- Episodes
- 237
- Released
- weekly
- Latest episode
- Oct 28, 2026
About the podcast
Christina Archer & Sarah Kelley discuss all of their most loved (and most hated) rom coms.
Episodes 237
THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON (2009)
The Twilight Saga: New Moon, otherwise known as Mormon Edging.We took it to Spooky Cozy Vampire Werewolf Season because we needed this in our (damned) souls!!!! If you also remember when Jacob leaps over the …
Show notes
The Twilight Saga: New Moon, otherwise known as Mormon Edging.
We took it to Spooky Cozy Vampire Werewolf Season because we needed this in our (damned) souls!!!! If you also remember when Jacob leaps over the bannister and has flippy legs please comment and let me know because it has stuck with me for years.
Edward and Bella are FREAKS! JUSTICE FOR JACOB!!!!
Bella, where the hell have you been, loca?!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
VAMPS (2012)
If you haven’t watched this movie, you need to get your f***ing a** up and WORK. Rat-forward, vampire-forward rom coms DO exist and they are INSANE! For an Amy Heckerling movie about vampire romance, we make a …
Show notes
If you haven’t watched this movie, you need to get your f***ing a** up and WORK. Rat-forward, vampire-forward rom coms DO exist and they are INSANE! For an Amy Heckerling movie about vampire romance, we make a surprising amount of jokes about The Crucible and Edgar Allen Poe (separately).
Begging you to watch this and lmk what you think.
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
THE LOVE HYPOTHESIS (2026)
Ali Hazelwood, the woman you are! We are absolutely hyped to be covering The Love Hypothesis (2026), starring Lili Reinhart, Tom Bateman, and NO rainbow socks! (IYKYK…we will get into it). This adaptation was …
Show notes
Ali Hazelwood, the woman you are! We are absolutely hyped to be covering The Love Hypothesis (2026), starring Lili Reinhart, Tom Bateman, and NO rainbow socks! (IYKYK…we will get into it). This adaptation was for booktok and for that we thank you.
Listen on for our raves and rants!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
JOYFUL NOISE (2012)
We’re continuing our religious streak with Joyful Noise (2012), starring Dolly Parton, Queen Latifah, and Keke Palmer! This was Sarah’s sister’s hyperfixation movie growing up, but other than that it feels like …
Show notes
We’re continuing our religious streak with Joyful Noise (2012), starring Dolly Parton, Queen Latifah, and Keke Palmer! This was Sarah’s sister’s hyperfixation movie growing up, but other than that it feels like this exists in an alternate timeline. Whichever timeline we’re in, thank God we have a movie with these three legends SANGIN’ TOGETHER!!!!
We are Double-Dolly-ing and covering 9 to 5 on the Patreon next week, so subscribe and Double-Dolly with us :-)
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
PRACTICAL MAGIC 2 (2026)
Sandy & Nicole are back!!!!! We love our original Practical Magic gals no matter how bad the sequel is! We have MANY thoughts, so stick with us as we go through them beat by beat.We are dying to know your …
Show notes
Sandy & Nicole are back!!!!! We love our original Practical Magic gals no matter how bad the sequel is! We have MANY thoughts, so stick with us as we go through them beat by beat.
We are dying to know your thoughts, so leave us a comment!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
SISTER ACT (1992)
We know this isnt a rom com (except for the love of god maybe?), but it was originally a Patreon episode for (Catholic) Sarah’s (Catholic) birthday week. Alas, we had to pivot (PIVOT!) due to a family …
Show notes
We know this isnt a rom com (except for the love of god maybe?), but it was originally a Patreon episode for (Catholic) Sarah’s (Catholic) birthday week. Alas, we had to pivot (PIVOT!) due to a family emergency.
Please enjoy us being a little edgier than we typically are on Main!!
If you're interested in the movie Christina talks about at the end it's The Magdalene Sisters (2002) and it is tragic and also they aren't nuns...I hadn't seen it in 6 years so I got everything wrong except the really bad stuff!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
THE BIRDCAGE (1996)
Happy (Catholic) Birthday to our very own (Catholic) Sarah!!!!!!!!!!!!! To celebrate 30 years of Sarah Sanchez Kelley we must also celebrate 30 years of The Birdcage (1996), starring Robin Williams & Nathan …
Show notes
Happy (Catholic) Birthday to our very own (Catholic) Sarah!!!!!!!!!!!!! To celebrate 30 years of Sarah Sanchez Kelley we must also celebrate 30 years of The Birdcage (1996), starring Robin Williams & Nathan Lane. YAY FOR GAY JOY!!!!!!
Yes, we realize that Sarah is Robin Williams and Christina is Nathan Lane. It simply is what it is.
I stopped drinking red wine because of the TANNINS!
patreon.com/toalltheromcoms (Sister Act will be out tmr!)
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
EASY A (2010)
Let’s be honest, we are still trying to ride the high of Burlesque, so we had to choose a movie featuring Stanley Tucci and James The Vampire From Twilight: Easy A! Directed by Will Gluck (of current One Night …
Show notes
Let’s be honest, we are still trying to ride the high of Burlesque, so we had to choose a movie featuring Stanley Tucci and James The Vampire From Twilight: Easy A! Directed by Will Gluck (of current One Night Only disdain/praise) and starring OSCAR WINNER EMMA STONE.
Some potential titles for our spinoff podcast:
Christina & Sarah: Searching For Tucci
Under The Tucci Sun
Searching for Ojai with Stanley Tucci
Tina and The Tuc’
This week on Patreon...CAMP ROCK 2!!!!!
(Shane from The L Word walked so Joe Jonas could run)
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
BURLESQUE (2010)
We are nothing if not a Cher Forward Chair Backward podcast!!!! If you are in need of healing (via the power of dance, Cher, and growl-singing) then WATCH THIS MOVIE! Burlesque (2010) brings us terrible …
Show notes
We are nothing if not a Cher Forward Chair Backward podcast!!!! If you are in need of healing (via the power of dance, Cher, and growl-singing) then WATCH THIS MOVIE! Burlesque (2010) brings us terrible dancing, absolutely insane vocals, and Stanley Tucci repeatedly throwing outfits at a woman as he walks through a closet.
Only talk to us if you are Cher Forward, Chair Backward!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
ONE NIGHT ONLY (2026)
It's the Sex Purge Movie!Buckle up, Christina finally learned how to properly say she “suspends her disbelief” and she won’t stop saying it! The movie on everyone’s lips (except for The Odyssey and Spiderman …
Show notes
It's the Sex Purge Movie!
Buckle up, Christina finally learned how to properly say she “suspends her disbelief” and she won’t stop saying it! The movie on everyone’s lips (except for The Odyssey and Spiderman: Brand New Day) is finally here and very political without actually having a stance?!
A tragic world underlies this rom com and we fear that’s just not the vibe. Maybe we should give Will Gluck one night a year to make a rom com and see what happens.
What would you make legal for one night a year?
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
MAMMA MIA! HERE WE GO AGAIN (2018)
MASTS UP! The Odyssey for Girls, Gays, and Greeks is here! (Who is Odysseus in this retelling? Colin Firth? Amanda Seyfried? Cher?) We thought the only appropriate way to bring us back into the rom-com state of …
Show notes
MASTS UP! The Odyssey for Girls, Gays, and Greeks is here! (Who is Odysseus in this retelling? Colin Firth? Amanda Seyfried? Cher?) We thought the only appropriate way to bring us back into the rom-com state of mind was to put us on an island and sing ABBA!
On a serious note, we are so thrilled to be back. We've missed you, our precious rom-com loving community, and we are so ready to go absolutely feral for the fall rom com season!
If you love our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon at www.patreon.com/toalltheromcoms. We (mostly) put out an extra episode each week and also conversational minisodes here and there. You also get access to pictures of Christina's terrible haircut.
Otherwise, talk to us here:
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
Summer Rewind: CAMP ROCK (2008)
Hello hotties & baddies!After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more …
Show notes
Hello hotties & baddies!
After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more stuff, don't you worry!
Get your Disney knees ready, it's time to revisit CAMP ROCK (2008)
joe jonas moan compilations here:
patreon.com/toalltheromcoms
ig: @romcomsweveloved
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
www.toalltheromcoms.com
Summer Rewind: FOOL'S GOLD (2008)
Hello hotties & baddies!After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more …
Show notes
Hello hotties & baddies!
After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more stuff, don't you worry!
In the meantime, enjoy this throwback episode from 2023 where we chat FOOL'S GOLD (2008) Tune in to hear us discuss adventure sandals, scuba arms, and more!
alright alright alright
patreon.com/toalltheromcoms
ig: @romcomsweveloved
Summer Rewind: MAMMA MIA! (2008)
Hello hotties & baddies!After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more …
Show notes
Hello hotties & baddies!
After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more stuff, don't you worry!
In the meantime, enjoy this throwback to MAMMA MIA! Summer's greatest musical rom com. Hear Christina's award-winning Christine Baranski impression and lots of ABBA.
Does your mother know that you're out??
patreon.com/toalltheromcoms
ig: @romcomsweveloved
Summer Rewind: UNDER THE TUSCAN SUN (2003)
Hello hotties & baddies!After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more …
Show notes
Hello hotties & baddies!
After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more stuff, don't you worry!
In the meantime, enjoy this discussion about women jumping into Italian fountains, Diane Lane's teeth, and most importantly: the origin of How We Became a Catholic Podcast.
tell us about your dream italian villa
patreon.com/toalltheromcoms
ig: @romcomsweveloved
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
Summer Rewind: HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL 2 (2007)
Hello hotties & baddies!After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more …
Show notes
Hello hotties & baddies!
After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more stuff, don't you worry!
In the meantime, here's a throwback episode from 2025: HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL 2! Troy learns about class consciousness, Ryan & Chad have a gay subplot, and Christina still wants justice for Sharpay.
patreon.com/toalltheromcoms
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
Summer Rewind: AQUAMARINE (2006)
Hello hotties & baddies!After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more …
Show notes
Hello hotties & baddies!
After recording non-stop for 2.5 years, we're taking a summer break! Thank you in advance for letting us spend some time getting tan & watching Love Island. We'll return soon with more stuff, don't you worry!
In the meantime, here's a throwback episode from 2024: Aquamarine! We're talking Jojo, Florida, and most importantly, MERMAIDS!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
OFFICE ROMANCE (2026)
Jenny from the block and Roy Kent? The power couple I never knew I needed. This movie has thrilled us into oblivion and we may simply never recover! Brett Goldstein and Jennifer Lopez, NEVER STOP ROM COMMING!I …
Show notes
Jenny from the block and Roy Kent? The power couple I never knew I needed. This movie has thrilled us into oblivion and we may simply never recover! Brett Goldstein and Jennifer Lopez, NEVER STOP ROM COMMING!
I have a fetish for powerful women with perfect bums.
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
YOU, ALWAYS (2025)
WARNING!!! This movie is BAD!!!!! Adrian Grenier…we hated you in The Devil Wears Prada (2006), and unfortunately we hate you in You, Always (2025) too. We saw the words “Australian romantic comedy” and prepared …
Show notes
WARNING!!! This movie is BAD!!!!! Adrian Grenier…we hated you in The Devil Wears Prada (2006), and unfortunately we hate you in You, Always (2025) too. We saw the words “Australian romantic comedy” and prepared for the best. Alas, here we are.
Australians, we are so sorry. Is there important Australian film we are missing??? Surely this movie was sabotaged by local Aussies!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA 2 (2026)
GIRD YOUR LOINS!!!!!!!! Miranda is BACK and messier than ever for The Devil Wears Prada 2 (2026)! We've got Meryl Streep, Stanley Tucci, Anne Hathaway, and Emily Blunt -- an incredible llineup -- back together …
Show notes
GIRD YOUR LOINS!!!!!!!! Miranda is BACK and messier than ever for The Devil Wears Prada 2 (2026)! We've got Meryl Streep, Stanley Tucci, Anne Hathaway, and Emily Blunt -- an incredible llineup -- back together to show us the future of Runway and the downfall of capitalism (not really but a girl can dream).
Fav outfits? Thoughts on the (many, many) ties? Thoughts on the new folks? LET US KNOW!!!!!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA (2006)
Did you fall down and smack your little head on the pavement? Because I did, and that's why this episode is late!!! Never fear, everything is back under control, and every time I think I won't get an episode …
Show notes
Did you fall down and smack your little head on the pavement? Because I did, and that's why this episode is late!!! Never fear, everything is back under control, and every time I think I won't get an episode out, I just eat a cube of cheese!
Do we think The Mentalist is creepy or hot or kind of both in this?
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
YOU, ME, & TUSCANY (2026)
Catch me angrily drinking an Aperol Spritz in an Italian courtyard this summer while my brother-cousin makes out with his ex-fiance in front of his fake fiance! You, Me, & Tuscany (2026) did us an absolute …
Show notes
Catch me angrily drinking an Aperol Spritz in an Italian courtyard this summer while my brother-cousin makes out with his ex-fiance in front of his fake fiance!
You, Me, & Tuscany (2026) did us an absolute solid by staying true to the genre and bringing us joy and an absolutely unhinged main character (looking at you, Little Mermaid). Give us more Halle Bailey and Regé-Jean Page!!!!
What was your favorite scene (and why was it the shirtless vineyard moment)?
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
XO, KITTY S3, EP1-4 (2026)
Sister Kitty Song-Covey is BACK and ready to cause chaos, never study, and lock lips with Minho!!!!! We have been absolutely desperate for this season and it's finally time. Give us romance! Gay revenge! Korean …
Show notes
Sister Kitty Song-Covey is BACK and ready to cause chaos, never study, and lock lips with Minho!!!!! We have been absolutely desperate for this season and it's finally time.
Give us romance! Gay revenge! Korean Tourism! Evil Bisexual Faceoff Real World Road Rules Challenge! All of the above!!!!
Also -- serious thank you for sticking with us during this chaotic time in our own lives. Much like Kitty, it feels like we are flying by the seat of our pants sometimes, but we are doing our best to stay on track and get these episodes out. Love ya for real xoxo, Tina & Sarah
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
A CINDERELLA STORY (2004)
Hello friends! Sarah and Christina have both been out of town and having life events, so this is a sneaky Patreon episode from early 2026. So, if you're here for some extra giggles, digressions, and cursing …
Show notes
Hello friends! Sarah and Christina have both been out of town and having life events, so this is a sneaky Patreon episode from early 2026. So, if you're here for some extra giggles, digressions, and cursing (sorry), you'll probably like this!
Synopsis starts at 05:44 if you can't deal with the banter today.
Also, a note from Sarah: "I'm so sorry I think I called her Regina Hall instead of Regina King, I know my mistake and that's totally my bad lmao"
Subscribe to our Patreon! We are covering XO Kitty Season 3 and we are HYPED!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
LITTLE ITALY (2018)
From Star Wars to Little Italy, Hayden Christensen is the most important man in America (Canada?). There’s nothing we here at To All The Rom Coms We’ve Loved Before love more than a rom com featuring Italians …
Show notes
From Star Wars to Little Italy, Hayden Christensen is the most important man in America (Canada?). There’s nothing we here at To All The Rom Coms We’ve Loved Before love more than a rom com featuring Italians and Emma Roberts, so Little Italy (2018) was an absolute treat.
What's your controversial pizza topping take?
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
MORNING GLORY (2010)
Rachel McAdams, Diane Keaton, and Harrison Ford in a rom com? Iconic! Oh, and also that guy from all those hauntings in Connecticut. Talk to us!!!!!!patreon.com/toalltheromcoms[email protected]ig: …
Show notes
Rachel McAdams, Diane Keaton, and Harrison Ford in a rom com? Iconic! Oh, and also that guy from all those hauntings in Connecticut.
Talk to us!!!!!!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
STARTER FOR 10 (2006)
BREAKING NEWS:1. Christina cannot identify the Big Dipper2. She's now an auntie! Everyone say congrats!This episode we're chatting STARTER FOR 10 (2006)! Tune in to hear us discuss hometown hero James McAvoy …
Show notes
BREAKING NEWS:
1. Christina cannot identify the Big Dipper
2. She's now an auntie! Everyone say congrats!
This episode we're chatting STARTER FOR 10 (2006)! Tune in to hear us discuss hometown hero James McAvoy, Pirates of Penzance, and Christina's beef with trivia.
Subscribe to our patreon for pictures of cats!!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
LICENSE TO WED (2007)
Breaking couples up and hijacking their trip to Jamaica? Our dream job. And he knows that.Robin Williams, light of our lives, we needed you in a rom com to soothe our tired souls! And because it's 2007 -- John …
Show notes
Breaking couples up and hijacking their trip to Jamaica? Our dream job. And he knows that.
Robin Williams, light of our lives, we needed you in a rom com to soothe our tired souls! And because it's 2007 -- John Krasinski and The Mandiest Moore!
Subscribe to our patreon for a handmade card!!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
THIS MEANS WAR (2012)
Chris Pine, Tom Hardy, and Reese Witherspoon in a rom com? Sounds amazing, but actually got us riled up about violations of privacy and the misuse of government funds! 2012 was a weird time, and it shows in …
Show notes
Chris Pine, Tom Hardy, and Reese Witherspoon in a rom com? Sounds amazing, but actually got us riled up about violations of privacy and the misuse of government funds! 2012 was a weird time, and it shows in This Means War (2012).
Subscribe to our patreon!!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
SAVED! (2004)
Just like Mandy Moore, we are FILLED with Christ's love!!!!!! Welcome to our most sacreligious episode to date, Saved! (2004). This movie has an absolutely stacked cast, continuous and hilarious jokes, and …
Show notes
Just like Mandy Moore, we are FILLED with Christ's love!!!!!! Welcome to our most sacreligious episode to date, Saved! (2004). This movie has an absolutely stacked cast, continuous and hilarious jokes, and, surprisingly, one of the happiest endings in a teen pregnancy movie we've ever seen.
Subscribe to our Patreon for a handmade card (& stickers)!
tiktok: @romcomsweveloved
These are the latest 40 of 237 episodes. You’ll find older episodes in the podcast’s feed.
Similar podcasts
More TV & Film podcasts
Is this your podcast?
Confirm it with an entry in your feed: you get a code here, add it as podcast:txt to the channel of your feed, and we check it. Your podcast is then shown as “verified” on SoundNode.